Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2512 of 10 November 2026 imposing provisional anti-dumping duties on imports of certain acrylic esters originating in the People’s Republic of China, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Republic of South Africa and the United States of America
Preamble 1
THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,
Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,
Having regard to Regulation (EU) 2016/1036 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2016 on protection against dumped imports from countries not members of the European Union ( 1 ) (‘the basic Regulation’), and in particular Article 7 thereof,
After consulting the Member States,
Whereas:
1. PROCEDURE
1.1. Initiation
HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:
recital 1recital 1
(1) On 12 March 2026, the European Commission (‘the Commission’) initiated an anti-dumping investigation into imports of certain acrylic esters originating in the People’s Republic of China (‘China’ or ‘the PRC’), the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (‘Saudi Arabia’), the Republic of South Africa (‘South Africa’) and the United States of America (‘the USA’), known together as ‘the countries concerned’ pursuant to Article 5 of the basic Regulation.
recital 2recital 2
(2) This followed a complaint lodged on 28 January 2026 by the Consortium for certain acrylic esters (‘the complainant’ or ‘the complainants’) on behalf of the Union industry within the meaning of Article 5(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 3recital 3
(3) The initiation was justified by the evidence of both dumping and resulting material injury provided in the complaint, as set out in the Notice of Initiation in the Official Journal of the European Union ( 2 ) (‘the Notice of Initiation’).
recital 4recital 4
1.2. Registration
(4) The Commission made imports of the product concerned subject to registration by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1085 ( 3 ) (‘the registration Regulation’).
recital 5recital 5
1.3. Interested parties
(5) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission invited interested parties to participate in the investigation. Specifically, it notified the complainant, known Union producers, exporting producers, the authorities of the countries concerned and other known stakeholders - including importers, suppliers, users, and trade associations. All interested parties were given the opportunity to comment on the initiation and to request a hearing with the Commission or the Hearing Officer in trade proceedings.
recital 6recital 6
(6) On 18 March 2026 Arkema Inc (a producer in the United States of America) made a request to be an interested party. This request was not accepted as the company did not export the product concerned to the Union during the investigation period.
recital 7recital 7
(7) On 19 March 2026 Taixing Sunke Chemicals Co., Ltd. (a producer in China) made a request to be an interested party. Again, this request was not accepted as the company did not export the product concerned to the Union during the investigation period.
recital 8recital 8
(8) On 25 March 2026 and 3 April 2026, Arkema Inc. and Taixing Sunke Chemicals Co. Ltd requested the intervention of the Hearing Officer regarding the Commission’s decision to reject their requests to be interested parties, which was because both companies did not export the product concerned to the Union during the investigation period. Both entities are related to the Union producer Arkema France.
recital 9recital 9
(9) The Hearing Officer suggested to both companies that they should provide evidence of all the elements needed to show that the companies were genuinely affected by the outcome of the case. The companies did provide further evidence. However, the Commission decided that such elements were not considered relevant and the request was therefore denied.
recital 10recital 10
(10) Rather, on 15 July 2026 the services replied to both companies noting that as part of the Arkema Group both companies could make comments in this investigation and access the file via Arkema France.
recital 11recital 11
(11) The Hearing Officer concluded that it appeared a matter of internal coordination within the Arkema Group how to best participate in the investigation and protect its procedural rights accordingly.
recital 12recital 12
1.4. Comments on initiation
(12) The Saudi General Authority for Foreign Trade (‘GAFT’), Sasol South Africa Limited (‘Sasol’) and Organik Kimya Netherlands BV (‘Organik’) submitted that the level of confidentiality applied to the complaint was excessive, preventing them from exercising their right of defence and from understanding the claims raised in the complaint.
recital 13recital 13
(13) Sasol argued specifically that there was an absence of good cause for confidentiality and that the macro- and micro-injury indicators provided in ranges or indexed form comprised aggregated data that did not specifically target any individual Union producer and therefore should have been disclosed.
recital 14recital 14
(14) GAFT further submitted that the complaint failed to disclose important information, in particular with respect to normal value, export price, injury analysis and even the names of the complainants.
recital 15recital 15
(15) First, the Commission found that the information provided in the open version of the complaint permitted a reasonable understanding of the substance of the information submitted in line with Article 19(2) of the basic Regulation, including on issues such as normal value, export price and injury analysis.
recital 16recital 16
(16) Second, regarding the confidential treatment of the complainants’ identity, it was noted that the disclosure of their names would have a significantly adverse effect on them, given the risks of retaliation. In any event, non-disclosure of the company names behind the complaint did not affect the ability of interested parties to comment meaningfully on the substance of the complaint.
recital 17recital 17
(17) Third, the Commission accepted aggregated ranges and indexed data for the micro-economic and macro-economic indicators in view of the limited number of Union producers. Nevertheless, the ranges and indexes provided sufficient detail to permit an assessment of the trends and developments of all the injury indicators, thereby ensuring that the rights of defence of interested parties are fully respected.
recital 18recital 18
(18) The fact that in the present case, GAFT, Sasol as well as Organik were able to submit detailed observations, including on the information provided in a non-confidential, indexed or aggregated form, further demonstrated that the parties were able to comment effectively on the complaint. The arguments of the parties were therefore rejected.
recital 19recital 19
(19) Furthermore, the Chinese exporter Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd (‘Pinghu Petro’) claimed that the complainant did not sufficiently demonstrate that it was representative of the Union industry in accordance with Article 5(4) of the basic Regulation. The party argued that the complainant provided no evidence that the 50 % threshold laid down in Article 5(4) of the basic Regulation has been met.
recital 20recital 20
(20) As part of the statutory analysis of the complaint, the Commission services have carried out a standing examination before initiation. For this purpose, all Union producers known to the Commission have been contacted before initiation and taken into consideration in the calculation of the degree of support. The outcome of the standing exercise showed that the complaint was lodged by or on behalf of the Union industry in line with Article 5(4) of the basic Regulation and that the relevant thresholds set out in the said Article have been met.
recital 21recital 21
(21) The 50 % threshold disputed by Pinghu Petro is only assessed after the complaint has been lodged and immediately prior to the initiation. Consequently, and contrary to Pinghu Petro’s claim, the complainant was not in the position to assess reliably the level of support for the complaint, nor was it legally required to do so. It was further recalled that a note for the file on standing was included in the open file and confirmed that standing has been established before initiation, as the replies to the standing exercise provided by the individual Union producers (despite being provided in ranges) indicated that also the 50 % threshold prescribed by Article 5(4) of the basic Regulation was met. Pinghu Petro’s claim was therefore dismissed.
recital 22recital 22
(22) According to GAFT, the Commission violated Article 5.3 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement (‘ADA’) in that it initiated the investigation on the basis of an incomplete and legally deficient complaint, which omitted several mandatory injury factors listed in Article 3.4 of ADA from its analysis (e.g. productivity, cash flow, wages, growth).
recital 23recital 23
(23) First, the legal standard of evidence required for a complaint under Article 5 of the basic Regulation (corresponding to Article 5 of ADA) makes it clear that the quantity and quality of information in the complaint is not the same as the one on which the Commission bases its findings during an investigation. In fact, the complaint needs to include sufficient evidence of dumping, injury and a causal link which is reasonably available to the complainant (which was the case here).
recital 24recital 24
(24) Further to that, Article 5 of the basic Regulation does not require that all injury factors mentioned in Article 3(5) (equivalent to Article 3.4 of ADA) are analysed or show deterioration to establish evidence of material injury sufficient to initiate an investigation.
recital 25recital 25
(25) Indeed, the wording of Article 5(2) of the basic Regulation states that the complaint must contain information on changes in the volume of the allegedly dumped imports, the effect of those imports on prices of the like product on the Union market and the consequent impact of the imports on the Union industry, as demonstrated by relevant (but not necessarily all) factors and indices having a bearing on the state of the Union industry, such as those listed in Articles 3(3) and 3(5) of the basic Regulation. Therefore, GAFT’s claim was dismissed.
recital 26recital 26
1.5. Sampling
(26) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission stated that it might sample interested parties in accordance with Article 17 of the basic Regulation.
recital 27recital 27
Sampling of Union producers
(27) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission informed parties that it had provisionally selected a sample of three Union producers based on production and sales quantities. The sampled Union producers accounted for over 80% of the total Union production.
recital 28recital 28
(28) The Commission invited interested parties to comment on the provisional sample. No comments were received and the definitive sample was found to be representative of the Union industry.
recital 29recital 29
Sampling of unrelated importers
(29) To determine if sampling was necessary, the Commission asked unrelated importers to provide the information specified in the Notice of Initiation.
recital 30recital 30
(30) As only two importers provided the requested information, the Commission decided that sampling was not necessary.
recital 31recital 31
Sampling of exporting producers
(31) To determine if sampling was necessary, the Commission asked all exporting producers in the countries concerned to provide the information specified in the Notice of Initiation. In addition, the Commission asked the Missions of the countries concerned to identify and/or contact other exporting producers that could be interested in participating in the investigation.
recital 32recital 32
(32) The Commission received five replies from Chinese exporting producers, one reply from Saudi Arabia, one reply from South Africa and two replies from exporting producers in the USA. They provided the requested information and agreed to be included in the sample. One producer from the USA did not export the product concerned during the investigation period and its sampling reply was therefore disregarded.
recital 33recital 33
(33) In view of the low number of replies from Saudi Arabia, South Africa and the USA, the Commission decided that sampling was not necessary. Consequently, all exporting producers that came forward from these countries were invited to submit a questionnaire reply.
recital 34recital 34
(34) Given the number of replies from Chinese exporting producers, and in accordance with Article 17(1) of the basic Regulation, the Commission selected a sample of two exporting producers.
recital 35recital 35
(35) This selection was based on the largest representative volume of exports to the Union that could reasonably be investigated within the time available. In accordance with Article 17(2) of the basic Regulation, the Commission consulted all known exporting producers and the authorities of China on the selection. The Commission did not receive any comments on the sample.
recital 36recital 36
1.6. Questionnaire replies and verification visits
(36) The Commission sent a questionnaire concerning the existence in China of significant distortions within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation to the Government of the People’s Republic of China (‘GOC’).
recital 37recital 37
(37) The Commission sent questionnaires to the sampled Union producers, sampled exporting producers in China, known exporting producers in Saudi Arabia, USA and South Africa, known importers and users. On the date of initiation, the Commission made the same questionnaires available online ( 4 ) . After the deadline to return the completed questionnaire, the Saudi exporting producer, SAMCO, informed the Commission that it would not be submitting a reply and provided reasons for its non-cooperation. On 27 April 2026, the Commission sent a letter to SAMCO informing them of its intention to apply Article 18 of the basic Regulation. No reply was received.
recital 38recital 38
(38) The Commission sought and verified all the information deemed necessary for a provisional determination of dumping, resulting injury and Union interest. Verification visits pursuant to Article 16 of the basic Regulation were carried out at the premises of the following companies: Union producers: — Synthomer a.s., Sokolov, Czech Republic (‘Synthomer’); — BASF SE, Ludwigshafen, Germany (‘BASF’); — Arkema France SA, Carling, France (‘Arkema’); Exporting producer in USA: — Rohm and Haas Texas Inc, Midland and Deer Park, USA, Rohm and Haas Chemical LLC, Midland, USA, and Union Carbide Corporation, Midland and New Orleans, USA (‘Dow US’); Exporting producers in China: — Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd, Pinghu, China (‘Pinghu Petro’); — Shanghai Huayi New Material Co., Ltd, Shanghai, China (‘Huayi’); Exporting producer in South Africa: — Sasol South Africa Limited, Johannesburg, South Africa (‘Sasol’); Related importers: — Dow Europe GmbH, Switzerland (Dow Europe); — Sasol Chemie Hamburg, Germany.
recital 39recital 39
1.7. Investigation period and period considered
(39) The investigation of dumping and injury covered the period from 1 January 2025 to 31 December 2025 (‘the investigation period’ or ‘IP’). The examination of trends relevant for the assessment of injury covered the period from 1 January 2022 to the end of the investigation period (‘the period considered’).
recital 40recital 40
2. PRODUCT UNDER INVESTIGATION, PRODUCT CONCERNED AND LIKE PRODUCT
2.1. Product under investigation
(40) The ‘product under investigation’ is certain acrylic esters (‘AE’) which are butyl acrylate (‘BA’) and 2-ethylhexyl acrylate (‘2EHA’). BA is currently falling under Chemical Abstracts Service number (‘CAS RN’) 141-32-2 and Customs Union and Statistics Code (‘CUS’) 0012413-0, and 2EHA is currently falling under CAS RN 103-11-7 and CUS 0017228-1.
recital 41recital 41
(41) The product scope excludes other essential acrylates like Ethyl Acrylate (EA) or Methyl Acrylate (MA) and specialty acrylates like Alkyl acrylates, Hydroxy-alkyl acrylates or Dialkylaminoethylacrylates.
recital 42recital 42
(42) BA and 2EHA are considered as one homogenous single product as they are both esters made from the same raw material (in majority propylene) and their production methods and areas of application are almost identical. Propylene is the main raw material used in the production of acrylic esters (accounting for around 50 % of the total production costs).
recital 43recital 43
(43) Acrylic esters impart colour stability and clarity, heat and ageing resistance, weather resistance, low temperature flexibility and/or other qualities to the polymeric materials in which they are used.
recital 44recital 44
(44) The main end uses of these polymers include the production of coatings, adhesives and sealants, paper, polymer additives, textiles, and inks. BA’s applications are larger than those of 2EHA. However, they both remain present on the same market of soft monomers which differ in terms of technical properties and applications from those of MA and EA.
recital 45recital 45
(45) BA and 2EHA are substitutable in many applications but cannot be substituted with MA/EA because of the different technical properties and uses.
recital 46recital 46
2.2. Product concerned
(46) The ‘product concerned’ is the product under investigation originating in the People’s Republic of China, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Republic of South Africa, and the United States of America (‘the countries concerned’), currently classified under CN code ex 2916 12 00 (TARIC code 2916 12 00 15).
recital 47recital 47
2.3. Like product
(47) The investigation showed that the following products have the same basic physical chemical and technical characteristics as well as the same basic uses: — the product concerned when exported to the Union; — the product under investigation produced and sold on the domestic market of countries concerned; and — the product under investigation produced and sold in the Union by the Union industry.
recital 48recital 48
(48) The Commission decided at this stage that those products are therefore like products within the meaning of Article 1(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 49recital 49
2.4. Claims regarding product scope
(49) Sasol claimed that BA and 2EHA differ substantively in terms of physical characteristics, prices and end uses. Therefore, according to this exporter, the injury analysis must be conducted on a segmented basis. In Sasol’s view, the segmented analysis should extend beyond price effects to encompass the assessment of volume effects, economic indicators, and the causal link or otherwise segment-specific trends may be masked.
recital 50recital 50
(50) The Commission disagreed with Sasol’s assessment. BA and 2EHA are acrylic esters, which are both substitutable on a functional and market basis, even if they are not strictly identical molecules. Both esters are produced in a condensation reaction (known as esterification) between crude acrylic acid and an alcohol. Moreover, from a chemical standpoint, BA and 2EHA belong to the same family of ‘soft’ acrylic esters.
recital 51recital 51
(51) They have very similar roles in coatings formulations: lowering the glass transition temperature (Tg), imparting flexibility, improving film formation, and contributing to adhesion. In practical formulation work, partial or total substitution between BA and 2EHA is feasible and commonly considered when optimizing system performance.
recital 52recital 52
(52) This reinforces the conclusion that the two esters compete within the same functional space and can substitute for each other under many circumstances. In this they are no different from product types of more homogeneous product.
recital 53recital 53
(53) Furthermore, from an industrial and market perspective, BA and 2EHA fit within the same value chain and are supplied to largely overlapping customer bases. Both are derived from similar upstream raw materials (notably propylene via oxo-alcohol processes), and both are used in comparable downstream applications. They are often grouped together as ‘heavy acrylate esters’ and distinguished collectively from lighter, more polar monomers such as ethyl acrylate (EA) or methyl acrylate (MA). This common positioning supports the view that they belong to the same product and market segment.
recital 54recital 54
(54) Moreover, it was recalled that the Commission enjoys a broad discretion in determination of injury caused to the Union industry. The basic Regulation does not, in principle, impose any obligation on the Commission to carry out an injury analysis and in particular the existence of price undercutting at a level other than that of the like product ( 5 ) . Provided that the relevant differences between product types were taken into consideration in the PCN, the Court stated ( 6 ) that the application of the PCN method, would normally take account of the market segments of the product under consideration for the purposes, in particular, of the analysis of price undercutting. Indeed, while the injury and causality analysis in this case is conducted based on aggregated, AE-related (covering both BA and 2EHA) information on imports, production and sales, dumping as well as injury calculations are performed on a product type basis to recognize price variations between BA and 2EHA and reflect price differences across these product types in the final determination of the dumping and injury margins.
recital 55recital 55
(55) In conclusion, in exercising its broad discretion and given that both BA and 2EHA (i) belong to the same product category of heavy acrylate esters, (ii) operate within the same market segment serving largely overlapping customer bases, and (iii) in light of the fact that both dumping as well as injury (undercutting/underselling) calculations are performed separately for BA and 2EHA, the Commission determined that no segmented assessment of volume effects, economic indicators or the causal link is required in this case. The Commission therefore rejected Sasol’s claim.
recital 56recital 56
3. DUMPING
3.1. Saudi Arabia
(56) The sole exporting producer in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Saudi Acrylic Monomers Company (‘SAMCO’) was notified that it should complete the questionnaire for exporting producers, as set out in recital (33) above.
recital 57recital 57
(57) As set out in recital (37) the Commission received no cooperation from SAMCO.
recital 58recital 58
(58) The Commission therefore used the provisions of Article 18 to calculate dumping for all exports of certain acrylic esters originating in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
recital 59recital 59
3.1.1. Normal value
(59) Without the cooperation of the sole exporting producer, the Commission used the facts available from the complaint and other publicly available sources as set out below to determine the normal value ( 7 ) .
recital 60recital 60
(60) The complainant stated that they were not able to find a publicly available source of domestic sales prices from the sole producer, SAMCO. The complainant stated that they had domestic sales invoices from Saudi Arabia, but these prices could not be disclosed ( 8 ) .
recital 61recital 61
(61) The complainant however stated that the domestic prices were lower than the cost of production ( 9 ) and SAMCO was not profitable during the investigation period according to the annual report of Tasnee ( 10 ) , their parent company, for 2024 ( 11 ) . Therefore, under Article 2(4) of the basic Regulation, domestic sales prices should not be used to determine normal value from Saudi Arabia.
recital 62recital 62
(62) On these grounds the normal value calculations in the complaint were based on a constructed normal value, using the consumption ratios of the Union industry and the costs of factors of production (inputs and costs) incurred in the production of acrylic esters ( 12 ) . The complainants excluded the price of imports into Saudi Arabia from China by analogy to the method used when constructing an undistorted normal value from a representative country for China. The Commission used the same method in the benchmark calculation below.
recital 63recital 63
(63) The Commission consulted the Tasnee annual report in 2024 and found that in fact the company had been profitable. However, their latest annual report for 2025 ( 13 ) revised the figures for 2024 to a small net loss, and for 2025 a large net loss. The Commission therefore agreed that Tasnee was indeed lossmaking in 2025 and no profit and loss data for SAMCO itself were publicly available.
recital 64recital 64
(64) The Commission was also unable to find publicly available data to show the domestic price of acrylic esters in Saudi Arabia, and as the company SAMCO did not cooperate at all with the investigation, no domestic sales data had been provided or could be verified.
recital 65recital 65
(65) The Commission was also unable to find publicly available data to show the cost of production of acrylic esters in Saudi Arabia, which would have allowed the Commission to compare indexes of Saudi domestic prices (available on subscription from various business websites ( 14 ) ) to the cost of production, to see whether these sales indexes would show a sale made in the ordinary course of trade.
recital 66recital 66
(66) In the absence of publicly available domestic sales prices and the cost of production of acrylic esters in Saudi Arabia, the Commission used the method set out in the complaint to construct normal value.
recital 67recital 67
(67) The complaint provided the consumption ratios of the Union industry and identified the main factors of production (‘FOP’) in Saudi Arabia. The Commission found publicly available sources and updated the benchmarks for 2025 as follows:
recital 68recital 68
3.1.1.1. Raw materials
(68) The complaint gave two raw materials, namely: — Propylene (HS code 2901 22 ); — N-Butanol (HS code 2905 13 ).
recital 69recital 69
(69) Saudi Arabia imported propylene from Libya, China and the USA during the investigation period. As per Commission’s methodology to calculate normal value (see also recital (250)), imports from China were removed but it did not significantly change the unit price, which was 2 362 SAR per tonne for the IP.
recital 70recital 70
(70) Saudi Arabia also imported n-Butanol from many sources, including China, during the investigation period. Removing the imports from China did not significantly change the unit price, which was 5 162 SAR per tonne for the IP.
recital 71recital 71
3.1.1.2. Energy
(71) The complaint gave two sources of energy to produce acrylic esters, which were used by the Commission for the provisional dumping margin calculation, namely: — Electricity (from Saudi Energy) ( 15 ) ; — Natural Gas (from Intratec, a USA based provider of commodity data) ( 16 ) .
recital 72recital 72
(72) Saudi Energy gives the electricity tariff for industrial users at 0,2 SAR per kWh regardless of the consumption amount.
recital 73recital 73
(73) The price of natural gas for 2025 quoted by Intratec was 8,06 SAR per MMBtu ( 17 ) .
recital 74recital 74
3.1.1.3. Labour costs
(74) The complainant used labour costs from the Saudi Statistical Authority ( 18 ) as a source of labour costs. The report ‘Labour Market Statistics Q4 2025’ gives average monthly wages per paid employee per sector, with the average monthly wage in industry for 2025 as 5 606 SAR per month ( 19 ) , 46 hours worked per week ( 20 ) and therefore 200 hours worked per month. The average wage per hour was calculated at 28,03 SAR.
recital 75recital 75
(75) This however did not include mandatory social security contributions paid by the employer and the employee to the General Organization for Social Insurance (GOSI) which is 22 % on top of the basic wage ( 21 ) .
recital 76recital 76
(76) The labour cost to the employer would therefore increase to 34,2 SAR/hour.
recital 77recital 77
3.1.1.4. Indirect manufacturing costs
(77) In the absence of information from the exporting producer, the complainant had established indirect costs as a share of direct costs, based on information from the complainants themselves. These included manufacturing overheads, depreciation and other indirect costs.
recital 78recital 78
3.1.1.5. Selling, general and administrative costs, and profit
(78) Normally this information would be taken from the response of the exporting producer to the questionnaire. In the absence of this information the Commission relied on publicly available data, and data published in the open version of the complaint.
recital 79recital 79
(79) The complainant relied on the annual report of Tasnee for 2023 and the annual reports for 2023 and 2024 of two other chemical companies in Saudi Arabia, SABIC ( 22 ) and ARAMCO ( 23 ) .
recital 80recital 80
(80) The complainant calculated average selling, general and administrative (‘SG & A’) costs of 10,9 % of the cost of manufacturing ( 24 ) , based on data from Tasnee, SABIC and ARAMCO for 2023 and 2024.
recital 81recital 81
(81) The Commission did not consider that the SG & A costs set out in the annual report of Tasnee for 2025 should be rejected on the grounds that the company was not profitable in that period, as the costs incurred on sales would be relevant regardless of the company’s financial position.
recital 82recital 82
(82) The Tasnee annual report also included a breakdown of SG & A costs that allowed for a more accurate calculation ( 25 ) . These tables showed total SG & A costs, excluding freight and transportation, or commissions, of 16,7 % of the cost of manufacturing.
recital 83recital 83
(83) The complainant also calculated an average profit margin of 11,6 % of the cost of manufacturing ( 26 ) , based on the profit of Tasnee for 2023.
recital 84recital 84
(84) As set out in recital (63), the Commission noted that Tasnee as a group was not profitable in 2024 and 2025 and therefore another source of data would need to be found for a profit margin to be added to the cost of manufacturing.
recital 85recital 85
(85) The Commission noted that the annual report for 2025 did include a breakdown of revenue and expenses for each sector of the business ( 27 ) (Metallurgy, Petrochemicals and Downstream activities) but that the petrochemical sector was also not profitable in 2025 ( 28 ) .
recital 86recital 86
(86) In the absence of other data, the Commission considered that a profit of 11,6 % of the cost of manufacturing, as provided in the complaint ( 29 ) , would be a reasonable profit to construct normal value in Saudi Arabia.
recital 87recital 87
3.1.1.6. Constructed normal value
(87) The normal value for acrylic esters originating in Saudi Arabia was therefore calculated by taking the benchmarks established above and using the consumption ratios in the complaint to reach a cost of manufacturing.
recital 88recital 88
(88) To this was added manufacturing overheads, SG&A costs and profit to reach an ex works normal value of 6 337,40 SAR/tonne.
recital 89recital 89
3.1.2. Export price
(89) Without the cooperation of the exporting producer, the Commission used the facts available to it, including import statistics from Eurostat and data submitted in the complaint.
recital 90recital 90
(90) The Commission used the Eurostat import statistics from Saudi Arabia to the Union under CN code 2916 12 00 , adjusted to ex works level by deducting a reasonable amount for sea freight.
recital 91recital 91
(91) The export price for the IP was therefore calculated at 4 388,47 SAR per tonne.
recital 92recital 92
3.1.3. Comparison
(92) The constructed normal value was compared to the export price, which were both already at an ex works level.
recital 93recital 93
(93) Therefore, no adjustment was necessary to either the normal value or the export price in order to compare them for the purposes of calculating dumping.
recital 94recital 94
3.1.4. Dumping calculation
(94) The complaint contained data to estimate the CIF Union frontier price of exports from Saudi Arabia, by adding 103,8 EUR per tonne for freight and related shipping costs ( 30 ) . In the absence of other information this was used to calculate the CIF price from the Saudi FOB export prices.
recital 95recital 95
3.1.5. Dumping margins
(95) On this basis, the provisional dumping margin expressed as a percentage of the CIF Union frontier price, duty unpaid, is as follows: Country Company Provisional dumping margin (%) Saudi Arabia All imports originating in Saudi Arabia 40,3
recital 96recital 96
3.2. China
3.2.1. Determination of the normal value under Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation
(96) In view of the sufficient evidence available at the initiation of the investigation pointing to the existence of significant distortions within the meaning of point (b) of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation with regard to China, the Commission considered it appropriate to initiate the investigation with regard to the exporting producers from this country having regard to Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 97recital 97
(97) To gather the data required for the potential application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation, the Commission's Notice of Initiation invited all Chinese exporting producers to provide details on the inputs used in their production. Four producers submitted the relevant information.
recital 98recital 98
(98) To obtain information it deemed necessary for its investigation with regard to the alleged significant distortions, the Commission sent a questionnaire to the GOC.
recital 99recital 99
(99) In addition, in point 5.3.2 of the Notice of Initiation, the Commission invited all interested parties to make their views known, submit information and provide supporting evidence regarding the application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation within 37 days of the date of publication of the Notice of Initiation in the Official Journal of the European Union .
recital 100recital 100
(100) No questionnaire reply was received from the GOC and no submission on the application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation was received within the deadline.
recital 101recital 101
(101) As no reply was received from the GOC, the Commission informed them that it would use facts available within the meaning of Article 18 of the basic Regulation for the determination of the existence of the significant distortions in China. No comments on the use of facts available were received from the GOC.
recital 102recital 102
(102) In point 5.3.2 of the Notice of Initiation the Commission also stated that in view of the evidence available it had provisionally selected Brazil as an appropriate representative country pursuant to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation for the purpose of determining the normal value based on undistorted prices or benchmarks. The Commission further stated that it would examine other possibly appropriate representative countries in accordance with the criteria set out in 2(6a)(a) first indent of the basic Regulation.
recital 103recital 103
(103) On 1 July 2026, the Commission published a note (‘the FOP Note’) to inform interested parties on the relevant sources it intended to use for the determination of the normal value. In that note the Commission provided a list of all factors of production such as raw materials, labour and energy used in the production of the product concerned, identified Indonesia as an appropriate representative country based on the criteria guiding the choice of undistorted prices or benchmarks, and stated that it would establish selling, general and administrative costs (‘SG & A costs’) and profits based on available information for the company PT Intanwijaya Internasional TBK ( 31 ) (‘Intanwijaya Internasional’).
recital 104recital 104
(104) Comments to this note were received from the complainants and from the two sampled Chinese exporting producers. The comments are addressed below.
recital 105recital 105
3.2.2. Normal value
(105) According to Article 2(1) of the basic Regulation, ‘the normal value shall normally be based on the prices paid or payable, in the ordinary course of trade, by independent customers in the exporting country’.
recital 106recital 106
(106) However, according to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation, ‘in case it is determined … that it is not appropriate to use domestic prices and costs in the exporting country due to the existence in that country of significant distortions within the meaning of point (b), the normal value shall be constructed exclusively on the basis of costs of production and sale reflecting undistorted prices or benchmarks’, and ‘shall include an undistorted and reasonable amount of administrative, selling and general costs and for profits’ (‘administrative, selling and general costs’ is referred to as ‘SG & A costs’).
recital 107recital 107
(107) As further explained below, the Commission concluded in the present investigation that, based on the evidence available, the application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation was appropriate.
recital 108recital 108
3.2.3. Existence of significant distortions
(108) Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation states that ‘significant distortions are those distortions which occur when reported prices or costs, including the costs of raw materials and energy, are not the result of free market forces as they are affected by substantial government intervention. In assessing the existence of significant distortions regard shall be had, inter alia, to the potential impact of one or more of the following elements: — the market in question being served to a significant extent by enterprises which operate under the ownership, control or policy supervision or guidance of the authorities of the exporting country; — state presence in firms allowing the state to interfere with respect to prices or costs; — public policies or measures discriminating in favour of domestic suppliers or otherwise influencing free market forces; — the lack, discriminatory application or inadequate enforcement of bankruptcy, corporate or property laws; — wage costs being distorted; — access to finance granted by institutions which implement public policy objectives or otherwise not acting independently of the state.’
recital 109recital 109
(109) As the list in Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation is non-cumulative, not all the elements need to be given for a finding of significant distortions. Moreover, the same factual circumstances may be used to demonstrate the existence of one or more of the elements of the list.
recital 110recital 110
(110) However, any conclusion on significant distortions within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation must be made on the basis of all the evidence at hand. The overall assessment on the existence of distortions may also take into account the general context and situation in the exporting country, in particular where the fundamental elements of the exporting country’s economic and administrative set-up provide the government with substantial powers to intervene in the economy in such a way that prices and costs are not the result of the free development of market forces.
recital 111recital 111
(111) Article 2(6a)(c) of the basic Regulation provides that ‘[w]here the Commission has well-founded indications of the possible existence of significant distortions as referred to in point (b) in a certain country or a certain sector in that country, and where appropriate for the effective application of this Regulation, the Commission shall produce, make public and regularly update a report describing the market circumstances referred to in point (b) in that country or sector’.
recital 112recital 112
(112) Pursuant to this provision, the Commission issued a country report concerning China ( 32 ) (‘the Report’), which contains evidence of the existence of substantial government intervention at many levels of the economy, including specific distortions in many key factors of production (such as land, energy, capital, raw materials and labour) as well as selected sectors (such as chemical). Interested parties were invited to rebut, comment or supplement the evidence contained in the investigation file at the time of initiation. The Report concerning China was placed in the investigation file at the initiation stage. The complaint also contained some relevant evidence complementing the Report.
recital 113recital 113
(113) The complainant relied on the evidence contained in the Report to argue that there are distortions in the Chinese acrylic esters industry. These distortions stem from the organization of the People’s Republic of China (‘PRC’), which is based on the concept of social market economy that is developed under the leadership of the Chinese Communist Party (‘CCP’) and covers all essential aspects of the State.
recital 114recital 114
(114) According to the complaint, at the economic level, the CCP exercises a particularly tight control, which is translated into the high importance of the State-Owned Enterprises (‘SOE’) in the economy and the CCP’s strong leverage over the private sector. The complainant pointed to three main channels of intervention by the GOC in the Chinese economy: administrative, financial and regulatory control of the State ( 33 ) .
recital 115recital 115
(115) The complaint argued that in China, business entities operating under state ownership, control, policy supervision or governmental guidance constitute a fundamental component of the economic structure and that this reality extends to the Chinese chemical industry. In the sector of the product concerned, the degree of state ownership remains significant, with major acrylic esters producers being fully or partially state-owned, such as: Shanghai Huayi Group Corporation Limited (Huayi Group), Shenyang Chemical Co. and Wanhua Chemical Group Co., Ltd ( 34 ) .
recital 116recital 116
(116) Concerning the State influence in the acrylic esters sector, the complainant mentioned that the State presence in firms allows it to interfere with respect to prices or costs and provided as an example the intervention in the cost of electricity ( 35 ) .
recital 117recital 117
(117) Moreover, the complainant explained that the main raw materials to produce acrylic esters are subject to the distortions. In this regard, the complaint mentioned the 2024 China Report, referring for instance to the 14th FYP of Gansu Province, the Gansu 14th Raw Material Industry Development Plan (‘Gansu Plan’) which outlined its scope including petrochemical, steel, non-ferrous metals, building materials and other industries ( 36 ) . The complaint mentioned similar plans in other places like Lianyungang and Taizhou ( 37 ) .
recital 118recital 118
(118) The complaint also mentioned other distortions affecting the acrylic esters market such as public policies discriminating in favour of domestic suppliers ( 38 ) and inadequate enforcement of bankruptcy, corporate or property laws ( 39 ) . The complaint also explained that the intervention of the State in the economy also has an impact on the wage costs ( 40 ) .
recital 119recital 119
(119) Moreover, the complainant explained that distortions also exist in the financial system, as access to finance is granted by institutions which implement public policy objectives or otherwise not acting independently of the State ( 41 ) .
recital 120recital 120
(120) In conclusion, the complainant argued that significant distortions pursuant to Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation are present in the acrylic esters sector.
recital 121recital 121
(121) The Commission examined whether it was appropriate or not to use domestic prices and costs in China, due to the existence of significant distortions within the meaning of point (b) of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation. The Commission did so on the basis of the evidence available on the file. The evidence on the file included the evidence contained in the Report, which relies on publicly available sources.
recital 122recital 122
(122) That analysis covered the examination of the substantial government interventions in China’s economy in general, but also the specific market situation in the relevant sector including the product concerned. The Commission further supplemented these evidentiary elements with its own research on the various criteria relevant to confirm the existence of significant distortions in China.
recital 123recital 123
3.2.3.1. Significant distortions affecting the domestic prices and costs in China
(123) The Chinese economic system is based on the concept of a ‘socialist market economy’. That concept is enshrined in the Chinese Constitution and determines the economic governance of China. The core principle is the ‘socialist public ownership of the means of production, namely, ownership by the whole people and collective ownership by the working people’ ( 42 ) .
recital 124recital 124
(124) The state-owned economy is the ‘leading force in the national economy’ and the state has the mandate to ensure its ‘consolidation and growth’ ( 43 ) . Indeed, compared to the 13th FYP, SASAC confirmed that total assets of central enterprises grew by 44,6 % during the 14th FYP, ‘effectively driving the integrated development of upstream and downstream enterprises in the industrial chain and providing strong support for the successful achievement of the main goals and tasks of my country’s economic and social development’ ( 44 ) .
recital 125recital 125
(125) Consequently, the overall setup of the Chinese economy not only allows for substantial government interventions into the economy, but such interventions are expressly mandated. The notion of supremacy of public ownership over the private one permeates the entire legal system and is emphasized as a general principle in all central pieces of legislation.
recital 126recital 126
(126) The Chinese property law is a prime example: it refers to the primary stage of socialism and entrusts the state with upholding the basic economic system under which the public ownership plays a dominant role. Other forms of ownership are tolerated, with the law permitting them to develop side by side with the state ownership ( 45 ) .
recital 127recital 127
(127) In addition, under Chinese law, the socialist market economy is developed under the leadership of the CCP. The structures of the Chinese state and of the CCP are intertwined at every level (legal, institutional, personal), forming a superstructure in which the roles of CCP and the state are indistinguishable.
recital 128recital 128
(128) Following an amendment of the Chinese Constitution in March 2018, the leading role of the CCP was given an even greater prominence by being reaffirmed in the text of Article 1 of the Constitution.
recital 129recital 129
(129) Following the already existing first sentence of the provision: ‘[t]he socialist system is the basic system of the People’s Republic of China’ a new second sentence was inserted which reads: ‘[t]he defining feature of socialism with Chinese characteristics is the leadership of the Communist Party of China’ ( 46 ) . This illustrates the unquestioned and ever-growing control of the CCP over the economic system of China.
recital 130recital 130
(130) The leadership and control are inherent to the Chinese system and goes well beyond the situation customary in other countries where the governments exercise general macroeconomic control within the boundaries of which free market forces are at play.
recital 131recital 131
(131) The Chinese state engages in an interventionist economic policy in pursuance of goals, which coincide with the political agenda set by the CCP rather than reflecting the prevailing economic conditions in a free market ( 47 ) . The interventionist economic tools deployed by the Chinese authorities are manifold, including the system of industrial planning, the financial system, as well as the level of the regulatory environment.
recital 132recital 132
(132) First, on the level of overall administrative control, the direction of the Chinese economy is governed by a complex system of industrial planning which affects all economic activities within the country. The totality of these plans covers a comprehensive and complex matrix of sectors and crosscutting policies and is present on all levels of government.
recital 133recital 133
(133) Plans at provincial level are detailed while national plans set broader targets. Plans also specify the means in order to support the relevant industries/sectors as well as the timeframes in which the objectives need to be achieved. Some plans still contain explicit output targets.
recital 134recital 134
(134) Under the plans, individual industrial sectors and/or projects are being singled out as (positive or negative) priorities in line with the government priorities and specific development goals are attributed to them (industrial upgrade, international expansion etc.).
recital 135recital 135
(135) The economic operators, private and state-owned alike, must effectively adjust their business activities according to the realities imposed by the planning system. This is not only because of the binding nature of the plans, but also because the relevant Chinese authorities at all levels of government adhere to the system of plans and use their vested powers accordingly, thereby inducing the economic operators to comply with the priorities set out in the plans ( 48 ) .
recital 136recital 136
(136) Second, on the level of allocation of financial resources, the financial system of China is dominated by the state-owned commercial and policy banks. Those banks, when setting up and implementing their lending policy need to align themselves with the government’s industrial policy objectives rather than primarily assessing the economic merits of a given project ( 49 ) .
recital 137recital 137
(137) The same applies to the other components of the Chinese financial system, such as the stock markets, bond markets, private equity markets etc. Also, these parts of the financial sector are institutionally and operationally set up in a manner not geared towards maximizing the efficient functioning of the financial markets but towards ensuring control and allowing intervention by the state and the CCP ( 50 ) .
recital 138recital 138
(138) Third, on the level of regulatory environment, the interventions by the state into the economy take a number of forms. For instance, the public procurement rules are regularly used in pursuit of policy goals other than economic efficiency, thereby undermining market-based principles in the area. The applicable legislation specifically provides that public procurement shall be conducted in order to facilitate the achievement of goals designed by state policies. However, the nature of these goals remains undefined, thereby leaving broad margin of appreciation to the decision-making bodies ( 51 ) .
recital 139recital 139
(139) Similarly, in the area of investment, the GOC maintains significant control and influence over destination and magnitude of both state and private investment. Investment screening as well as various incentives, restrictions, and prohibitions related to investment are used by authorities as an important tool for supporting industrial policy goals, such as maintaining state control over key sectors or bolstering domestic industry ( 52 ) .
recital 140recital 140
(140) In sum, the Chinese economic model is based on certain basic axioms, which provide for and encourage manifold government interventions. Such substantial government interventions are at odds with the free play of market forces, resulting in distorting the effective allocation of resources in line with market principles ( 53 ) .
recital 141recital 141
3.2.3.2. Significant distortions according to Article 2(6a)(b), first indent of the basic Regulation: the market in question being served to a significant extent by enterprises which operate under the ownership, control or policy supervision or guidance of the authorities of the exporting country
(141) In China, enterprises operating under the ownership, control and/or policy supervision or guidance by the state represent an essential part of the economy.
recital 142recital 142
(142) The sector of the product concerned is served by both private companies such as Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd ( 54 ) . and by state-owned companies such as Shanghai Huayi New Material Co. Ltd., a subsidiary ( 55 ) wholly owned by the Shanghai Huayi Group which is 57,75 % state-owned ( 56 ) and effectively controlled by the Shanghai State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission ( 57 ) . Other producers of acrylic esters ( 58 ) are Wanhua Chemical Group Co. Ltd ( 59 ) , which is 21,65 % state-owned ( 60 ) and ultimately controlled by the Yantai Municipality State Owned Asset Supervision and Administration Commission ( 61 ) and Shenyang Chemical Co. Ltd ( 62 ) , which is 47,23 % state-owned ( 63 ) and a subsidiary of Sinochem, an SOE under SASAC ( 64 ) . Shenyang Chemical Co. Ltd is ultimately controlled by SASAC ( 65 ) .
recital 143recital 143
(143) Furthermore, in the upstream sector of propylene, an input used to produce acrylic esters, while some producers are private companies like Hengli Petrochemicals ( 66 ) , the degree of state ownership remains significant, with a number of key producers being controlled by the state, such as Sinopec ( 67 ) or, China National Petroleum Corporation ( 68 ) (‘CNPC’), or China National Offshore Oil Corporation ( 69 ) (‘CNOOC’) all three being state owned enterprises (‘SOEs’) controlled by SASAC ( 70 ) .
recital 144recital 144
(144) Moreover, CCP interventions into operational decision making have become the norm not only in SOEs, but also in private companies ( 71 ) , with CCP claiming leadership over virtually every aspect of the country’s economy.
recital 145recital 145
(145) Indeed, the State’s influence by means of CCP structures within companies effectively results in economic operators being under the government’s control and policy supervision, given how far the State and Party structures have grown together in China.
recital 146recital 146
(146) Moreover, the whole sector of the product concerned, is subject to several government policies such as, the 14th FYP on raw materials ( 72 ) which directly addresses the petrochemical and chemical sectors by stating that ‘[i]n sectors including petrochemicals and chemicals, steel, non-ferrous metals, and building materials, we shall foster a number of industry chain pioneer enterprises exerting leadership on the ecosystem and characterized by core competitiveness, (…). The guiding role of leading enterprises in chemical and building materials sectors shall be leveraged to promote corporate reform and restructuring.’
recital 147recital 147
(147) Additionally, the Work Plan for the steady growth of the petrochemical and chemical industry ( 73 ) is formulated in order ‘to promote the stable operation and structural optimization and upgrading of the petrochemical industry’ and to ‘expand effective investment and promote transformation and upgrading’.
recital 148recital 148
(148) Similarly, at provincial level, the Zhejiang 14th FYP on developing the Petrochemical and Chemical industry ( 74 ) seeks to ‘[e]nhance the upstream supply chain, (…) consolidate refining capacity, strengthen the olefins industry (…) [as well as to] [f]ocus on developing a strategic industrial chain for basic chemical raw materials, such as propane dehydrogenation to propylene’.
recital 149recital 149
(149) Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd is located in Zhejiang ( 75 ) .
recital 150recital 150
(150) Also, the Shanghai 14th FYP for the Development of Chemical Industry Parks ( 76 ) mandates to ‘accelerate the strengthening, complementing and extension of the chemical industry chain’ as well as to ‘[s]upport leading enterprises in the parks to make good use of existing ethylene and propylene resources, adjust product structures, and further develop high value-added products’.
recital 151recital 151
(151) Shanghai Huayi Group is located in Shanghai ( 77 ) .
recital 152recital 152
(152) Government control and policy supervision can be also observed at the level of the relevant industry associations ( 78 ) .
recital 153recital 153
(153) For instance, the China Petrochemical and Chemical Industry Federation (‘CPCIF’) is the industry association for the sector of the product concerned. According to Article 3 of CPCIF’s Articles of Association, the organisation ‘adheres to the comprehensive leadership of the CCP [and] accepts the professional guidance, supervision and management by the entities in charge of registration and management, by entities in charge of Party building, as well as by the relevant administrative departments in charge of industry management’ ( 79 ) .
recital 154recital 154
(154) Moreover, Article 36 of CPCIF’s Articles of Association stipulates that the president, vice-presidents and secretary-general of the Association must ‘adhere to the leadership of the CCP, support socialism with Chinese characteristics, [and] resolutely implement the Party’s line, principles and policies’ ( 80 ) .
recital 155recital 155
(155) Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd ( 81 ) , Shanghai Huayi Group ( 82 ) , Hengli Petrochemicals ( 83 ) , Sinopec ( 84 ) , CNPC ( 85 ) and CNOOC ( 86 ) are all members of CPCIF.
recital 156recital 156
(156) Consequently, privately owned producers in the sector of the product concerned are prevented from operating under market conditions. Indeed, both public and privately owned enterprises in the sector are subject to policy supervision and guidance.
recital 157recital 157
3.2.3.3. Significant distortions according to Article 2(6a)(b), second indent of the basic Regulation: State presence in firms allowing the state to interfere with respect to prices or costs
(157) The GOC is in position to interfere with prices and costs through state presence in firms. Indeed, CCP cells in enterprises, state-owned and private alike, represent an important channel through which the state can interfere with business decisions.
recital 158recital 158
(158) According to China’s company law, a CCP organisation is to be established in every company (with at least three CCP members as specified in the CCP Constitution ( 87 ) ) and the company shall provide the necessary conditions for the activities of the Party organisation.
recital 159recital 159
(159) In the past, this requirement appeared not to have always been followed or strictly enforced. However, since at least 2016 the CCP has been reinforcing its claims to control business decisions in companies as a matter of political principle ( 88 ) , including exercising pressure on private companies to put ‘patriotism’ first and to follow Party discipline ( 89 ) .
recital 160recital 160
(160) Already in 2017, it was reported that party cells existed in 70 % of some 1,86 million privately owned companies, with growing pressure for the CCP organisations to have a final say over the business decisions within their respective companies ( 90 ) . These rules are of general application throughout the Chinese economy, across all sectors, including to the producers of the product concerned and the suppliers of their inputs.
recital 161recital 161
(161) In addition, on 15 September 2020 a document titled General Office of CCP Central Committee’s Guidelines on stepping up the United Front work in the private sector for the new era ( 91 ) (‘the Guidelines’) was released, which further expanded the role of the Party committees in private enterprises.
recital 162recital 162
(162) Section II.4 of the Guidelines states: ‘[w]e must raise the Party’s overall capacity to lead private-sector United Front work and effectively step up the work in this area’; and section III.6 states: ‘[w]e must further step up Party building in private enterprises and enable the Party cells to play their role effectively as a fortress and enable Party members to play their parts as vanguards and pioneers’. The Guidelines thus emphasise and seek to increase the role of the CCP in companies and other private sector entities ( 92 ) .
recital 163recital 163
(163) The investigation confirmed that overlaps between managerial positions and CCP membership / Party functions exist also in the acrylic esters sector.
recital 164recital 164
(164) To provide an example, the Deputy Chairman of Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd. also serves as the Secretary of the Party Committee ( 93 ) . Furthermore, Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd. claims that ‘[f]or 30 years, the Satellite Group has consistently adhered to the Party’s policies and guidelines, closely followed the national industrial development strategy’ ( 94 ) . This is confirmed again by the company’s chairman declaring in May 2026, during the visit by the Secretary of the Zhejiang Provincial Party Committee, that Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd. ‘closely follows the strategic deployment of the Provincial Party Committee and Provincial Government’ ( 95 ) .
recital 165recital 165
(165) Also, the Chairman of Shanghai Huayi Group serves as the Secretary of the Party Committee, and several members of the company’s Board of Directors are members of the CCP ( 96 ) . Moreover, the company confirms in its 2025 annual report that ‘[a]ll cadres and employees of the Group thoroughly implemented the spirit of the Fourth Plenary Session of the 20th CPC Central Committee and the Eighth Plenary Session of the 12th Shanghai Municipal Committee. Under the correct leadership of the Group's Party Committee and Board of Directors, […] the Group actively responded to the unfavourable situation of the slow overall recovery of the chemical industry, successfully completing all tasks of the 14th Five-Year Plan’ ( 97 ) .
recital 166recital 166
(166) Similarly, the Chairman of Wanhua Chemical Group Co. Ltd. serves as the Secretary of the Party Committee ( 98 ) .
recital 167recital 167
(167) Also, the General Manager of Shenyang Chemical Co. Ltd. serves as the Secretary of the Party Committee, and several other members of the Board of Directors are CCP members, including the Chairman who also serves as the Secretary of the Party Committee in a related company ( 99 ) .
recital 168recital 168
(168) Additionally, the 2022 annual report of the Sinopec Group, points out that ‘[t]he company continuously improves the quality of party building work, boosting the spirit of the employees, strengthening discipline inspection and supervision work, helping the board of directors to effectively implement various decisions and arrangements, and promoting the high-quality development of the company’ ( 100 ) . Moreover, Sinopec Group’s chairman of the board of directors is the secretary of the Party committee and several members of the board serve as deputy secretaries of the Party committee ( 101 ) . Sinopec Group also stated that it intends to ‘focus on the company's new mission and new tasks on the new journey, carry forward the party’s self-revolutionary spirit, strengthen the party’s leadership and party building in an all-round and integrated manner, and systematically promote comprehensive and strict party governance, so as to provide a strong guarantee for writing a new chapter of China’s modern petrochemical industry’ ( 102 ) .
recital 169recital 169
(169) The state’s presence and intervention in the financial markets as well as in the provision of raw materials and inputs further have an additional distorting effect on the market ( 103 ) . Thus, the state presence in firms, in the acrylic esters sector and other sectors (such as the financial and input sectors) allows the GOC to interfere with respect to prices and costs.
recital 170recital 170
3.2.3.4. Significant distortions according to Article 2(6a)(b), third indent of the basic Regulation: public policies or measures discriminating in favour of domestic suppliers or otherwise influencing free market forces
(170) The direction of the Chinese economy is to a significant degree determined by an elaborate system of planning which sets out priorities and prescribes the goals the central, provincial and local governments must focus on. Relevant plans exist at all levels of government and cover virtually all economic sectors. The objectives set by the planning instruments are of a binding nature and the authorities at each administrative level monitor the implementation of the plans by the corresponding lower level of government.
recital 171recital 171
(171) Overall, the system of planning in China results in resources being driven to sectors designated as strategic or otherwise politically important by the government, rather than being allocated in line with market forces ( 104 ) .
recital 172recital 172
(172) The Chinese authorities have enacted a number of policies guiding the functioning of the sector of the product concerned.
recital 173recital 173
(173) The 14th FYP on economic and social development and 2035 perspectives ( 105 ) aims to ‘upgrade traditional industries, promote the optimization and structural adjustment of raw material industries such as petrochemicals, steel, nonferrous metals, and building materials, expand the supply of high-quality products in sectors such as light industry and textiles, speed up the transformation and upgrading of enterprises in key industries such as the chemical industry and papermaking, and improve the green manufacturing system’ ( 106 ) .
recital 174recital 174
(174) According to the 14th FYP on the raw materials industry ( 107 ) , China ‘will develop a batch of industrial clusters in petrochemicals. […] In sectors including petrochemicals and chemicals, steel, non-ferrous metals, and building materials, [China] will foster a number of pioneering enterprises that could lead the ecosystem of the industrial chain with core competitiveness’ ( 108 ) .
recital 175recital 175
(175) Additionally, the Guiding Opinion on promoting the high quality development of the petrochemical and chemical industry ( 109 ) requires to ‘strengthen sectoral policies and scientifically regulate the scale of the industry: […] enhance the supply capacity of high-end polymers, specialty chemicals and other products […]’ as well as to ‘[i]mprove supporting policies: strengthen the coordination of fiscal, financial, regional, investment, import and export, energy, ecological, environmental, price and other policies with industrial policies [and to g]ive full play to the role of the national industry-finance cooperation platform […]’.
recital 176recital 176
(176) At the provincial level, the Zhejiang 14th FYP on developing the Petrochemical and Chemical Industry ( 110 ) mandates to ‘strengthen the guarantee of essential resources such as industrial capital, talent, land, and energy with a particular focus on leading petrochemical enterprises, major projects, and infrastructure development [as well as to] [o]ptimize and coordinate relevant provincial special funds to increase support for the development of the petrochemical industry’.
recital 177recital 177
(177) Still in Zhejiang, at local level, the Jiaxing Municipality released a Three-Year-Action Plan ( 111 ) seeking to ‘implement a plan to foster leading technology enterprises [… and] encourage leading enterprises in traditional industries such as textile materials and chemical materials to increase their innovation and R & D efforts’.
recital 178recital 178
(178) Satellite Chemicals Co. Ltd. is located in the Jiaxing Economic and Technological Development Zone ( 112 ) .
recital 179recital 179
(179) Similarly, the Shanghai 14th FYP for the Development of Chemical Industry Parks ( 113 ) mandates to ‘optimize the industrial structure, enhance industrial innovation capabilities, improve the industrial chain, enrich the industrial development ecosystem, and further enhance core competitiveness, in accordance with national and Shanghai municipal strategic needs, as well as with the strategy of strengthening the leading role of high-end industries, with a particular focus on the chemical manufacturing industry’.
recital 180recital 180
(180) Furthermore, Shanghai Huayi Group benefitted from the ‘long term support in raw material and electricity supply’ ( 114 ) from China Energy Group, another SOE under SASAC ( 115 ) and both SOEs signed a strategic cooperation agreement in 2021 ( 116 ) . Through these and other means, the GOC therefore directs and controls virtually every aspect in the development and functioning of the sector, as well as the upstream inputs and the downstream products.
recital 181recital 181
(181) In sum, the GOC has measures in place to induce operators to comply with the public policy objectives concerning the sector. Such measures impede market forces from operating freely.
recital 182recital 182
3.2.3.5. Significant distortions according to Article 2(6a)(b), fourth indent of the basic Regulation: the lack, discriminatory application or inadequate enforcement of bankruptcy, corporate or property laws
(182) According to the information on file, the Chinese bankruptcy system delivers inadequately on its own main objectives such as to fairly settle claims and debts and to safeguard the lawful rights and interests of creditors and debtors. This appears to be rooted in the fact that while the Chinese bankruptcy law formally rests on principles that are similar to those applied in corresponding laws in countries other than China, the Chinese system is characterised by systematic under-enforcement.
recital 183recital 183
(183) The number of bankruptcies remains notoriously low in relation to the size of the country’s economy, not least because the insolvency proceedings suffer from a number of shortcomings which effectively function as a disincentive for bankruptcy filings. Moreover, the role of the state in the insolvency proceedings remains strong and active, often having direct influence on the outcome of the proceedings ( 117 ) .
recital 184recital 184
(184) In addition, the shortcomings of the system of property rights are particularly obvious in relation to ownership of land and land-use rights in China ( 118 ) . All land is owned by the state (collectively owned rural land and State-owned urban land) and its allocation remains solely dependent on the state. There are legal provisions that aim at allocating land use rights in a transparent manner and at market prices, for instance by introducing bidding procedures. However, these provisions are regularly not respected, with certain buyers obtaining their land for free or below market rates ( 119 ) . Moreover, authorities often pursue specific political goals including the implementation of the economic plans when allocating land ( 120 ) .
recital 185recital 185
(185) Much like other sectors in the Chinese economy, the producers of the product concerned are subject to the ordinary rules on Chinese bankruptcy, corporate, and property laws. That has the effect that these companies, too, are subject to the top-down distortions arising from the discriminatory application or inadequate enforcement of bankruptcy and property laws. Those considerations, on the basis of the evidence available, appear to be fully applicable also in the acrylic esters sector. The present investigation revealed nothing that would call those findings into question.
recital 186recital 186
(186) In light of the above, the Commission concluded that there was discriminatory application or inadequate enforcement of bankruptcy and property laws in the sector of the product concerned.
recital 187recital 187
3.2.3.6. Significant distortions according to Article 2(6a)(b), fifth indent of the basic Regulation: wage costs being distorted
(187) A system of market-based wages cannot fully develop in China as workers and employers are impeded in their rights to collective organisation. China has not ratified a number of essential conventions of the International Labour Organisation, in particular those on freedom of association and on collective bargaining ( 121 ) .
recital 188recital 188
(188) Under national law, only one trade union organisation is active. However, this organisation lacks independence from the state authorities and its engagement in collective bargaining and protection of workers’ rights remains rudimentary ( 122 ) . Moreover, the mobility of the Chinese workforce is restricted by the household registration system, which limits access to the full range of social security and other benefits to local residents of a given administrative area.
recital 189recital 189
(189) This typically results in workers who are not in possession of the local residence registration finding themselves in a vulnerable employment position and receiving lower income than the holders of the residence registration ( 123 ) . Those findings lead to the distortion of wage costs in China.
recital 190recital 190
(190) No evidence was submitted to the effect that the acrylic esters. sector would not be subject to the Chinese labour law system described. The sector is thus affected by the distortions of wage costs both directly (when making the product concerned or the main raw material for its production) as well as indirectly (when having access to capital or inputs from companies subject to the same labour system in China).
recital 191recital 191
3.2.3.7. Significant distortions according to Article 2(6a)(b), sixth indent of the basic Regulation: access to finance granted by institutions which implement public policy objectives or otherwise not acting independently of the state
(191) Access to capital for corporate actors in China is subject to various distortions.
recital 192recital 192
(192) First, the Chinese financial system is characterised by the strong position of state-owned banks ( 124 ) , which, when granting access to finance, take into consideration criteria other than the economic viability of a project. Similar to non-financial SOEs, the banks remain connected to the state not only through ownership but also via personal relations (the top executives of large state-owned financial institutions are ultimately appointed by the CCP) ( 125 ) and they regularly implement public policies designed by the GOC.
recital 193recital 193
(193) In doing so, the banks comply with an explicit legal obligation to conduct their business in accordance with the needs of the national economic and social development and under the guidance of the industrial policies of the state ( 126 ) . While it is acknowledged that various legal provisions refer to the need to respect normal banking behaviour and prudential rules such as the need to examine the creditworthiness of the borrower, the overwhelming evidence, including findings made in trade defence investigations, suggests that these provisions play only a secondary role in the application of the various legal instruments.
recital 194recital 194
(194) Recent developments further illustrate the extent of government influence over financial institutions in China. In March 2025, the Government of China (GOC) announced an issuance of RMB 500 billion in treasury bonds to provide substantial financial support to major banks, including the Bank of China, China Construction Bank, Bank of Communications, and Postal Savings Bank of China. This intervention was aimed at stabilising these institutions amidst declining profitability and record low net interest margins, highlighting the proactive measures taken by the state to maintain economic stability ( 127 ) .
recital 195recital 195
(195) Also, the GOC has clarified that even private commercial banking decisions must be overseen by the CCP and remain in line with national policies. One of the state’s three overarching goals in relation to banking governance is now to strengthen the Party’s leadership in the banking and insurance sector, including in relation to operational and management issues ( 128 ) . Also, the performance evaluation criteria of commercial banks have now to, notably, take into account how entities ‘serve the national development objectives and the real economy’, and in particular how they ‘serve strategic and emerging industries’ ( 129 ) .
recital 196recital 196
(196) Furthermore, on the level of allocation of financial resources, with Several Measures to Further Promote the Development of Private Investment ( 130 ) , the GOC seeks to ‘increase central budget resources to support qualified private investment projects and to actively play a guiding and leading role’. The GOC also intends to ‘make good use of new policy financial instruments [and] support a number of qualified private investment projects in important industries and key areas’ ( 131 ) .
recital 197recital 197
(197) Additionally, bond and credit ratings are often distorted for a variety of reasons including the fact that the risk assessment is influenced by the firm’s strategic importance to the GOC and the strength of any implicit guarantee by the government ( 132 ) . This is compounded by additional existing rules, which direct finances into sectors designated by the government as encouraged or otherwise important ( 133 ) . This results in a bias in favour of lending to SOEs, large well-connected private firms and firms in key industrial sectors, which implies that the availability and cost of capital is not equal for all players on the market.
recital 198recital 198
(198) Second, borrowing costs have been kept artificially low to stimulate investment growth. This has led to the excessive use of capital investment with ever lower returns on investment. This is illustrated by the growth in corporate leverage in the state sector despite a sharp fall in profitability, which suggests that the mechanisms at work in the banking system do not follow normal commercial responses.
recital 199recital 199
(199) Thirdly, although nominal interest rate liberalization was achieved in October 2015, price signals are still not the result of free market forces but are influenced by government-induced distortions. The share of lending at or below the benchmark rate still represented at least one-third of all lending as of the end of 2018 ( 134 ) . Official media in China have recently reported that the CCP called for ‘guiding the loan market interest rate downwards’ ( 135 ) . Artificially low interest rates result in under-pricing, and consequently, the excessive utilization of capital.
recital 200recital 200
(200) Overall credit growth in China indicates a worsening efficiency of capital allocation without any signs of credit tightening that would be expected in an undistorted market environment. As a result, non-performing loans have increased rapidly, with the GOC a number of times opting to either avoid defaults, thus creating so called ‘zombie’ companies, or to transfer the ownership of the debt (e.g. via mergers or debt-to-equity swaps), without necessarily removing the overall debt problem or addressing its root causes.
recital 201recital 201
(201) In essence, despite the steps that have been taken to liberalize the market, the corporate credit system in China is affected by significant distortions resulting from the continuing pervasive role of the state in the capital markets. Therefore, the substantial government intervention in the financial system leads to the market conditions being severely affected at all levels.
recital 202recital 202
(202) No evidence was submitted in the present investigation demonstrating that the sector of the product concerned is not affected by the government intervention in the financial system in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b), sixth indent of the basic Regulation. Therefore, the substantial government intervention in the financial system leads to the market conditions being severely affected at all levels.
recital 203recital 203
3.2.3.8. Systemic nature of the distortions described
(203) The Commission noted that the distortions described in the updated Report are characteristic for the Chinese economy. The evidence available shows that the facts and features of the Chinese system as described above as well as in Part I of the updated Report apply throughout the country and across the sectors of the economy. The same holds true for the description of the factors of production as set out above and in Part II of the updated Report.
recital 204recital 204
(204) The Commission recalls that in order to produce the product concerned, certain inputs are needed. When the producers of the product concerned purchase/contract these inputs, the prices they pay (and which are recorded as their costs) are clearly exposed to the same systemic distortions mentioned before. For instance, suppliers of inputs employ labour that is subject to the distortions. They may borrow money that is subject to the distortions on the financial sector/capital allocation. In addition, they are subject to the planning system that applies across all levels of government and sectors. These distortions were described in detail above, in particular in recitals (141) to (202). The Commission pointed out that the regulatory setup underpinning those distortions is generally applicable, acrylic esters producers being subject to those rules as any other economic operator in China. The distortions have therefore a direct bearing on the cost structure of the product concerned.
recital 205recital 205
(205) As a consequence, not only the domestic sales prices of the product concerned are not appropriate for use within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation, but all the input costs (including raw materials, energy, land, financing, labour, etc.) are also affected because their price formation is affected by substantial government intervention, as described in Parts I and II of the updated Report.
recital 206recital 206
(206) Indeed, the government interventions described in relation to the allocation of capital, land, labour, energy and raw materials are present throughout China. This means, for instance, that an input that in itself was produced in China by combining a range of factors of production is exposed to significant distortions. The same applies for the input to the input and so forth.
recital 207recital 207
(207) No evidence or argument to the contrary has been adduced by the GOC or the exporting producers in the present investigation.
recital 208recital 208
3.2.4. Representative country
3.2.4.1. General remarks
(208) The choice of the representative country was based on the following criteria pursuant to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation: — A level of economic development similar to China. For this purpose, the Commission used countries with a gross national income per capita similar to China on the basis of the database of the World Bank ( 136 ) ; — Production of the product under investigation in that country; — Existence of relevant readily available data in the representative country. — Where there is more than one possible representative country, preference was given, where appropriate, to the country with an adequate level of social and environmental protection.
recital 209recital 209
(209) As explained in recital (103) above, the Commission issued one note (‘the FOP Note’) on the sources for the determination of the normal value.
recital 210recital 210
(210) This note described the facts and evidence underlying the relevant criteria.
recital 211recital 211
(211) The note also informed interested parties of the Commission’s intention to consider Indonesia as an appropriate representative country in the present case if the existence of significant distortions pursuant to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation would be confirmed.
recital 212recital 212
3.2.4.2. A level of economic development similar to China
(212) In the FOP note, the Commission identified Brazil, Malaysia, Indonesia and South Africa where production of the product under investigation was known to take place and as countries with a similar level of economic development as China according to the World Bank, as they are all classified as ‘upper-middle income’ countries on a gross national income basis.
recital 213recital 213
(213) The complainant argued that Indonesia did not consistently meet the criterion of a level of economic development similar to that of China, as its World Bank income classification had fluctuated between lower-middle-income and upper-middle-income status in recent years. The complainant submitted that, unlike Brazil, which had consistently remained classified as an upper-middle-income country, Indonesia lacked the stability and consistency required for selection as the representative country under Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 214recital 214
(214) The Commission rejected this claim and pointed out that during the investigation period, Indonesia was classified by the World Bank as an upper-middle-income country, corresponding to the level of economic development considered appropriate for the purposes of the representative country analysis. Accordingly, the Commission considered that Indonesia satisfied the criterion set out in Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 215recital 215
3.2.4.3. Existence of relevant readily available data in the representative country
(215) In the FOP Note, the Commission informed the interested parties that it intended to use Indonesia as an appropriate representative country and Intanwijaya Internasional, in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a), first indent of the basic Regulation in order to source undistorted prices or benchmarks for the calculation of normal value.
recital 216recital 216
(216) The Commission assessed in the FOP Note the other representative countries identified by the complainant and the Commission besides Indonesia, i.e. Brazil, Malaysia, and South Africa, and did not find them to be suitable.
recital 217recital 217
(217) With regards to Brazil, based on the Global Trade Atlas ( 137 ) (‘GTA’) there were only negligible imports of propylene (i.e. 40 tonnes) which alone represented 30 to 35 % of the cost of production of acrylic esters. Moreover, Brazil imported from China 90 % of these 40 MT of propylene and 50 % of acrylic acid in the investigation period. The Commission therefore considered Brazil not to be an appropriate representative country.
recital 218recital 218
(218) With regards to Malaysia, based on the GTA, there were only negligible imports of n-butanol (i.e. 63 tonnes) which alone represented 40 to 45 % of the cost of production of the total acrylic esters and up to 50 to 55 % of the cost of production of the Butyl Acrylate (BA) type. Moreover, Malaysia imported from China 30 % of these 63 MT n-butanol, 50 % of acrylic acid and 20 % of 2- Ethylhexanol in the IP. The Commission therefore considered Malaysia not to be an appropriate representative country.
recital 219recital 219
(219) With regards to South Africa, based on the GTA, there were essentially non-existent imports of propylene (i.e. 5 tonnes) and n-butanol (i.e. 369 tonnes) which are by far the most important raw materials to produce acrylic esters. Moreover, South Africa imported from China 69 % of the propylene and 98 % of acrylic acid in the IP. The Commission therefore considered South Africa not to be an appropriate representative country.
recital 220recital 220
(220) With regards to Indonesia, based on the GTA, imports statistics showed that the country imported the highest amount in tonnes of all the raw materials listed in Table 1 during the investigation period. Out of the total quantity imported, Indonesia imported from China less than 15 % of acrylic acid, less than 6 % of 2- ethylhexanol and close to 0 % of propylene, n-butanol and propane.
recital 221recital 221
(221) Based on the information available to the Commission, there was only one producer manufacturing acrylic esters in Indonesia, PT. Nippon Shokubai Indonesia. This company was part of Nippon Shokubai (Japan) and it was one of the major producers of acrylic esters in Asia. However, it only presented consolidated annual accounts at global level ( 138 ) . It was therefore not possible to extract the financial statements for acrylic esters or for the Indonesian branch of the company.
recital 222recital 222
(222) One of the sampled Chinese exporting producers proposed to use the company PT Chandra Asri Pacific TBK. The Commission assessed the suggested company. The company does not produce acrylic esters, but upstream products (including propylene, one of the main raw materials for acrylic esters). Based on the information provided in Orbis ( 139 ) , financial data for this company were available for 2025 and at consolidated level the company was profitable in 2025. However, when looking at data for the chemical department, the company was lossmaking in 2025 ( 140 ) .
recital 223recital 223
(223) The Commission did not identify any other readily available financial statements of other producers of acrylic esters in Indonesia and considered the producers of a product in the same general category or sector of the product under investigation. Therefore, the Commission looked at other companies within the same NACE code as acrylic esters (i.e. NACE 2014, ‘Manufacture of organic chemical raw materials’). The Commission found a company, Intanwijaya Internasional, which produces formaldehyde. It is noteworthy that formaldehyde shares a very similar production process with the acrylaldehyde, which is the result of the first step of acrylic esters manufacturing, when propylene is reacted with oxygen. This company was profitable in 2025, and its financial data were publicly available on Orbis.
recital 224recital 224
(224) Interested parties were invited to comment on the appropriateness of Indonesia as a representative country and of Intanwijaya Internasional as producer in the representative country.
recital 225recital 225
(225) The complainant argued that Indonesia was not an appropriate representative country because Indonesia's benchmarks were influenced by regional cost advantages, including ASEAN preferential trade arrangements, lower labour and electricity costs, and import prices for key raw materials that were allegedly affected by regional pricing dynamics, particularly with Malaysia and other ASEAN suppliers. In particular, the complainant argued that imports into Indonesia of n-Butanol were mostly from Malaysia and that these were impacted by preferential tariff arrangements between ASEAN members. Moreover, the complainant noted that propylene import prices into Indonesia and more generally in the Southeast Asian market, moved broadly in line with Chinese prices. According to the complainant, the Brazilian benchmarks better reflected undistorted international market conditions and should therefore be preferred.
recital 226recital 226
(226) The Commission rejected these claims. The complainant did not provide sufficient evidence demonstrating that the Indonesian benchmarks were distorted within the meaning of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation. The mere fact that the Indonesian benchmark values were lower than those proposed for Brazil does not establish that they are distorted or unsuitable for the construction of normal value. Lower production costs may legitimately arise from market-based factors such as geographical location, regional supply integration, logistics efficiencies or labour market conditions and cannot, in themselves, justify the rejection of otherwise reliable benchmark data.
recital 227recital 227
(227) As regards n-Butanol, the Commission noted that the complainant's arguments on preferential tariff treatment do not, by itself, demonstrate that the underlying transaction prices are not market based. Nor did the complainant provide evidence that Malaysian export prices were subject to government intervention or otherwise failed to reflect normal commercial conditions. The Commission therefore considered that the complainant had not substantiated their claim that the Indonesian import prices were unsuitable for benchmark purposes.
recital 228recital 228
(228) As regards propylene, the Commission considered that such price correlation is not uncommon for internationally traded commodities and does not, in itself, demonstrate that Indonesian import prices are distorted or determined by Chinese domestic market conditions. The complainant did not provide evidence demonstrating that the Indonesian benchmark prices did not reflect market-based transactions.
recital 229recital 229
(229) The complainant argued that Brazil should not have been excluded as a representative country solely because of its low propylene import volumes. They submitted that Brazil's limited imports reflected its substantial domestic production capacity rather than a lack of representative market conditions and that the Commission should instead have relied on alternative undistorted benchmarks, such as publicly available ICIS prices, in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 230recital 230
(230) The Commission did not accept this claim. The representative country assessment is based on the availability of appropriate and reliable readily available data for the factors of production. The complainant did not provide sufficient evidence demonstrating that the proposed alternative benchmark accurately reflected undistorted costs in Brazil or that it was more appropriate than the benchmark data available for the selected representative country. Accordingly, the Commission considered that the existence of domestic production capacity in Brazil did not alter its assessment.
recital 231recital 231
(231) The complainant further criticised the choice of Indonesia as representative country due to absence of Indonesian producer of acrylic esters with readily available financial statements and that the Commission had to rely on a producer of formaldehyde as a proxy for SG & A and profit. According to the complainant, formaldehyde production was not technically or economically comparable to acrylic esters manufacturing, and the absence of financial data from an actual or closely comparable producer constituted an additional reason why Indonesia was not a suitable representative country under Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 232recital 232
(232) The Commission rejected this claim. As explained in recitals (215) to (223), the selection of the representative country was based on the criteria set out in Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation and the availability of the best relevant readily available information.
recital 233recital 233
(233) While the Commission acknowledged that no standalone financial statements of an Indonesian producer of the product under investigation were readily available, the complainants did not identify any alternative Indonesian company that would be more comparable, nor did they submit any alternative representative country that would provide more appropriate relevant readily available financial information while satisfying the relevant selection criteria.
recital 234recital 234
(234) Accordingly, the Commission considered that the use of the selected proxy company did not preclude the selection of Indonesia as the representative country.
recital 235recital 235
(235) In the alternative, the complainant proposed a hybrid methodology for the construction of normal value. They argued that the Commission should use Brazil as the source of the factor of production benchmarks, while relying on the financial statements of Intanwijaya Internasional in Indonesia for the calculation of SG & A and profit.
recital 236recital 236
(236) They submitted that Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation and the Commission’s previous practice allowed the use of different undistorted sources for different elements of the constructed normal value, where this results in more appropriate benchmark data.
recital 237recital 237
(237) The Commission noted that there was no need for such an approach as all data necessary to construct the normal value was available in the appropriate representative country. Indeed, as explained in recitals (215) to (223), the Commission established that appropriate readily available data were available in Indonesia for the construction of the normal value.
recital 238recital 238
(238) Finally, the complainant argued that while applying the methodology explained in recital (223) and selecting a company within the same NACE code as acrylic esters, the Commission should have also selected another active producer of formaldehyde in Indonesia (i.e. PT Duta Pertiwi Nusantara Tbk) with publicly available standalone financial statements for 2025, alongside Intanwijaya Internasional.
recital 239recital 239
(239) The Commission analysed the 2025 financial accounts of PT Duta Pertiwi Nusantara Tbk and concluded that the company could not be regarded as a source of undistorted and reasonable amounts for SG & A costs and for profit, since its financial performance did not reflect normal operating conditions. According to its published audited accounts, the company permanently ceased production in February 2025 ( 141 ) , resulting in revenue falling by approximately 84 % compared with 2024; SG & A expenses amounted to around 100 % of net sales, reflecting fixed overheads spread over a reduced sales base; and the net result was primarily attributable to non-operating income. The claim was therefore rejected.
recital 240recital 240
3.2.4.4. Level of social and environmental protection
(240) Having established that Indonesia was the only available appropriate representative country, based on all of the above elements, there was no need to carry out an assessment of the level of social and environmental protection in accordance with the last sentence of Article 2(6a)(a) first indent of the basic Regulation.
recital 241recital 241
3.2.4.5. Conclusion
(241) In view of the above analysis, Indonesia met the criteria laid down in Article 2(6a)(a), first indent of the basic Regulation to be considered as an appropriate representative country.
recital 242recital 242
3.2.5. Sources used to establish undistorted costs
(242) In the FOP Note, the Commission listed the factors of production such as raw materials, energy and labour used in the production of the product under investigation by the exporting producers and invited interested parties to comment and propose publicly available information on undistorted values for each of the factors of production mentioned in that note
recital 243recital 243
(243) The FOP Note stated that to construct the normal value in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation, the Commission would use GTA to establish the undistorted cost of the factors of production, notably the raw materials. In addition, the Commission set out the sources for other factors of production.
recital 244recital 244
(244) Due to the large number of factors of production of the sampled exporting producers that provided complete information and the negligible weight of some of the raw materials in the total cost of production, these negligible items would be grouped under ‘consumables’.
recital 245recital 245
(245) The percentage of the consumables would be calculated on the total cost of raw materials and applied to the recalculated cost of raw materials when using the established undistorted benchmarks in the appropriate representative country.
recital 246recital 246
3.2.6. Undistorted costs and benchmarks
3.2.6.1. Factors of production
(246) Considering all the information submitted by the interested parties and collected during the verification visits, the following factors of production and their sources have been identified in order to determine the normal value in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation: Table 1 Factors of production Factor of Production Commodity Code (HS6) Unit of measurement Unit value Source RAW MATERIALS Propylene 2901 22 MT 6 037 CNY/t GTA n-Butanol 2905 13 MT 6 036 CNY/t GTA 2-Ethylhexanol 2905 16 MT 8 064 CNY/t GTA Acrylic acid and its salts 2916 11 MT 8 029 CNY/t GTA Propane 2711 12 MT 3 850 CNY/t GTA LABOUR COSTS n/a Hours worked 46,16 CNY/h ERI SalaryExpert ELECTRICITY n/a kWh 0,47 CNY/kWh Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN)
recital 247recital 247
(247) The Commission included a value for manufacturing overhead costs to cover costs not included in the factors of production referred to above. The methodology is duly explained in section 3.2.6.6.
recital 248recital 248
3.2.6.2. Raw materials
(248) To establish the undistorted price of raw materials as delivered at the gate of a representative country producer, the Commission used as a basis the weighted average import price to the representative country as reported in GTA to which import duties and transport costs were added.
recital 249recital 249
(249) An import price in the representative country was determined as a weighted average of unit prices of imports from all third countries excluding China and countries which are not members of the WTO, listed in Annex I of Regulation (EU) 2015/755 of the European Parliament and the Council ( 142 ) .
recital 250recital 250
(250) The Commission decided to exclude imports from China into the representative country as it concluded in recital (107) that it is not appropriate to use domestic prices and costs in China due to the existence of significant distortions in accordance with Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation. Given that there is no evidence showing that the same distortions do not equally affect products intended for export, the Commission considered that the same distortions affected export prices.
recital 251recital 251
(251) The Commission expressed the transport cost incurred by the cooperating exporting producer for the supply of raw materials as a percentage of the actual cost of such raw materials and then applied the same percentage to the undistorted cost of the same raw materials to obtain the undistorted transport cost. The Commission considered that, in the context of this investigation, the ratio between the exporting producer’s raw material and the reported transport costs could be reasonably used as an indication to estimate the undistorted transport costs of raw materials when delivered to the company’s factory.
recital 252recital 252
3.2.6.3. Labour
(252) In the FOP Note, the Commission indicated that it would use the information provided by ERI SalaryExpert ( 143 ) on the average salary for chemical workers in Indonesia, based on salary surveys collected from Indonesian employers and employees. It also indicated that it would add the mandatory additional labour related costs borne by the employer, including the work accident insurance (JKK), the old age benefit (JHT), the life insurance (JKM), the contribution to the pension scheme (JP) and the national health insurance (BPJS) ( 144 ) .
recital 253recital 253
(253) Following the FOP Note, the complainant argued that the Commission underestimated the actual Indonesian employers’ labour costs. In particular:
recital 254recital 254
(254) The complainant disagreed with the Commission's use of an average rate for the JKK, which can range from 0,24 % to 1,74 % of wages, depending on how dangerous the job is. Since acrylic esters production is a high-risk petrochemical process, the JKK rate should be applied at the maximum rate (1,74 %), corresponding to the highest risk category in the BPJS risk classification ( 145 ) , rather than at a lower rate within the 0,24 %–1,74 % range.
recital 255recital 255
(255) The religious holiday bonus (THR) and the contribution to the unemployment insurance programme (JKP) were not included among the mandatory additional labour related costs paid by employers.
recital 256recital 256
(256) The Commission relied on a national average labour cost for chemical workers. Instead, it should have applied either the sectoral minimum wage for Banten, where the sole identified Indonesian producer, PT Nippon Shokubai Indonesia, is located, multiplied by 2,5 to reflect experienced worker pay levels, or specific data drawn from BPS’s Statistics of Indonesia Manufacturing Industry 2023 ( 146 ) publication.
recital 257recital 257
(257) First, acrylic esters production is not explicitly listed in the BPJS risk classification. However, according to Indonesia’s official standard industrial classification system (KBLI) ( 147 ) , the basic chemical industry from petroleum, natural gas and coal is classified as a high-risk industry. Therefore, given its hazardous nature, the Commission considered it plausible that acrylic esters production fell under the BPJS highest risk category. On this basis, the Commission agreed with the complainant that the maximum rate of 1,74 % should be applied in the calculation of the hourly labour cost, rather than an average.
recital 258recital 258
(258) Second, the Commission found that the THR, equivalent to one full month's gross wage, was indeed a mandatory charge ( 148 ) , and should therefore be added to the calculation of the labour cost. However, the Commission found that the JKP was not an additional cost for the employer, since the employer-funded portion of the JKP was included in the JKK contribution itself, not paid separately on top of it ( 149 ) . Therefore, no addition for JKP was warranted.
recital 259recital 259
(259) Last, the Commission considered that national averages remained a reliable benchmark as the data pooled by ERI SalaryExpert were actual data from a broad and representative dataset of chemical workers. Moreover, the proposed 2,5 multiplier for experienced worker pay, to be applied on sectoral minimum wages, was unsubstantiated, and in any event the resulting figure would not depart considerably from the salary level used by the Commission. As regards the suggested use of specific data from BPS’s Statistics of Indonesia Manufacturing Industry 2023 publication, the Commission was unable to identify the relevant data within that source, nor did the complainant provide it.
recital 260recital 260
3.2.6.4. Electricity
(260) In the FOP Note, the Commission indicated that it intended to use the price of electricity for companies (industrial users) in Indonesia as published by GlobalPetrolPrices. The Commission used the published business electricity price for December 2025 ( 150 ) . The tariff of GlobalPetrolPrices was based on the energy rate of the sole Indonesian provider Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN).
recital 261recital 261
(261) Following the FOP Note, the complainant argued that the PLN was subsidised by the Indonesian government and its electricity tariff was therefore not a genuine undistorted market price.
recital 262recital 262
(262) The complainant also claimed that the price from GlobalPetrolPrices.com reflected only the base energy tariff, but did not include additional mandatory billing components like demand charges, time-of-use peak multipliers, reactive power penalties, and VAT.
recital 263recital 263
(263) The Commission found that Indonesian electricity tariffs were divided into subsidised and non-subsidised categories. While subsidised tariff rates were intended for small and disadvantaged households with low voltage needs ( 151 ) , the industrial tariff used by the Commission and applicable to medium-voltage industrial consumers was not identified as a subsidised tariff. The Commission therefore considered that the existence of subsidies for certain PLN customers did not establish that the industrial tariff used by the Commission was subsidised or distorted. The claim was therefore rejected.
recital 264recital 264
(264) As to the second claim, the Commission analysed the tariff rates for industrial users (category I-3) as published by PLN ( 152 ) . For this category, the additional billing components are inapplicable in practice.
recital 265recital 265
(265) There is no standing demand charge: the tariff only includes a minimum-billing floor equal to 40 hours of consumption at the contracted capacity, which is not triggered under normal industrial utilisation levels.
recital 266recital 266
(266) No time-of-use surcharge is being charged, since PLN currently bills peak and off-peak hours at the same rate.
recital 267recital 267
(267) Reactive energy is the electricity needed to sustain alternating electromagnetic field in inductive equipment like motors and transformers, without doing any direct mechanical work. It still uses grid capacity and therefore electricity providers charge extra when a facility uses too much of it relative to its real electricity consumption. Indonesia sets its no-penalty threshold at a power factor ( 153 ) of 0,85. China’s own regulations set a stricter standard and require industrial users to maintain a power factor of 0,90 ( 154 ) . Applying Indonesia’s own compliance threshold, a facility maintaining the power factor required under China’s own rules would incur no reactive-energy surcharge.
recital 268recital 268
(268) Lastly, VAT is a fully recoverable input tax for a VAT-registered industrial purchaser. The claims were therefore rejected.
recital 269recital 269
(269) However, the Commission recalculated the electricity benchmark using the tariff published by PLN but adjusting it to reflect the mandatory regional street-lighting tax ( 155 ) , calculated as a percentage of the billed electricity amount.
recital 270recital 270
3.2.6.5. Consumables
(270) Due to the large number of factors of production of the sampled exporting producers that provided complete information and the negligible weight of some of the raw materials in the total cost of production, some of the factors of production were considered consumables. The Commission calculated the percentage of the consumables in the total cost of production and applied this percentage to the recalculated cost of production based on benchmarks.
recital 271recital 271
3.2.6.6. Manufacturing overhead costs, SG&A costs and profit
(271) According to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation, ‘the constructed normal value shall include an undistorted and reasonable amount for administrative, selling and general costs and for profits’. In addition, a value for manufacturing overhead costs needs to be established to cover costs not included in the factors of production referred to above.
recital 272recital 272
(272) The manufacturing overheads incurred by the cooperating exporting producers were expressed as a share of the costs of manufacturing actually incurred by the exporting producers. This percentage was applied to the undistorted costs of manufacturing.
recital 273recital 273
(273) For establishing an undistorted and reasonable amount for SG & A costs and profit, the Commission initially relied on the financial data for 2025 for Intanwijaya Internasional as extracted from Orbis.
recital 274recital 274
(274) Following the FOP Note, the exporting producers Pinghu Petro and Huayi submitted that Intanwijaya Internasional’s actual financial statements, which were publicly available, should be used because they provided considerably more detail than the Orbis data used by the Commission.
recital 275recital 275
(275) Based on the information reported in Intanwijaya Internasional’s 2025 financial statements ( 156 ) , the SG & A costs included freight expenses. Pinghu Petro and Huayi claimed that, as freight expenses were already deducted from the export price, these expenses should be excluded from the SG & A in line with the Commission’s practice.
recital 276recital 276
(276) Based on the detailed breakdown of the SG & A in the Intanwijaya Internasional’s financial statements, the Commission agreed that freight expenses should be excluded from the SG & A costs to allow the constructed normal value to be adjusted to the same level of trade as the export price.
recital 277recital 277
3.2.7. Calculation of normal value
(277) On the basis of the above, the Commission constructed the normal value per product type on an ex-works basis in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 278recital 278
(278) First, the Commission established the undistorted manufacturing costs. The Commission applied the undistorted unit costs to the actual consumption of the individual factors of production of the cooperating exporting producer. These consumption rates were verified during the verification. The Commission multiplied the usage factors by the undistorted costs per unit observed in the representative country, as described in Section 3.2.6.2.
recital 279recital 279
(279) Once the undistorted manufacturing cost was established, the Commission applied the manufacturing overheads, SG & A cost and profit as noted in recitals (272) and (273).
recital 280recital 280
(280) SG&A costs expressed as a percentage of the Costs of Goods Sold (‘COGS’) and applied to the undistorted costs of production, amounted to 13,43 %. The profit expressed as a percentage of the COGS and applied to the undistorted costs of production, amounted to 10,40 %.
recital 281recital 281
(281) On that basis, the Commission constructed the normal value per product type on an ex-works basis in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 282recital 282
3.2.8. Export price
(282) For the exporting producers that exported the product concerned directly to independent customers in the Union, the export price was the price actually paid or payable for the product concerned when sold for export to the Union, in accordance with Article 2(8) of the basic Regulation.
recital 283recital 283
(283) For the exporting producers that exported to the Union through unrelated traders, the export price was the price actually paid or payable by the first unrelated customers (i.e. the unrelated traders) for the product concerned when sold for export to the Union, in accordance with Article 2(8) of the basic Regulation.
recital 284recital 284
3.2.9. Comparison
(284) Article 2(10) of the basic Regulation requires the Commission to make a fair comparison between the normal value and the export price at the same level of trade and to make allowances for differences in factors which affect prices and price comparability.
recital 285recital 285
(285) The Commission chose in this case to compare the normal value and the export price of the sampled exporting producers at the ex works level of trade ( 157 ) . As further explained below, where appropriate, the normal value and the export price were adjusted in order to: (i) net them back to the ex works level; and (ii) make allowances for differences in factors which were claimed, and demonstrated, to affect prices and price comparability.
recital 286recital 286
3.2.9.1. Adjustments made to the normal value
(286) The normal value was established at the ex works level of trade by using costs of production together with amounts for SG & A costs and for profit, which were considered to be reasonable for that level of trade.
recital 287recital 287
3.2.9.2. Adjustments made to the export price
(287) In order to net the export price back to the ex works level of trade, allowances were made for freight, insurance, handling, loading and ancillary expenses.
recital 288recital 288
(288) Allowances were made for the following factors affecting prices and price comparability: credit cost and bank charges.
recital 289recital 289
3.2.10. Dumping margins
3.2.10.1. For the cooperating exporting producers
(289) For the sampled exporting producers, the Commission compared the weighted average normal value of each type of the like product with the weighted average export price of the corresponding type of the product concerned, in accordance with Article 2(11) and (12) of the basic Regulation.
recital 290recital 290
(290) For the non-sampled cooperating exporting producers, the Commission calculated the weighted average dumping margin, in accordance with Article 9(6) of the basic Regulation.
recital 291recital 291
(291) Therefore, that margin was established based on the margins of the sampled exporting producers.
recital 292recital 292
3.2.10.2. For non-cooperating companies
(292) For all other exports the Commission established the dumping margin on the basis of the facts available in accordance with Article 18 of the basic Regulation. To this end, the Commission determined the level of cooperation of the exporting producers.
recital 293recital 293
(293) The level of cooperation is the quantity of exports of the cooperating exporting producers to the Union expressed as a proportion of the total imports from the country concerned to the Union in the IP taken from Eurostat data.
recital 294recital 294
(294) The level of cooperation in this case was high because the exports of the cooperating exporting producers constituted more than 90% of the total imports during the IP. On this basis, the Commission decided to establish the dumping margin for all other imports at the level of the cooperating sampled company with the highest dumping margin.
recital 295recital 295
(295) The provisional dumping margins, expressed as a percentage of the CIF Union frontier price, duty unpaid, are as follows: Country Company Provisional dumping margin (%) China Shanghai Huayi New Material Co., Ltd. 29,0 Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd. 22,3 Other Chinese cooperating companies in Annex 23,9 All other imports originating in China 29,0
recital 296recital 296
3.3. The United States of America
3.3.1. Normal value
(296) One exporting producer, The Dow Chemical Company Group (‘Dow US’), comprising the producers Rohm & Haas (R & H) and Union Carbide Corporation (UCC), cooperated with the investigation. No other exporting producers in the USA, that exported during the IP to the EU, were identified.
recital 297recital 297
(297) The Commission first examined whether Dow US’s total volume of domestic sales was representative, in accordance with Article 2(2) of the basic Regulation. The domestic sales are representative if the total domestic sales volume of the like product to independent customers on the domestic market per exporting producer represented at least 5 % of its total export sales volume of the product concerned to the Union during the investigation period. On that basis, the total sales of Dow US of the like product on the domestic market were representative.
recital 298recital 298
(298) The Commission subsequently identified the product types sold domestically by Dow US that were identical or comparable with the product types sold for export to the Union with representative domestic sales.
recital 299recital 299
(299) The Commission then examined whether the domestic sales by Dow US on its domestic market for each product type that is identical or comparable with a product type sold for export to the Union were representative, in accordance with Article 2(2) of the basic Regulation. The domestic sales of a product type are representative if the total volume of domestic sales of that product type to independent customers during the investigation period represents at least 5 % of the total volume of export sales of the identical or comparable product type to the Union. The Commission established that the domestic sales of each product type were representative for the exporting producer.
recital 300recital 300
(300) The Commission next defined the proportion of profitable sales to independent customers in the domestic market for each product type during the investigation period in order to decide whether to use actual domestic sales for the calculation of the normal value, in accordance with Article 2(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 301recital 301
(301) The normal value is based on the actual domestic price per product type, irrespective of whether those sales are profitable or not, if: (a) the sales volume of the product type, sold at a net sales price equal to or above the calculated cost of production, represented more than 80 % of the total sales volume of that product type; and (b) the weighted average sales price of that product type is equal to or higher than the unit cost of production.
recital 302recital 302
(302) In this case, the normal value is the weighted average of the prices of all domestic sales of that product type during the IP.
recital 303recital 303
(303) The normal value is the actual domestic price per product type of only the profitable domestic sales of the product types during the IP, if: (a) the volume of profitable sales of the product type represents 80 % or less of the total sales volume of that type; or (b) the weighted average price of this product type is below the unit cost of production.
recital 304recital 304
(304) The analysis of domestic sales showed that less than 80 % of all domestic sales of the product types that are identical or comparable with the product types sold for export to the Union were profitable. Accordingly, for all product types, the normal value was calculated as actual domestic price per product type of only the profitable domestic sales of the product types during the IP.
recital 305recital 305
3.3.2. Export price
(305) Dow Chemical exported to the Union indirectly through Dow Europe, a related importer located in Switzerland.
recital 306recital 306
(306) The export price for sales made through Dow Europe was established on the basis of the price at which the imported product was first resold to independent customers in the Union, in accordance with Article 2(9) of the basic Regulation. In this case, adjustments to the price were made for all costs incurred between importation and resale, including SG & A costs, and for profits accruing.
recital 307recital 307
(307) The profit of Dow Europe was found to be fully affected by the association between the two companies as it was directly allocated by Dow US. The transfer price therefore was not a price that would have been established in a negotiation with an independent importer. The Commission therefore concluded that the profit margin of Dow Europe was not reasonable. Pursuant to Article 2(9) of the basic Regulation, it is considered appropriate to use a reasonable profit margin independent of the actual profit resulting from the transfer price in order to avoid any distorting effects that may arise from the transfer price, in line with established case-law of Union courts.
recital 308recital 308
(308) Two unrelated importers cooperated with the investigation, but were loss-making. In the absence of any reasonable profit provided by the cooperating unrelated importers, the Commission decided to resort to the profit margin used in a previous proceeding concerning another chemical product manufactured by a similar industry and imported under similar circumstances, namely a profit margin of 6,89 % ( 158 ) established in the polyvinyl alcohols (‘PVA’) investigation. In the Commission’s view that profit margin is the most objective basis available for the purpose of arriving at a satisfactory estimate of an arm's length export price.
recital 309recital 309
3.3.3. Comparison
(309) Article 2(10) of the basic Regulation requires the Commission to make a fair comparison between the normal value and the export price at the same level of trade and to make allowances for differences in factors which affect prices and price comparability. In the case at hand the Commission chose to compare the normal value and the export price of the sampled exporting producers at the ex-works level of trade. As further explained below, where appropriate, the normal value and the export price were adjusted in order to: (i) net them back to the ex-works level; and (ii) make allowances for differences in factors which were claimed, and demonstrated, to affect prices and price comparability.
recital 310recital 310
(310) In order to net the export price back to the ex-works level of trade, adjustments were made on the account of customs duty, other import charges, freight, insurance, handling loading and ancillary expenses.
recital 311recital 311
(311) Allowances were made for the following factors affecting prices and price comparability: credit cost, bank charges and commissions.
recital 312recital 312
3.3.4. Dumping margins
3.3.4.1. For the cooperating exporting producer
(312) For the cooperating exporting producer, the Commission compared the weighted average normal value of each type of the like product with the weighted average export price of the corresponding type of the product concerned, in accordance with Article 2(11) and (12) of the basic Regulation.
recital 313recital 313
3.3.4.2. For all other exports
(313) For all other exports the Commission established the dumping margin on the basis of the facts available in accordance with Article 18 of the basic Regulation. To this end, the Commission determined the level of cooperation of the exporting producers.
recital 314recital 314
(314) Because the exports of the cooperating exporting producer constituted all of the imports from the USA during the IP, the Commission decided to establish the dumping margin for all other imports at the level of the cooperating company.
recital 315recital 315
(315) On this basis, the provisional dumping margins, expressed as a percentage of the CIF Union frontier price, duty unpaid, are as follows: Country Company Provisional dumping margin (%) United States of America Dow Chemical Company 61,9 All other imports originating in the USA 61,9
recital 316recital 316
(316) In Dow’s view, if the Commission does not terminate the investigation with respect to the USA, imports by Dow from the USA destined for captive use should be excluded from the scope of any anti-dumping duties.
recital 317recital 317
(317) The approach proposed by Dow was not found to be tenable, as such possibility is not foreseen under the applicable legal framework. Duties imposed are applicable to imports from a given country concerned, irrespective of the exporter and any affiliation that the exporter may have with the buyers in the Union. Moreover, as established, the USA imports of Dow were in competition with the domestic Union industry sales, irrespective of whether they ultimately ended up at related Dow entities or on the merchant market. Any exclusion from duties would therefore frustrate the objective of restoring fair trade in the Union that the imposition of duties has. Dow’s claim was therefore dismissed.
recital 318recital 318
3.4. The Republic of South Africa
3.4.1. Normal value
(318) One exporting producer, Sasol South Africa, cooperated with the investigation. No other exporting producers in South Africa were identified.
recital 319recital 319
(319) The Commission first examined whether the total volume of domestic sales by Sasol was representative, in accordance with Article 2(2) of the basic Regulation. The domestic sales are representative if the total domestic sales volume of the like product to independent customers on the domestic market per exporting producer represented at least 5 % of its total export sales volume of the product concerned to the Union during the investigation period.
recital 320recital 320
(320) The Commission subsequently identified the product types sold domestically by Sasol that were identical or comparable with the product types sold for export to the Union with representative domestic sales.
recital 321recital 321
(321) The Commission then examined whether the domestic sales by Sasol on its domestic market for each product type that is identical or comparable with a product type sold for export to the Union were representative, in accordance with Article 2(2) of the basic Regulation. The domestic sales of a product type are representative if the total volume of domestic sales of that product type to independent customers during the investigation period represents at least 5 % of the total volume of export sales of the identical or comparable product type to the Union.
recital 322recital 322
(322) Although the Commission found that the quantity of domestic sales was representative, all sales on the domestic market were lossmaking during the IP. As a result, the Commission constructed normal value based on the cost of manufacturing, plus amounts for SG & A costs and for profit.
recital 323recital 323
(323) As there were no SG & A costs or profit made in the ordinary course of trade, the Commission used the provisions of Article 2(6) of the basic Regulation as follows to determine the SG & A costs and profit to be added to the cost of manufacturing of Sasol South Africa:
recital 324recital 324
(324) In the absence of any other cooperating exporting producer in the country concerned, the SG & A expenses and profit could not be established under Article 2(6)(a) of the basic Regulation. The Commission also considered whether SG & A expenses and profit could be established on the basis of amounts realised by the exporting producer on production and sales, in the ordinary course of trade, of the same general category of products on the South African domestic market, in accordance with Article 2(6)(b) of the basic Regulation. However, these sales of the same general category of products were found to be unprofitable.
recital 325recital 325
(325) The Commission could neither base the SG & A expenses and profit on the data of any of the other cooperating exporting producers covered by this investigation, due to confidentiality reasons.
recital 326recital 326
(326) The Commission therefore based the SG & A costs and profit on the basis of a reasonable method set out in Article 2(6)(c) of the basic Regulation, namely the SG & A costs linked to the domestic sales of the product under investigation and used the profit made by Sasol as a whole as the profit normally realised.
recital 327recital 327
(327) The Commission determined that the profit of Sasol used to construct normal value was below the profit cap mandated by Article 2(6)(c) of the basic Regulation.
recital 328recital 328
3.4.2. Export price
(328) All sales of Sasol South Africa to the Union were made through a related importer in Germany. The export price was therefore established on the basis of the price at which the imported product was first resold to independent customers in the Union, in accordance with Article 2(9) of the basic Regulation.
recital 329recital 329
(329) In this case, adjustments to the price were made for all costs incurred between importation and resale, including SG & A expenses, and for a reasonable profit. In accordance with Article 2(9) of the basic Regulation, the reported profit of the related importer was 6,89 %, as set out in recital (308) above.
recital 330recital 330
3.4.3. Comparison
3.4.3.1. Adjustments made to the normal value
(330) The normal value was established at the ex works level of trade by using costs of production together with amounts for SG & A costs and for profit, which were considered to be reasonable for that level of trade. No adjustments were necessary to net the normal value back to the ex works level.
recital 331recital 331
3.4.3.2. Adjustments made to the export price
(331) In order to net the export price back to the ex works level of trade, allowances were made for freight, insurance, handling, loading and ancillary expenses.
recital 332recital 332
(332) Allowances were then made for credit cost and commissions that affected prices and price comparability.
recital 333recital 333
3.4.4. Dumping margins
3.4.4.1. For the cooperating exporting producer
(333) For the cooperating exporting producer, the Commission compared the weighted average normal value of each type of the like product with the weighted average export price of the corresponding type of the product concerned, in accordance with Article 2(11) and (12) of the basic Regulation.
recital 334recital 334
3.4.4.2. For all other exports
(334) For all other exports the Commission established the dumping margin on the basis of the facts available in accordance with Article 18 of the basic Regulation. To this end, the Commission determined the level of cooperation of the exporting producers.
recital 335recital 335
(335) Because the exports of the cooperating exporting producer constituted the total imports from South Africa during the IP, the Commission decided to establish the dumping margin for all other imports at the level of the cooperating exporting producer.
recital 336recital 336
(336) On this basis, the provisional dumping margins, expressed as a percentage of the CIF Union frontier price, duty unpaid, are as follows: Country Company Provisional dumping margin (%) South Africa Sasol South Africa Ltd 83,1 All other imports originating in South Africa 83,1
recital 337recital 337
3.5. Provisional dumping margins
(337) The provisional dumping margins, expressed as a percentage of the CIF Union frontier price, duty unpaid, are as follows: Country Company Provisional dumping margin (%) China Shanghai Huayi New Material Co., Ltd. 29,0 Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd. 22,3 Other Chinese cooperating companies in Annex 23,9 All other imports originating in China 29,0 Saudi Arabia All imports originating in Saudi Arabia 40,3 South Africa Sasol South Africa Ltd 83,1 All other imports originating in South Africa 83,1 United States of America Dow Chemical Company 61,9 All other imports originating in the USA 61,9
recital 338recital 338
4. INJURY
4.1. Definition of the Union industry and Union production
(338) The like product was manufactured by four producers in the Union during the investigation period. They constitute the ‘Union industry’ within the meaning of Article 4(1) of the basic Regulation.
recital 339recital 339
(339) The total Union production during the investigation period was established at around 490 000 tonnes. The Commission established the figure based on the verified questionnaire replies by the sampled producers and the questionnaire reply submitted by Dow Europe GmbH (‘Dow Europe’ or ‘Dow’). The sampled Union producers and Dow Europe accounted for the totality of the Union production of the like product.
recital 340recital 340
4.2. Determination of the relevant Union market
(340) To establish whether the Union industry suffered injury and to determine consumption and the various economic indicators related to the situation of the Union industry, the Commission examined whether and to what extent the subsequent use of the Union industry’s production of the like product had to be taken into account in the analysis.
recital 341recital 341
(341) The Commission found that a substantial part of the sampled Union producers’ AE production was destined for captive use (around 55% over the period considered) by the Union producers or their related companies for the downstream production of acrylic dispersions or additives. The product was often simply transferred (without invoice) and/or delivered at transfer prices within the same group of companies (which did not have a free choice of supplier) for further downstream processing.
recital 342recital 342
(342) The distinction between captive and free market is relevant for the injury analysis because products destined for captive use are not exposed to direct competition from imports. By contrast, production destined for free market sale is in direct competition with imports of the product concerned.
recital 343recital 343
(343) To provide a picture of the Union industry that is as complete as possible, the Commission obtained data for the entire AE activity and determined whether the production was destined for captive use or for the free market.
recital 344recital 344
(344) The Commission examined certain economic indicators relating to the Union industry on the basis of data for the free market. These indicators are sales volume and sales prices on the Union market; market share; growth; export volume and prices; profitability; return on investment; and cash flow. Where justified, the findings of the examination were compared with the data for the captive market to provide a more complete picture of the situation of the Union industry.
recital 345recital 345
(345) Other economic indicators could meaningfully be examined only by referring to the whole activity, including the captive use of the Union industry. These are: production; capacity, capacity utilisation; investments; stocks; employment; productivity; wages; and ability to raise capital. They depend on the whole activity, whether the production is captive or sold on the free market.
recital 346recital 346
(346) Since the captive consumption showed a smaller decrease than the consumption on the free market and followed the same pattern as the evolution of free market consumption over the majority of the period considered (the share of captive consumption constituted 38-41% of the total Union consumption over the entirety of the period considered), the analysis of the captive market was limited and the main focus rested with the situation on the free market in the Union,
recital 347recital 347
4.3. Union consumption
(347) The Commission established the Union consumption based on the verified questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers, of the US exporter (‘Dow US’), of the South African exporter (‘Sasol’), the reply to the macro questionnaire by Dow Europe, and Eurostat.
recital 348recital 348
(348) Union consumption developed as follow: Table 2 Union consumption (tonnes) 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Total Union consumption 622 883 538 948 595 340 562 010 Index 100 87 96 90 Free market [340 056 –415 623 ] [299 113 –365 582 ] [331 484 – 405 146 ] [299 316 –365 831 ] Index 100 88 97 88 Captive market [220 538 –269 547 ] [185 940 –227 260 ] [204 322 –249 727 ] [206 492 –252 379 ] Index 100 84 93 94 Source: Sampled Union producers Macro questionnaire reply of Dow Europe Eurostat, Sasol and Dow US questionnaire.
recital 349recital 349
(349) The Union consumption (both on the free market as well as total consumption) reached its highest level at the beginning of the period considered. High demand in 2022 and considerable restocking of the material was triggered by the previous COVID-19 crisis which had significantly disrupted the supply chain and tightened the supply of AE. In 2023, demand declined sharply due to high inflation and reduced economic activity, which particularly impacted key downstream sectors for AE producers, such as construction, adhesives, coatings and automotive. In 2024, macroeconomic conditions stabilized with easing inflation and improved demand sentiment, leading to a temporary recovery in demand. However, demand in the IP again decreased relative to 2024, with renewed, moderate destocking by users over the year.
recital 350recital 350
4.4. Imports from the countries concerned
4.4.1. Cumulative assessment of the effects of imports from the countries concerned
(350) The Commission examined whether imports of AE originating in the countries concerned should be assessed cumulatively, in accordance with Article 3(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 351recital 351
(351) The margin of dumping established in relation to the imports from all countries concerned was above the de minimis threshold laid down in Article 9(3) of the basic Regulation. The volume of imports from each of the countries concerned was not negligible within the meaning of Article 5(7) of the basic Regulation. Market shares in the investigation period were [11–13] % for the US, [8–10] % for China, [4–6] % for South Africa and [4–6] % for Saudi Arabia.
recital 352recital 352
(352) The conditions of competition between the dumped imports from the countries concerned and between the dumped imports from the countries concerned and the like product were similar. More specifically, the imported AE competed with each other and with the AE produced in the Union because they were sold ultimately to industrial users. Furthermore, the imports from the countries concerned were all in competition with each other and the Union production, because their pricing was based on ICIS ( 159 ) indices. The imports all consisted of AE sharing the same basic characteristics meaning that they were fully interchangeable. AE are considered commodity products that are comparable regardless of their origin. Moreover, imports from all the countries concerned followed largely similar price patterns over the entirety of the period considered.
recital 353recital 353
(353) Therefore, all the criteria set out in Article 3(4) of the basic Regulation were met and imports from all the countries concerned were examined cumulatively for the purposes of the injury determination.
recital 354recital 354
(354) Dow argued that the Commission should not cumulate imports from the USA with imports from the other countries concerned, in particular, China. Dow claimed that the USA imports were consistently present in Union even prior to the period considered (unlike for example Chinese imports), they declined in the period considered and represented a small share of the Union consumption. Dow also claimed that import from the USA were not subject to similar conditions of competition as imports from China, as EU market prices were driven by the exceptionally low prices of Chinese imports of AE.
recital 355recital 355
(355) Moreover, Dow maintained that only a limited volume of imports of AE from the USA is sold on the Union free market and most of its imports are used captively, while these captive volumes do not compete with free market sales and do not exert price pressure on the EU market.
recital 356recital 356
(356) As outlined in recitals (351)-(352), conditions for cumulative assessment were met for the USA imports and hence the USA imports were assessed together with imports from the other countries concerned and were not subject to individual assessment in this case. Neither continued presence on the Union market prior to the period considered, nor the alleged evolution of import volumes or prices (which in any event followed the same price pattern as import prices from other countries concerned) over the period considered could invalidate this determination in the fact of the findings made regarding the similarity of conditions of competition.
recital 357recital 357
(357) In relation to the nature of USA imports entering the Union, for the purposes of this case and for the evaluation of macro-indicators, all USA imports were treated as imports that are sold or capable to be sold on the free market. In this respect, the Commission noted that imports, whether captive or not, are in direct competition with the free sales of the Union industry and may cause injury to them, as each import represents a potentially lost sale. Furthermore, contrary to what Dow US claimed, their exports were sold in significant quantities ([15–25] kt) on the Union free market. In view of the above the claim was rejected
recital 358recital 358
(358) Gantrade Europe BV (‘Gantrade’), a cooperating unrelated importer, argued that the conditions for the cumulative assessment of imports from the countries concerned were not met in the present case. According to Gantrade, given the differences in captive use (large part of USA exports is for captive use), tariff treatment (South Africa benefits from 0 % customs duty as opposed to imports from Saudi Arabia, the USA and China), import trends, and production methods (the South African producer uses coal-based chemistry for AE production), the conditions of competition were not comparable across the countries concerned.
recital 359recital 359
(359) Moreover, Sasol claimed that imports from South Africa should not be cumulated with those from the other countries concerned because of different competition conditions. More specifically, Sasol submitted that imports from South Africa do not compete with China, the United States, as well as the Union industry across the full scope of product types covered by the investigation, since South Africa only exported to the Union one AE product type (BA), which moreover does not have similar physical characteristics, nor is interchangeable with the other AE type (2EHA). Furthermore, Sasol also observed that South African import volumes were markedly lower relative to other countries concerned and that the South African prices followed prevailing market conditions rather than setting the prices.
recital 360recital 360
(360) Finally, according to Dow, imports from the USA were not subject to similar conditions of competition because import prices from the USA followed, rather than set, market prices.
recital 361recital 361
(361) Regarding Gantrade’s claims, it was established that all imports, whether captive or not, are in direct competition with the free sales of the Union industry and may cause injury to them, as each import represents a potentially lost sale. Furthermore, differences in production methods or in tariff treatment of certain imports are not factors materially affecting the determination as to whether conditions for cumulative assessment under Article 3(4)(b) are met. Instead, focus is on the overall conditions of competition in terms of pricing behaviour, sales channels, customers and interchangeability of the products imported and sold by the Union producers and the exporting producers in the other exporting countries.
recital 362recital 362
(362) With respect to Sasol’s claim, the fact that South Africa only imported one AE product type equally did not invalidate the conclusions drawn by the Commission. The product type imported by South Africa (BA) was the same as that produced and sold on the Union market by other countries concerned as well as by the Union industry. Therefore, South Africa’s imports were in competition with other imports and the Union industry. The fact that Chinese and USA exporters as well as the Union producers sold an additional AE product type does not detract from the Commission’s finding on cumulation of South African imports with other imports. Thus, the claim was rejected.
recital 363recital 363
(363) Moreover, and irrespective of the evolution of import volumes of the individual countries concerned, the price pattern followed by all countries concerned was the same. More specifically, the price followed a downward trend with the same price dynamics manifested over the period considered (prices peaking in 2022 to then sharply decline in 2023 and remain at low levels until the IP for all countries concerned). It was found to be equally immaterial whether the country concerned was considered a price setter or price taker on the market – important is that the imports from all countries concerned operated in the same market, were confronted with the same conditions and ultimately competed for the same customers.
recital 364recital 364
4.4.2. Volume and market share of the imports from the countries concerned
(364) In the present case, South Africa and the USA have each only one known exporting producer (Sasol and Dow US respectively). Exporters from both countries cooperated with the investigation. Therefore, to ensure the highest possible level of accuracy of import figures used, the Commission used as a basis for the import volumes of South Africa and the USA the export sales data for the period considered, as provided by both exporting producers.
recital 365recital 365
(365) Regarding China, in the absence of more granular statistics, the Commission used Eurostat figures for CN code 2916 12 00 (customs code under which product concerned is classified, which however may include also types of esters of acrylic acid other than product concerned) to estimate the volume of imports. In this respect, the Eurostat import statistics used for China in the IP were also consistent with the sampling replies submitted by the cooperating Chinese exporters of AE. which further confirmed the appropriateness of the methodology used by the Commission.
recital 366recital 366
(366) With respect to Saudi Arabia, Eurostat figures for the CN code 2916 12 00 were equally used considering the non-cooperation by the Saudi exporting producer and in the absence of more granular statistics. This was found to be in line with the sampling reply submitted by the Saudi exporting producer.
recital 367recital 367
(367) Imports into the Union from the countries concerned developed as follows: Table 3 Import quantity and market share on the free market 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period United States (tonnes) [40 543 –49 552 ] [50 935 –62 254 ] [44 328 –54 179 ] [35 141 –42 950 ] Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 126 109 87 China (tonnes) 51 994 33 298 45 483 29 772 Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 64 87 57 South Africa (tonnes) [6 939 –8 572 ] [12 898 –15 933 ] [13 043 –16 113 ] [13 600 –16 800 ] Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 186 188 196 Saudi Arabia (tonnes) 6 638 11 995 17 327 15 089 Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 181 261 227 Total imports from the countries concerned (tonnes) [106 252 –128 620 ] [111 209 –134 621 ] [121 040 –146 521 ] [94 912 –114 893 ] Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 105 114 89 Market share (%) 30 35 35 30 Index 100 119 117 101 Source: Eurostat, Sasol and Dow US questionnaire.
recital 368recital 368
(368) In absolute terms the imports from the countries concerned decreased during the period considered by less than 12 000 tonnes. However, this decrease in imports coincided with an almost four times higher drop in Union demand (over 45 000 tonnes). The total market share of the imports of the countries concerned reached high levels already in 2022 amid active stockpiling activity, increasing gradually from 30 % in 2022 to reach a 35 % market share in 2023-2024. While the market share of imports decreased in the investigation period, it remained consistently high (30 %) and at the levels observed at the beginning of the period considered.
recital 369recital 369
(369) Gantrade claimed that an objective analysis would require an examination of import trends prior to 2022 to accurately contextualize the import data during the period considered. According to Gantrade, imports from the countries concerned were already present in the Union before the period considered, and reached their peak in 2021, when they filled the supply gap created by decreased imports from Taiwan and South Korea. In Gantrade’s view, following 2022, imports generally followed a decreasing trend in line with contraction in demand, while import prices also started naturally to decrease.
recital 370recital 370
(370) As a preliminary remark, the period considered should be long enough to enable the Commission to duly evaluate all relevant economic factors and indices having a bearing on the state of the Union industry. In the present case, the Commission, in accordance with its standard practice, selected a period of three full years as well as the investigation period for examination of the macro- and microeconomic trends and indicators. It was further noted that the Commission’s injury assessment involves a dynamic assessment of the economic factors over the period considered and not merely the conditions at the start and the end of the period considered. In any event, even if 2021 was to be considered for the purposes of the injury analysis, the relative importance of the imports remained high over the period 2022-IP and the share of imports from the countries concerned stayed at 30 % in the IP. Moreover, and importantly, the consistently low-priced dumped imports generated a severe price depression in the Union market, with the gap between the cost of the Union producers and their revenue widening between 2023-IP. Therefore, an extension of the period considered would not invalidate or otherwise alter the injury findings set out in this Regulation. Gantrade’s claim was therefore rejected.
recital 371recital 371
4.5. Prices of the imports from the countries concerned, price undercutting and price suppression / depression
(371) The Commission established the prices of imports on the same basis as the volume of imports.
recital 372recital 372
(372) Price undercutting of the imports was established based on the verified questionnaire replies of the (sampled) exporting producers for imports from China, the USA and South Africa, and based on Eurostat prices for Saudi Arabia.
recital 373recital 373
(373) The weighted average price of imports into the Union from the countries concerned developed as follows: Table 4 Import prices (EUR/tonne) 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period United States [1 982 –2 423 ] [1 250 –1 527 ] [1 230 – 1 504 ] [1 192 –1 457 ] Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 63 62 60 China 2 649 1 603 1 613 1 549 Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 61 61 58 South Africa [1 686 –2 820 ] [1 152 –1 423 ] [1 039 –1 283 ] [927 –1 145 ] Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 68 62 55 Saudi Arabia 2 089 1 243 1 326 1 147 Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 60 63 55 Import prices: Total countries concerned [2 077 –2 554 ] [1 244 –1 530 ] [1 245 –1 532 ] [1 154 –1 420 ] Index (2022 = 100 %) 100 60 60 56 Source: Eurostat, Sasol and Dow US questionnaires.
recital 374recital 374
(374) During the period considered, the average unit price of the dumped imports from the countries concerned decreased by 44 %, showing a clear downward trend in 2023, with the low price level sustained for the rest of the period considered.
recital 375recital 375
(375) The Commission determined the price undercutting during the investigation period for China, the USA and South Africa by comparing: (a) the weighted average sales prices per product type of the sampled Union producers charged to unrelated customers on the Union market, adjusted to an ex-works level; and (b) the corresponding weighted average prices per product type of the imports from the sampled cooperating country name producers to the first independent customer on the Union market, established on a Cost, insurance, freight (CIF) basis, with appropriate adjustments for customs duties and post-importation costs.
recital 376recital 376
(376) The price undercutting during the investigation period for Saudi Arabia, was determined on the basis of (a) the weighted average AE sales prices of the sampled Union producers charged to unrelated customers on the Union market, adjusted to an ex-works level and (b) CIF price established based on Eurostat, with appropriate adjustments for customs duties and post-importation costs.
recital 377recital 377
(377) The price comparison was made on a type-by-type basis for transactions at the same level of trade, duly adjusted where necessary, and after deduction of rebates and discounts. The result of the comparison was expressed as a percentage of the sampled Union producers’ theoretical turnover during the investigation period.
recital 378recital 378
(378) It showed a weighted average undercutting margin of 14,5 % by the countries concerned on the Union market. Also, undercutting was found for each individual country concerned, namely China was found to undercut the Union industry prices by [10–15] %, the USA by [20–25] %, South Africa by [11–16] % and Saudi Arabia by [7–10] % ( 160 ) . In any event, regardless of the findings on undercutting, the Commission observed that the dumped imports led to significant price depression (as reflected by the underselling margins) during the investigation period, when the Union industry sold AE below its cost of production.
recital 379recital 379
(379) The Commission also analysed the sales prices and costs of the Union industry (as shown in Table 8), together with its profitability (Table 11) and the import prices and quantities of the cumulated imports (Tables 3 and 4). It was clear that a serious depression of prices took place on the Union market in the period 2023-investigation period. In 2022 the high costs of the Union industry were passed on to customers, but in 2023-IP it was no longer possible to recover costs due to the price pressure of the high volumes of dumped imports at low and decreasing prices.
recital 380recital 380
4.6. Economic situation of the Union industry
4.6.1. General remarks
(380) In accordance with Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation, the examination of the impact of the dumped imports on the Union industry included an evaluation of all economic indicators having a bearing on the state of the Union industry during the period considered.
recital 381recital 381
(381) As mentioned in recital (27), sampling was used for the determination of possible injury suffered by the Union industry.
recital 382recital 382
(382) For the injury determination, the Commission distinguished between macroeconomic and microeconomic injury indicators. The Commission evaluated the macroeconomic indicators on the basis of data contained in the questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers and the reply to macro questionnaire submitted by Dow Europe. The data related to all Union producers. The Commission evaluated the microeconomic indicators on the basis of data contained in the questionnaire replies from the sampled Union producers. The data related to the sampled Union producers. Both sets of data were found to be representative of the economic situation of the Union industry.
recital 383recital 383
(383) The macroeconomic indicators are production, production capacity, capacity utilisation, sales volume, market share, growth, employment, productivity, magnitude of the dumping margin, and recovery from past dumping.
recital 384recital 384
(384) The microeconomic indicators are average unit prices, unit cost, labour costs, inventories, profitability, cash flow, investments, return on investments, and ability to raise capital.
recital 385recital 385
4.6.2. Macroeconomic indicators
4.6.2.1. Production, production capacity and capacity utilisation
(385) The total Union production, production capacity and capacity utilisation developed over the period considered as follows: Table 5 Production, production capacity and capacity utilisation 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Production (tonnes) 511 411 433 211 510 182 492 951 Index 100 85 100 96 Production capacity (tonnes) 723 781 723 781 723 781 723 781 Index 100 100 100 100 Capacity utilisation (%) 71 60 70 68 Index 100 85 100 96 Source: Macro questionnaire reply of Dow Europe, Sampled Union producers.
recital 386recital 386
(386) The production of the like product in the Union showed a mixed picture. While there was a significant drop in 2023, the production returned to the 2022 levels in 2024 to then decline by 4 % in the IP. Year 2023 is marked by a slowdown in downstream markets compared to restocking in 2022, resulting in muted demand for acrylic monomers. 2024 has seen a temporary stabilisation of the market followed however by a lack of structural demand and renewed destocking by users in 2025.
recital 387recital 387
(387) Production capacity remained stable during the period considered at around 724 000 tonnes.
recital 388recital 388
(388) Therefore, the capacity utilisation followed very similar trends to production volume, first declining in 2023 to 60 % to then increase again almost to the levels of 2022 in 2024-IP. Hence throughout the period considered, the capacity utilisation was relatively stable, declining by 3 percentage points from 71 % in 2022 to 68 % in the IP.
recital 389recital 389
(389) Overall, and as set out in recital (390) and recital (414) below, the Union producers prioritized higher sales volumes over margins in order to increase plant utilization, which directly contributed to higher production levels and operating rate in 2024-IP compared to 2023.
recital 390recital 390
4.6.2.2. Sales quantity and market share
(390) The Union industry’s sales quantity and market share developed over the period considered as follows: Table 6 Sales quantity and market share on the free market 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Total sales on the free market in the Union (tonnes) [167 446 –204 657 ] [148 835 –181 909 ] [189 465 –231 568 ] [184 871 –225 954 ] Index 100 89 113 110 Captive use by Union producers [220 538 –269 547 ] [185 940 –227 260 ] [204 322 –249 727 ] [206 492 –252 379 ] Index 100 84 93 94 Total sales on free market in the Union + captive use by Union producers [387 985 –474 204 ] [334 775 –409 169 ] [393 787 –481 295 ] [391 364 –478 334 ] Index 100 86 101 101 Market share of the Union industry on the free market (%) 49 50 57 62 Source: Macro questionnaire reply of Dow Europe, Sampled Union producers.
recital 391recital 391
(391) The sales volume of the Union producers on the free market showed significant variations over the period considered. While the sales volume dropped in 2023 due to a severe slowdown in all key end markets (coatings, adhesives, construction, water treatment), combined with destocking throughout the value chain, this decrease was followed by a temporary increase in sales volumes in 2024, which however slowed down in 2025 as a result of further demand contraction. In terms of market share of the free market sales by the Union producers, a gradual increase from 49 % to 62 % market share is observed.
recital 392recital 392
(392) Such market behaviour of the Union producers is a manifestation of the volume defence strategy, whereby the Union industry sought to maintain relevant sales volume in the market, although at the expense of having negative profitability.
recital 393recital 393
(393) Trends similar to the free market situation can be observed for captive use in the period considered. While decreasing sharply in 2023, the captive use increased and remained stable between 2024 and the investigation period, (although at the lower levels compared to 2022). Free market sales by the Union industry accounted for around 43 % of their combined total Union sales/use in 2022 and that proportion increased to around 47 % in the IP.
recital 394recital 394
4.6.2.3. Growth
(394) Both the free market consumption in the Union as well as the total Union consumption (including the captive use in the Union) decreased by 12 % and 10 % respectively during the period considered, while the sales volume of the Union industry in the Union free market increased by 10 % over the same period.
recital 395recital 395
(395) The Union consumption (both on the free market as well as total consumption) reached their highest levels at the beginning of the period considered, which was caused by the aftermath of COVID-19 and restocking of the material.
recital 396recital 396
(396) The demand subsequently contracted in 2023 and although showing signs of recovery in 2024, the consumption again fell in the investigation period. The sales of the Union producers equally dropped, albeit by a lower margin (11 %) in 2023 compared to the beginning of the period considered, to then rise above the 2022 levels in 2024-IP in the pursuit of a volume strategy. This was to maintain a relevant presence on the Union market and to cope with the competitive pressure exerted by the dumped imports from countries concerned, which continued to flow into the Union in considerable quantities and at low prices.
recital 397recital 397
(397) Therefore, while the Union industry increased market share in a shrinking market, such approach reflected a deliberate volume defence strategy, implemented in response to a pricing and volume pressure exerted by the dumped imports.
recital 398recital 398
4.6.2.4. Employment and productivity
(398) Employment and productivity developed over the period considered as follows: Table 7 Employment and productivity 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Number of employees 324 332 347 346 Index 100 102 107 107 Productivity (unit/employee) 1 576 1 306 1 468 1 424 Index 100 83 93 90 Source: Macro questionnaire reply of Dow Europe, Sampled Union producers.
recital 399recital 399
(399) The number of employees showed a slight increase during the period considered by 7 %. Such increase in headcount is attributable mainly to the increase in production levels by 15 % in 2024 compared to 2023 and a staff retention in the IP despite the declining production in the IP.
recital 400recital 400
(400) The productivity per employee took an adverse turn in 2023. The situation then improved in 2024 to decline slightly again during the investigation period. The lower productivity in 2023-the investigation period was a result of the combination of moderately increasing headcount numbers with the fluctuating levels of production over the same period. Overall, the productivity in tonnes per employee decreased by 10 % over the period considered.
recital 401recital 401
4.6.2.5. Magnitude of the dumping margin and recovery from past dumping
(401) All dumping margins were significantly above the de minimis level. The impact of the magnitude of the actual margins of dumping on the Union industry was substantial, given the volume and prices of imports from the countries concerned.
recital 402recital 402
(402) This is the first anti-dumping investigation regarding the product concerned. Therefore, no data were available to assess the effects of possible past dumping.
recital 403recital 403
4.6.2.6. Comments of the parties
(403) Several parties, namely Pinghu Petro, Sasol, Gantrade, and Organik claimed that the Union industry did not suffer material injury under Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation, given that numerous key economic indicators (such as sales, market share, production) for the Union industry showed positive developments during the period considered. Pinghu Petro also noted in this context that the Commission has in its previous practice made a finding of non-injury where most indicators had experienced positive developments towards the end of the period considered.
recital 404recital 404
(404) First, the Commission noted that the assessment in each investigation is based on the facts and circumstances in that investigation. Moreover, the lawfulness of regulations imposing anti-dumping measures must be assessed in the light of legal rules and not based on the Commission’s alleged previous decisions.
recital 405recital 405
(405) Second, in line with Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation, the assessment of injury requires a comprehensive evaluation of all relevant economic factors and indices having a bearing on the state of the industry. The assessment involves a holistic appraisal of both macro- and microeconomic factors, while one or several of these factors in isolation do not necessarily give decisive guidance as to the outcome of the assessment. In this context, a finding of material injury does not require all relevant economic indicators to show a negative trend - which is the case here as set out in recital (428). Therefore, the claims raised by the parties had to be rejected.
recital 406recital 406
4.6.3. Microeconomic indicators
4.6.3.1. Prices and factors affecting prices
(406) The weighted average unit sales prices of the sampled Union producers to unrelated customers in the Union developed over the period considered as follows: Table 8 Sales prices and production cost in the Union 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Average unit sales price to unrelated customers in the Union (EUR/ tonne) 2 184 1 502 1 378 1 226 Index 100 69 63 56 Unit cost of production (EUR/ tonne) 1 923 1 597 1 423 1 419 Index 100 83 74 74 Source: Sampled Union producers.
recital 407recital 407
(407) The average unit sales price in the Union was consistently decreasing during the period considered, with the sharpest drop observed between 2022-2023. The uptick in demand in 2022 in the aftermath of the COVID-19 crisis resulted in prices that exceeded the production costs. However, this trend was not sustained and the situation deteriorated in 2023-IP.
recital 408recital 408
(408) The cost of production saw a correction following 2022 once the energy crisis subsided and the price of the main feedstock, propylene, decreased, but the sales price decreased even more sharply as shown in Table 8. Overall, during the period considered, the cost of production went down by 26 % while the average sales price decreased by a much larger margin, namely by 44 %. As a result, the sampled Union producers were operating at a significant loss during the investigation period.
recital 409recital 409
(409) This major disparity between the cost of production and sales prices by the Union producers is illustrative of the price depression to the level around the prices of the dumped imports, suffered by the Union producers.
recital 410recital 410
4.6.3.2. Labour costs
(410) The average labour costs of the sampled Union producers developed over the period considered as follows: Table 9 Average labour costs per employee (EUR) 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Average labour costs per employee 73 714 72 499 72 619 79 024 Index 100 98 99 107 Source: Sampled Union producers.
recital 411recital 411
(411) The average labour cost per employee increased by 7 % in the IP relative to the beginning of the period considered. The Commission did not consider that the evolution of the average labour cost would in any way affect the injury assessment in this case.
recital 412recital 412
4.6.3.3. Stocks
(412) Stock levels of the sampled Union producers developed over the period considered as follows: Table 10 Stocks 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Closing stock (tonnes) 16 414 10 976 21 691 11 695 Index 100 67 132 71 Closing stock as a percentage of production (%) 4 3 5 3 Index 100 79 130 74 Source: Sampled Union producers.
recital 413recital 413
(413) Year-end closing stocks as a percentage of production were oscillating between 3-5 % in the period considered. Given this limited proportion of closing stocks on total production, the Commission does not consider that the evolution of closing stocks would in any way affect the injury assessment in this case.
recital 414recital 414
4.6.3.4. Profitability, cash flow, investments, return on investments and ability to raise capital
(414) Profitability, cash flow, investments and return on investments of the sampled Union producers developed over the period considered as follows: Table 11 Profitability, cash flow, investments and return on investments 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Profitability of sales in the Union to unrelated customers (% of sales turnover) 12 -6 -0,3 -13 Index 100 -48 -2 - 109 Cash flow (EUR) 71 703 238 -2 035 479 -9 671 512 -25 433 931 Index 100 -3 -13 -35 Investments (EUR) 9 362 829 13 834 857 23 949 636 30 189 019 Index 100 148 256 322 Return on investments (%) 76 -29 -5 -67 Index 100 -38 -6 -88 Source: Sources of information.
recital 415recital 415
(415) The Commission established the profitability of the sampled Union producers by expressing the pre-tax net profit of the sales of the like product to unrelated customers in the Union as a percentage of the turnover of those sales.
recital 416recital 416
(416) The profitability reached exceptional levels in 2022 despite the emerging energy crisis, as the COVID-19 aftermath led to a boost in demand for the AE-containing products and restocking of the material. However, starting from 2023 and notably in the investigation period, the situation became unsustainable for the Union producers as they had to reduce the sales prices in the pursuit of their defensive volume strategy in a contracting market to face consistently large, dumped imports from the countries concerned.
recital 417recital 417
(417) This led to a loss-making situation from 2023, culminating in a high loss of -13 % in the investigation period.
recital 418recital 418
(418) The net cash flow is the ability of the Union producers to self-finance their activities. The net cash flow analysis shows a downward trend from 2022 with a significant slump in 2023, when the cash flow is negative for the first time during the period considered.
recital 419recital 419
(419) The investments were increasing gradually in the period considered to reach more than 30 million EUR in the IP. The investments made included recurrent investments for maintenance (such as the replacement of reaction catalysts or an annual maintenance work on the installations for compliance with safety and environmental regulations) or investments to improve energy efficiency and to decarbonize the acrylic monomers industry ( 161 ) . The latter category of investments in particular aimed at improving competitiveness of the Union producers and showed their commitment to preserve the AE industry in the Union.
recital 420recital 420
(420) The return on investments is the profit in percentage of the net book value of investments. Considering the developments described above, this indicator turned negative from 2023 onwards and for the remainder of the period considered, falling from a healthy +76 % in 2022 to -67 % in the investigation period.
recital 421recital 421
(421) The sampled Union producers’ ability to raise capital will be severely affected, should the deterioration in their economic performance be perpetuated.
recital 422recital 422
(422) According to Sasol, profitability of the chemical industry can only be meaningfully assessed (i) across integrated value chains involving multiple products, rather than individual products in isolation; and (ii) over a full investment cycle of approximately 5–10 years, rather than on the basis of short-term fluctuations.
recital 423recital 423
(423) First, economic trends, including profitability were assessed over a sufficiently long, four-year period considered, providing a comprehensive overview of the state of the Union industry over this extended period. In any event, extending the period considered beyond the four-year window would not invalidate the conclusions drawn in this case (see also recital (370)). Second, and importantly, this investigation covers AE only and does not extend beyond the product scope defined in the Notice of Initiation to cover wider group of products. While from a business and strategical perspective, Sasol’s considerations may be relevant, the boundaries of this investigation are set by the basic Regulation and the Notice of Initiation and cannot be arbitrarily exceeded. Assessing profitability for a wider group of products would be liable to materially affect the analysis and lead to distorted findings regarding the product under investigation. Sasol’s claim was therefore dismissed.
recital 424recital 424
4.7. Conclusion on injury
(424) Although the absolute import quantity from the countries concerned fell by less than 12 kt in the period considered, the Union demand contracted even more sharply (-45 kt), so the relative importance of the imports remained high and the share of imports from the countries concerned stayed at 30 % in the IP (at the same levels as at the beginning of the period considered). Moreover, and importantly, the consistently low-priced dumped imports generated a severe price-depression in the Union market, with the gap between the cost of the Union producers and their revenue widening between 2023-IP. This price pressure, compounded by the consistently high volumes of imported AE in a contracting market, rendered the Union industry loss-making from 2023 onward.
recital 425recital 425
(425) The acrylic esters market operates with high fixed costs and requires a high capacity utilisation rate to achieve profitability. In particular, following the downward trend in energy prices from 2023, the Union industry should have been expected to maintain their production and sales levels stable despite a slightly contracting market thereby allowing the distribution of their fixed costs over a higher quantity produced and maintaining profitability. However, the prices of the dumped imports started plummeting following 2022, forcing the Union industry to lower their prices, while trying to keep a reasonable plant capacity utilization and control over their fixed costs. Whilst this approach allowed the Union industry to gain market share (mainly at the expense of imports from other third countries which were not found to be dumped), it completely eroded their profitability.
recital 426recital 426
(426) Macroeconomic indicators, such as Union production, production capacity, capacity utilisation remained broadly stable and employment rose modestly (7 % increase in head-count) over the period considered, while the Union producers managed to increase their sales volumes in the Union market as well as their market share. Moreover, the investment expenditure continued to rise. These positive trends illustrate the efforts of the Union AE industry to mitigate the adverse effects of the injurious dumping.
recital 427recital 427
(427) However, these developments did not translate into improved profitability because the Union industry was forced to lower its sales price far below cost to keep a relevant presence on the Union market in the face of sizeable, dumped imports. Following positive profitability, strong cash-flow and robust return on investment in 2022, from 2023 onwards the sector’s financial performance deteriorated sharply. Sales prices fell by 44 % over the period considered, while unit production costs fell much less (-26 %). Both cash flow and return on investment turned negative, and the net profitability of sales to unrelated customers collapsed from +12 % in 2022 to -13 % in the IP.
recital 428recital 428
(428) Overall, the sustained high import share of the countries concerned coupled with a pronounced price pressure amplified by market contraction created a price-depression environment that forced Union producers to sell below cost, generating losses. While indicators such as production, capacity utilisation, sales volumes, market share and investment showed limited positive movement, they were outweighed by the severe price and profitability erosion caused by the dumped imports. The combined effect of falling profitability, negative cash-flow, deteriorating returns on investment and reduced productivity will (if continued) severely limit the Union industry’s capacity to raise capital and to fund further investment, impeding any prospect of recovery or growth.
recital 429recital 429
(429) On the basis of the above, the Commission concluded at this stage that the Union industry suffered material injury within the meaning of Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation.
recital 430recital 430
5. CAUSATION
(430) In accordance with Article 3(6) of the basic Regulation, the Commission examined whether the dumped imports from the countries concerned caused material injury to the Union industry. In accordance with Article 3(7) of the basic Regulation, the Commission also examined whether other known factors could at the same time have injured the Union industry. The Commission ensured that any possible injury caused by factors other than the dumped imports from the countries concerned was not attributed to the dumped imports. These factors are imports from other third countries, export performance of the Union producers, effects of the raw material prices and the increased cost of production, decline in the Union consumption, alleged structural overcapacity and increase in investments.
recital 431recital 431
5.1. Effects of the dumped imports
(431) The import quantities from the countries concerned decreased during the period considered by 11,9 kt. However, this decrease in imports coincided with an almost four times higher drop in Union demand. Furthermore, the total market share of the imports from the countries concerned stayed consistently high and at or above 30% throughout the entire period considered.
recital 432recital 432
(432) In terms of price effects on the Union industry, the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic associated with an extraordinary surge in demand for AE-containing products helped the Union producers to rebuff injurious effects of the dumped imports in 2022 (beginning of the period considered). However, the price effects of the dumped imports became more pronounced from 2023 onwards, with the imports exerting price pressure on the Union industry in a shrinking market. While in 2022 the Union producers were profitable, the pressure from consistently high import volumes at dumped prices became unsustainable for the Union industry in the period that followed. From 2023 onwards, the Union industry became unable to keep its sales prices in line with the cost of production, despite the latter going down, to pass on to customers the cost of raw materials.
recital 433recital 433
(433) Dumped import prices effectively acted as the market benchmark, directly contributing to persistent losses despite continued production capability and presence of the Union producers in the Union market. Indeed, from being profitable in 2022, the Union industry became loss-making for the remainder of the period considered, with the situation looking dire in particular in the investigation period (-13 % loss).
recital 434recital 434
(434) Therefore, the low-priced imports from the countries concerned caused the prices of the Union industry to be depressed to a significant degree within the meaning of Article 3(3) of the basic Regulation.
recital 435recital 435
(435) In view of the above considerations, the Commission provisionally established that the material injury suffered by the Union industry was caused by the dumped imports from the countries concerned within the meaning of Article 3(6) of the basic Regulation. The consistently high level of imports from the countries concerned throughout the period considered was significant enough to cause material injury because of the low prices undercutting and depressing the prices of the Union industry.
recital 436recital 436
(436) Pinghu Petro argued that a China-specific causal link between the imports and the alleged injury as required under Article 3(6) of the basic Regulation was not established. Furthermore, Pinghu Petro submitted that there was a temporal disconnect between the evolution of import volumes and prices on one hand and the situation of the Union industry on the other hand. GAFT also contended that it is unlikely that import volumes from the countries concerned negatively affected the Union industry.
recital 437recital 437
(437) It was noted that conditions for cumulative assessment are met for the Chinese imports (see recitals (351)-(352)) and hence the Chinese imports were assessed together with imports from the other countries concerned and were not subject to individual assessment in this case, including for causality. In any event, the import statistics for China showed consistently high presence on the Union market over the period considered and a similar price trend to that observed for the other countries concerned (high prices in 2022, followed by a sharp decline in 2023, which was sustained until the end of the period considered).
recital 438recital 438
(438) With respect to the alleged lack of coincidence in time between imports and the deterioration of the state of Union industry, the following was noted. The existence of a causal link under Article 3(6) of the basic Regulation does not require a full temporal coincidence between the evolution of import prices/volumes and deterioration of Union industry’s situation. What is decisive is to establish whether the import volumes and prices and their evolution are responsible for an adverse, material impact on the Union industry.
recital 439recital 439
(439) In the present case, it was found that the dumped imports from the countries concerned, present in the Union market in consistently high volumes and at low price levels prevented the Union industry from reaching reasonable levels of profit throughout the period considered, in particular from 2023 onwards and hence caused injury to the Union industry. Pinghu Petro’s and GAFT’s arguments were therefore rejected.
recital 440recital 440
5.2. Effects of other factors
5.3. Imports from third countries
(440) The quantity of imports from other third countries developed over the period considered as follows, following the same methodology as for China and Saudi Arabia as explained in recitals (365) and (366) above: Table 12 Imports from third countries Country 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period South Korea Quantity (tonnes) 17 637 19 811 12 192 12 048 Market share (%) [4 –6 ] [5 –7 ] [2 –4 ] [3 –5 ] Average price (EUR) 3 970 2 406 2 987 3 073 Taiwan Quantity (tonnes) 23 488 16 736 6 977 5 051 Market share (%) [5 –7 ] [4 –6 ] [1 –3 ] [1 –3 ] Average price (EUR) 3 130 2 178 1 730 3 377 Japan Quantity (tonnes) 7 731 4 322 4 599 4 584 Market share (%) [1 –3 ] [0 –2 ] [0 –2 ] [0 –2 ] Average price (EUR) 3 946 3 791 3 390 3 496 Other third countries Quantity (tonnes) 31 087 9 044 6 620 5 571 Market share (%) [7 –9 ] [2 –4 ] [1 –3 ] [1 –3 ] Average price (EUR) 2 155 1 960 2 162 1 902 Total of all third countries except the countries concerned Quantity (tonnes) 79 944 49 913 30 388 27 254 Market share (%) [19 –23 ] [13 –17 ] [6 –10 ] [6 –10 ] Average price (EUR) 3 015 2 369 2 580 2 961 Source: Eurostat.
recital 441recital 441
(441) During the period considered, AE was imported into the Union in commercially significant quantities mainly from South Korea, Taiwan and Japan.
recital 442recital 442
(442) Overall, the imports from third countries other than the countries concerned consistently decreased over the period considered, with their market share in the Union market dropping from [19-23] % in 2022 (when the Union industry still generated high profits) to [6-10] % in the IP and the volumes declining from almost 80 kt in 2022 to 27,2 kt in the IP, when the injurious effects of dumped imports were felt the most. The trends at the individual country level followed generally the same tendency.
recital 443recital 443
(443) With regards to the prices of the imports from other third countries, the average prices in aggregate as well as on the country level were consistently above the Union sales prices and the average import price of the countries concerned in the period 2023-IP, when the injurious effects of the imports from countries concerned were felt the most by the Union producers.
recital 444recital 444
(444) In light of the above, the Commission provisionally concluded that imports from other third countries did not contribute to the material injury of the Union industry.
recital 445recital 445
(445) Gantrade argued that, when considering the import trends as from 2022, the imports from the countries concerned only replaced the imports from other countries without affecting the sales by the Union producers. Pinghu Petro also submitted that injury allegedly suffered by the Union industry was not caused by imports from the countries concerned and that there was in fact a shift in sourcing patterns where Union customers reallocated volumes previously imported by other third countries among available suppliers from the countries concerned. Organik equally submitted that the limited increase in imports from the countries concerned is explained by a reallocation within the remaining import supply structure, rather than by an increase in import pressure on the Union market.
recital 446recital 446
(446) It was observed that the decrease in imports from countries other than the countries concerned largely coincided with Union market contraction in the period considered, rendering the re-allocation or replacement theory put forward by the parties highly speculative and unfounded. Irrespective of the above, as set out in recitals (424)-(428), it was predominantly the price effects that the consistently high volumes of imported AE had in a contracting market that resulted in material injury, rather than the volume-based effects of the dumped imports. Gantrade’s, Organik’s and Pinghu Petro’s arguments were therefore rejected.
recital 447recital 447
5.4. Export performance of the Union industry
(447) The quantity of exports of the sampled Union producers developed over the period considered as follows: Table 13 Export performance of the Union producers 2022 2023 2024 Investigation period Export quantity (tonnes) 34 993 28 734 31 493 28 513 Index 100 82 90 81 Average export price of sampled Union producers (EUR/tonne) 2 214 1 491 1 392 1 290 Index 100 67 63 58 Source: Sampled Union producers, Macro questionnaire reply of Dow Europe.
recital 448recital 448
(448) Export volumes of the Union industry decreased over the period considered and mainly in 2023 and the IP, which is consistent with the defence strategy of the Union producers, prioritizing their presence in the Union market and their domestic sales accordingly. Furthermore, export prices followed the same trend as prices on the Union market over the period considered, which is attributable to the presence and similar price behaviour of the countries concerned also in the export markets of the Union producers such as Türkiye.
recital 449recital 449
(449) The Commission provisionally concluded that while the export performance of the Union industry contributed to the material injury, it did not attenuate the causal link between the dumped imports from the countries concerned and the injury found.
recital 450recital 450
(450) Several parties (Sasol, GAFT and Pinghu Petro) claimed that it was the decline in the export performance, characterised by a sharp decline in export volumes and a sustained price erosion across export markets that contributed to or can explain any alleged injury of the Union industry.
recital 451recital 451
(451) As set out in recital (435), while the export volumes of the Union producers declined over the period considered and the prices also decreased, this was due to the fact that imports from countries concerned were present and exhibited a similar price behaviour as in the Union also in these export markets.
recital 452recital 452
(452) In any event, it was recalled that imports from the countries concerned do not need to be the sole cause of that injury and that the existence of other contributing factors (such as export performance of the Union industry) does not negate the causal link, provided that the effects of imports remain distinguishable and significant (which is the case here).
recital 453recital 453
5.5. Decline in the Union consumption
(453) According to Gantrade, the post-2022 price and profitability decrease reflected a natural market correction and are not a result of injurious pricing from imports. Organik also claimed that despite the contraction in demand, Union producers managed to increase their production volumes, sales volumes and market share during the period concerned, which was difficult to reconcile with an allegation that imports caused material injury to the Union industry. Furthermore, Sasol claimed that the deterioration in Union sales prices, which, in turn, negatively affected profitability of the Union producers was not driven by imports from the countries concerned, but largely by the Union producers’ strategy to expand market share in a context of contracting demand. In the same vein, Pinghu Petro submitted that where injury flows from strategic pricing decisions in a deteriorating demand environment, it cannot be attributed to imports. Moreover, in Pinghu Petro’s view, the demand contraction can mechanically depress prices irrespective of imports and amplify competitive behaviour among suppliers seeking to defend volumes.
recital 454recital 454
(454) As outlined in recitals (348)-(349) above, indeed the Union consumption on the free market showed a decrease over the period considered. However, under normal conditions of competition, a demand contraction would not force economic operators with a market share exceeding 50 % to sell their products below cost at lossmaking levels (which was the case for Union producers) – certainly not over a prolonged period extending over three calendar years. Moreover, in 2024 when the Union consumption almost returned to 2022 levels (the year in which the Union producers enjoyed high profits), the profit levels of the Union producers remained in the negative.
recital 455recital 455
(455) In any event and contrary to what the parties argue, Union industry’s defensive behaviour which ultimately led to their increased sales volumes and market share and stable production levels, was not indicative of a healthy competition. Instead, it was indicative of a situation in which firms were forced to prioritise volume over profitability to remain present in the market and to confront the dumped imports.
recital 456recital 456
(456) In conclusion, the economic contraction contributed to the material injury of the Union industry, however not to the extent that it would attenuate the causal link between the injury suffered by the Union industry and the dumped imports from the countries concerned.
recital 457recital 457
5.6. Captive demand of the Union industry
(457) Gantrade argued that a contraction in demand, including from the Union industry’s own downstream operations, was a cause of material injury unrelated to the allegedly dumped imports.
recital 458recital 458
(458) Captive consumption followed a trend similar to the evolution of the free market consumption. In fact, as set out in recital (348), the degree of contraction of the captive demand was 50 % lower than the rate of the free market consumption decrease over the period considered. Moreover, the captive consumption even increased in the IP (when the material injury was most prominent) compared to 2024, which is not the case for the free market consumption. Hence the evolution of Union industry’s internal demand only had limited impact on the situation of the Union industry and at most contributed to the material injury, without breaking the causal link between the material injury suffered by the Union industry and the dumped imports.
recital 459recital 459
5.7. Cost of raw materials, energy and labour
(459) Gantrade argued that the challenges faced by the Union industry were attributable to structurally higher raw materials (propylene in this case) and energy costs for the Union industry, which inherently affected its competitiveness. Pinghu Petro also submitted that the Union industry was exposed to an exceptional energy-cost shock in 2022–2023, which sharply escalated production costs. Finally, according to Sasol, the evidence demonstrated that the sharp increase in inflation as well as the surge in energy costs in 2022-2023, accompanied by the rising labour costs throughout the period considered led to reduced margins and declining profitability for the Union producers.
recital 460recital 460
(460) Prices of propylene were indeed found to be elevated in 2022, while they stabilised at lower levels for the rest of the period considered. Furthermore, it was not disputed that the inflationary pressures and energy crisis in 2022-2023 affected the cost of production of the Union producers. However, the energy cost started decreasing and inflation decelerated and stabilised at lower levels from 2023 onwards. Furthermore, although average labour cost of the Union producers moderately increased over the period considered (+7 %), overall cost of production decreased by 26 % over the same period. Against this background, in 2022, despite the high raw material and energy prices and general inflationary pressures, the Union producers were able to increase their sales prices to absorb the high production cost and generate profits. On the other hand, following 2023 and up to the investigation period, when the upward trend in energy prices had reversed, propylene prices have stabilised and inflation has eased down, the profitability trend of the Union producers became negative to reach alarmingly negative levels in the investigation period. Hence while the Union producers succeeded in passing on the cost of raw material and energy prices in 2022, they failed to do so in the period that followed, even if the cost of production dropped considerably for the Union producers. Under conditions of fair competition, Union producers would have been able to pass their costs on to customers through higher sales prices. However, this ability was impeded by the presence of dumped imports, mainly from 2023 onwards.
recital 461recital 461
(461) In view of that, the temporary increases in cost of raw material and energy did not attenuate the causal link between the dumped imports originating in the countries concerned and the injury suffered by the Union industry.
recital 462recital 462
5.8. Structural overcapacity
(462) Sasol claimed that should material injury be established, this was caused largely by the significant overcapacities and inherent inefficiencies within the local production infrastructure at the Union producers.
recital 463recital 463
(463) As set out in recital (385) and contrary to Sasol’s claim, the operating rates at the Union producers were rather high over the period considered. Moreover, while in 2022 (when the Union industry still generated high profits) the Union industry operated at 71 % of the capacity, in the IP, the capacity utilisation was at a comparable 68 %, although the profitability of the Union industry was highly negative by then. Alleged overcapacity could therefore not have contributed to the material injury suffered by the Union industry.
recital 464recital 464
5.9. Pricing and investment decisions
(464) Pinghu Petro as well as Sasol submitted that the Union producers’ decision to invest heavily necessarily resulted in a downward pressure on profitability independently of imports. Sasol further claimed that a sustained and significant rise in investment was incompatible with a situation of material injury and instead demonstrates that the economic state of the Union industry remains financially robust.
recital 465recital 465
(465) As illustrated by a major decarbonization investment project undertaken by the Union industry, this type of investments is a result of strategic decisions taken as part of a multiannual framework and requires years of preparation. Moreover, these investment decisions are taken at the enterprise level (rather than at the level of a product department), and are part of wider, global corporate initiatives ( 162 ) . Therefore, and as correctly pointed out also by Sasol in their submission, such investments reflect long-term strategic objectives. They do not occur in response to short-term market fluctuations, are forward-looking, not necessarily product-specific and hence cannot explain a sudden deterioration in profitability and resulting injury in this case and for AE specifically. By the same token, the fact that a producer undertakes significant investments which will likely result in a positive effect in a mid- to long-term does not preclude a finding of material injury caused by dumped imports.
recital 466recital 466
(466) Pinghu Petro also argued that the operation of outdated production facilities in the Union typically entails significantly higher costs and inferior production efficiencies and may constitute an autonomous source of injury.
recital 467recital 467
(467) Pinghu Petro’s claim was considered speculative and unsubstantiated. As set out in recital (419) and contrary to the claim, the Union industry made continuous investments into their production facilities going beyond maintenance and regulatory compliance. These investments improve energy efficiency of the facilities and at the same time ensure that the Union producers maintain a relevant presence in the Union market. Therefore, Pinghu Petro’s claim was dismissed.
recital 468recital 468
5.10. Conclusion on causation
(468) A causal link was established between the dumped imports from the countries concerned on one hand and the injury suffered by the Union industry on the other hand. In particular after 2022, the dumped imports remained high (around 30-35 % of total free Union consumption) and their prices fell markedly. In a relatively weak market with demand contraction, the increasingly low-priced and sizeable dumped imports eroded margins of the Union industry and its ability to set prices that would absorb the high costs of production, thereby clearly pointing to the existence of price depression. This situation resulted in a lossmaking situation of the Union producers in 2023-IP.
recital 469recital 469
(469) The Commission examined other possible factors that may have had an impact on the situation of the Union industry. The effects of these factors on the situation of the Union industry were distinguished and separated from the injurious effects of the dumped imports.
recital 470recital 470
(470) Regarding the effects of imports from other third countries, the Commission concluded that these imports fell in both volume and market share (from [19–23] % to [6–10] %) and their average prices stayed both above Union sales prices and import prices from the countries concerned, so they did not contribute to the material injury suffered by the Union producers.
recital 471recital 471
(471) The export price performance of the Union industry was affected by a similar pattern to that observed for the Union sales over the period considered, while the export quantities dropped by 19 % contrary to domestic sales which rose in the pursuit of volume defence strategy. While the effect of the export performance of the Union producers contributed to the adverse situation at the Union producers, it did not break the causal link between the dumped imports and the injury suffered by the Union industry.
recital 472recital 472
(472) Regarding the contraction of Union consumption (both on free market as well as captive consumption), it amplified the price pressure and contributed to the material injury; however, it was not liable to break the causal link established between the material injury suffered and dumped imports. Moreover, although the raw material and energy costs rose in 2022, they subsequently fell, yet the Union industry became unprofitable from 2023 onward, indicating that cost evolution cannot explain the injury. Lastly, the material injury cannot be explained by any alleged overcapacities (that were moreover not established), nor by long-term investments made at the enterprise level in a strategic move to enhance competitiveness of the Union industry in the chemical sector.
recital 473recital 473
(473) On the basis of the above, the Commission concluded at this stage that the dumped imports from the countries concerned caused material injury to the Union industry (notably in 2023-IP) and that the other factors, considered individually or collectively, did not attenuate the causal link between the dumped imports and the material injury. The injury consists principally of severe price depression, loss of profitability, negative cash flow and negative return on investments.
recital 474recital 474
(474) Pinghu Petro submitted that the potential causality factors (other than dumped imports) must be assessed cumulatively in this case, as they arise concurrently and interact in a mutually reinforcing manner amplifying the combined impact. Sasol made a similar claim, arguing that a combination of other factors breaks the causal link.
recital 475recital 475
(475) Contrary to the arguments of the parties, while the factors other than dumped imports exacerbated individually or collectively the injurious situation of the Union industry, there was a clear and identifiable causal link between the material injury suffered and the dumped imports from the countries concerned, which is not attenuated by any of these other factors. The arguments raised by the parties must therefore be rejected.
recital 476recital 476
6. LEVEL OF MEASURES
(476) The complainants claimed the existence of raw material distortions within the meaning of Article 7(2a) of the basic Regulation in the complaint.
recital 477recital 477
(477) Thus, in order to conduct the assessment on the appropriate level of measures, the Commission first established the amount of duty necessary to eliminate the injury suffered by the Union industry in the absence of distortions under Article 7(2a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 478recital 478
(478) Then it examined whether the dumping margin of sampled exporting producers would be higher than their injury margin.
recital 479recital 479
6.1. Injury margin
(479) The injury would be removed if the Union industry were able to obtain a target profit by selling at a target price in the sense of Articles 7(2c) and 7(2d) of the basic Regulation.
recital 480recital 480
(480) In accordance with Article 7(2c) of the basic Regulation, for establishing the target profit, the Commission took into account the following factors: the level of profitability before the increase of imports from the countries concerned, the level of profitability needed to cover full costs and investments, research and development (R & D) and innovation, and the level of profitability to be expected under normal conditions of competition. Such profit margin should not be lower than 6 %.
recital 481recital 481
(481) The profit for the sampled Union producers widely fluctuated within the period considered. The exceptionally high profits in 2022 were achieved in an extraordinary period of demand fuelled by the COVID-19 economy and supply chain restraints, as also acknowledged by the complainant. Therefore, it would not be appropriate to use the profit figures from 2022 as a basic profit in accordance with Article 7(2c) of the basic Regulation. Furthermore, for the years prior to the period considered, the Union producers could not reliably identify precise levels of profitability. The Commission therefore established the target profit to determine the non-injurious price at 6 %, in accordance with Article 7(2c) of the basic Regulation.
recital 482recital 482
(482) Furthermore, none of the sampled Union producers made a substantiated claim for investments foregone or R & D and innovation costs. In view of those facts, the Commission resorted to the use of the minimum 6 % target profit which was added to the Union industry’s actual cost of production to establish the non-injurious price.
recital 483recital 483
(483) As no substantiated claims were made pursuant to Article 7(2d) concerning current or future costs which result from multilateral environmental agreements and protocols thereunder or from the listed ILO Conventions, no further costs were added to the non-injurious price thus established.
recital 484recital 484
(484) The Commission then determined the injury margin level on the basis of a comparison of the weighted average import price of the sampled cooperating exporting producers in the countries concerned as established for the price undercutting calculations, with the weighted average non-injurious price of the like product sold by the sampled Union producers on the Union market during the investigation period. Any difference resulting from this comparison was expressed as a percentage of the weighted average import CIF value.
recital 485recital 485
(485) Due to non-cooperation from the sole Saudi exporting producer, the injury margin for Saudi Arabia was based on facts available. The Saudi export price was compared to the highest individual target price of the like product produced by the sampled Union producers.
recital 486recital 486
(486) The injury elimination level for ‘other cooperating companies’ and for ‘all other imports’ originating in the respective country concerned is defined in the same manner as the dumping margin for these companies and imports.
recital 487recital 487
6.2. Examination of the margin adequate to remove the injury to the Union industry
(487) As explained in the Notice of Initiation, the complainant provided the Commission sufficient evidence that there are raw material distortions in China regarding the product under investigation. Therefore, in accordance with Article 7(2a) of the basic Regulation, this investigation examined the alleged distortions to assess whether, if relevant, a duty lower than the margin of dumping would be sufficient to remove injury.
recital 488recital 488
(488) However, as the margins adequate to remove injury are higher than the dumping margins with regard to the Chinese exporting producers, the Commission considered that at this stage it was not necessary to address this aspect.
recital 489recital 489
6.3. Conclusion on the level of measures
(489) Following the above assessment, provisional anti-dumping duties should be set as below in accordance with Article 7(2) of the basic Regulation: Country Company Provisional dumping margin (%) Provisional injury margin (%) Provisional anti-dumping duty (%) China Shanghai Huayi New Material Co., Ltd. 29,0 37,4 29,0 Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd. 22,3 41,4 22,3 Other Chinese cooperating companies 23,9 40,5 23,9 All other imports originating in China 29,0 41,4 29,0 Saudi Arabia All imports originating in Saudi Arabia 40,3 40,8 40,3 South Africa Sasol South Africa Ltd 83,1 32,4 32,4 All other imports originating in South Africa 83,1 32,4 32,4 United States of America Dow Chemical Company 61,9 39,0 39,0 All other imports originating in the USA 61,9 39,0 39,0
recital 490recital 490
7. UNION INTEREST
(490) Having decided to apply Article 7(2) of the basic Regulation, the Commission examined whether it could clearly conclude that it was not in the Union interest to adopt measures in this case, despite the determination of injurious dumping, in accordance with Article 21 of the basic Regulation.
recital 491recital 491
(491) The determination of the Union interest was based on an appreciation of all the various interests involved, including those of the Union industry, importers and users.
recital 492recital 492
7.1. Interest of the Union industry
(492) The Union industry for AE consists of four producers that manufactured the product during the investigation period. This industry is an important part of the EU industrial base, as acrylate monomers are used in a wide range of downstream products, including coatings, adhesives, sealants, paper, polymer additives, textiles and inks.
recital 493recital 493
(493) The imposition of anti-dumping measures would likely help Union producers restore profitability and stabilise cash flow. By improving profitability, Union producers would be better placed to maintain compliance with environmental rules, invest in research, development and lower-carbon production and operational efficiency. Furthermore, the imposition of measures would enable the Union industry to preserve employment and security of supply within the Union. A preservation of the Union production at sustainable levels would also support upstream petrochemical industries, in particular through higher and more stable demand for propylene and related feedstocks.
recital 494recital 494
(494) By contrast, without corrective measures, the Union industry would face further pressure from unfairly low-priced imports, leading to deeper losses and threatening a long-term viability of the Union production. Continued price depression would make it difficult to sustain operations and preserve jobs. In such a situation, further investment would likely be limited, while plans for long-term competitiveness could be delayed or abandoned altogether.
recital 495recital 495
(495) In addition, the continued deterioration of the AE business would affect the downstream activities at the Union producers, which are operationally or economically linked to the production of the product under investigation. The downsizing or loss of upstream AE production in the Union would therefore have wider implications for the sustainability of related value-chain activities within the Union.
recital 496recital 496
(496) The Commission therefore concluded that imposing anti-dumping duties would be in the interest of the Union industry.
recital 497recital 497
7.2. Interest of unrelated importers
(497) With respect to unrelated importers, two companies, Opes International Limited (‘Opes’) and Gantrade, cooperated in this investigation, including by providing replies to the Commission questionnaire. Gantrade was opposed to the imposition of the measures in this case, while Opes did not publicly express its position on the measures.
recital 498recital 498
(498) It is provisionally considered that the measures will likely have an insignificant impact (if any) on importers as they can continue importing AE at fair prices from the countries concerned or other third countries, creating a healthy competition for the domestically produced AE. Furthermore, the evidence provided by the cooperating unrelated importers shows that more than half of their imports in value concerns products other than AE, hence further diluting the effect of measures on these importers and demonstrating that the importers can diversify their business activities to other products.
recital 499recital 499
7.3. Interest of users
(499) In the present case, users predominantly representing the acrylic resins segment came forward, opposing the measures The resins are an intermediary product used for the main user applications of the product concerned – coatings adhesives and additives. Several users (Allnex Belgium SA / NV (‘Allnex’), Covestro AG, Organik, EPS B.V., ICAP-SIRA Chemicals and Polymers S.p.A., Trinseo PLC and Dow ( 163 ) ) replied to the user questionnaire made available at the beginning of the investigation, while other users (Bear Quimica, s.a. (‘Bear’), Alberdingk Boley GmbH (‘Alberdingk’) and Follmann Chemie GmbH (‘Follmann’)) solely submitted their written position on the investigation.
recital 500recital 500
(500) For the users that completed the dedicated questionnaire, their financial performance showed that all (save for one user) enjoyed healthy profit margins, ranging between 3–36 % in the investigation period. and one user was lossmaking, close to breakeven – however, the proportion of the turnover generated on the AE-inclusive product for the user concerned accounted for less than 10 % of its total company turnover.
recital 501recital 501
(501) Moreover, the submissions by majority of users indicated that the proportion of the AE cost on their cost of production was limited and accounted (for five out of seven users) for no more than 3–15 % of the cost of production. Regarding the two most affected users which have the highest share of cost of the product under investigation in their total cost of production (20–30 %), they were profitable (with profits around 3–5 % and 16–20 % respectively). Moreover, both companies purchased the vast majority of AE (60–85 %) from the Union and therefore the proposed duties would have a limited effect on their profitability. Considering the above, the measures are likely to have a limited and manageable effect on the users.
recital 502recital 502
(502) The measures are also not expected to cause shortages for the users. Despite the imposition of measures, users would still be able to import from the countries concerned, since anti-dumping duties are intended to correct unfairly low prices, not to block imports completely. In addition, commercially relevant quantities have been imported into the Union from third countries not subject to measures (such as South Korea, Japan and Taiwan) during the period considered. Hence imports from these countries can provide users with alternative sources of acrylic esters. Union producers also have spare capacity and could increase output without needing new investment in enlarging capacity.
recital 503recital 503
7.4. Comments of the interested parties
(503) The Chinese exporting producer Pinghu Petro claimed that the imposition of anti-dumping duties against imports of AE from China would drive up costs for Union downstream users in a wide variety of sectors. Sasol made a similar claim, adding that higher production costs across the downstream value chain would ultimately be borne by Union consumers. Organik, Allnex, Gantrade, Bear, Alberdingk and Follmann also argued that imposition of duties would result in cost increases for the Union downstream operators (with limited ability to absorb such increases or pass them on) and compression of their margins, which would potentially lead to their reduced competitiveness and to increased imports of downstream products (since measures would not apply to the downstream products). According to parties, this situation could ultimately lead to relocation of the downstream industries outside the Union.
recital 504recital 504
(504) While the anti-dumping measures may result in some increase in input prices for users, such increase is expected to be limited and manageable. Having regard to the current profitability record of the users relative to the profitability (or rather lack thereof) of the Union producers, downstream users can be expected to pass on any cost increases along the value chain. Moreover, the price effects of the measures can be mitigated by contractual pricing arrangements and diversified sourcing practices, which are already implemented by the users. Continued presence of imports from countries concerned (also in view of the level of duties imposed) and other third countries on the Union market in addition to the four Union producers will also ensure the competitive pressure which is likely to mitigate any potential cost increases that might arise from the imposition of these duties. In any event, it is observed that the measures will primarily correct artificially low import prices (at which the users were buying the material for an extended period) that currently undercut Union producers. Having regard to the above, the imposition of measures should not have a prohibitive effect on the users and their competitiveness let alone force them to relocate outside the Union. The arguments of the parties were therefore rejected.
recital 505recital 505
(505) Moreover, it is reasonable to consider that the impact on the Union consumers will be immaterial, given the overall cost structure of the final consumer products in this segment (such as acrylic paints purchased in a DIY store) and the fact that these final products are more resilient to fluctuations in prices of the intermediates that enter the value chain much higher upstream.
recital 506recital 506
(506) In conclusion, hypothetical adverse effects on the user industries and on final consumers cannot outweigh the distinct need to restore a level playing field on the Union AE market, in particular where the long-term viability of the Union industry and sustainability of related value-chain activities within the Union are at stake. The alternative scenario without duties and with the Union industry disappearing would be more harmful for the users than a price increase the imposition of duties might lead to.
recital 507recital 507
(507) Organik argued that anti-dumping measures would restrict imports from countries concerned, which consequently would further exacerbate the AE supply constraints for independent downstream users, given that the AE Union market is highly concentrated and a substantial share of AE is used captively. Gantrade also argued that imposition of duties would significantly reduce the availability of AE in the Union market. Furthermore, according to Pinghu Petro, the likely consequence of anti-dumping duties would be to effectively foreclose the Union market altogether for Chinese imports. Also in the South African exporting producer Sasol’s view, the competitiveness of Union downstream manufacturers would be undermined by potentially limiting access to AE if duties significantly reduce import volumes. Bear, Alberdingk and Follmann also claimed that vertically integrated Union producers could prioritize captive supplies to merchant market sales after imposition of measures.
recital 508recital 508
(508) First, the Commission recalled that the Union AE market is competitive, covering four Union producers as well as other exporting countries such as Korea, or Taiwan in addition to the countries concerned (including China), which will not be prevented from entering the Union at fair and non-injurious prices. Imposition of anti-dumping duties is hence not prone to lead to an increased concentration of Union producers in the AE market. On the other hand, and contrary to parties’ claims, imposition of measures will ensure continued presence of the Union-based suppliers and hence reliable supply base for Union users, especially in the current geopolitical context, where certain events (such as closure of key shipping gateways) can result in unavailability of imports. Moreover, the parties did not provide any substantiated evidence that the Union producers and other existing sources of supply would not be able to satisfy the demand on the Union market.
recital 509recital 509
(509) Second, the level of captive consumption has been stable over the period considered and any claim that this trend is bound to change and that supply constraints would increase for independent users is speculative and unfounded. As outlined in recital (393), free market sales by the Union industry accounted for around 45 % of their combined total Union sales and usage and that proportion even increased to 47–48 % in 2024-IP. Furthermore, the Union industry has been operating at around 70 % of the installed capacity during the period considered and hence there is a spare capacity in the Union to satisfy any potential increase in demand from independent downstream users.
recital 510recital 510
(510) Organik and Gantrade further submitted that suppliers located in alternative third markets such as Korea, Japan or Taiwan cannot offer sufficient and scalable volumes capable of replacing the subject imports on a sustained basis. Contrary to the claim of the parties and as it follows from recitals (440)-(441), AE was imported into the Union in commercially significant quantities from South Korea, Taiwan and Japan, with their combined market share of 6,5 % in the IP showing relevant and non-negligible presence in the Union market. Earlier in the period considered, sales volumes from these countries were even higher. Moreover, users such as Organik do not need to rely exclusively on alternative sources of supply, especially since they traditionally sought to source most of their products from Union producers. In addition, the parties can obviously continue to import the material from countries concerned, at reasonable and non-injurious prices. Organik’s and Gantrade’s arguments were therefore rejected as unfounded.
recital 511recital 511
(511) Organik also stated that for the company, product type BA is a core input representing a significant component of Organik’s cost structure.
recital 512recital 512
(512) While Organik might be more exposed to an increase in AE cost relative to some other downstream users, the impact on this user cannot outweigh the interest in fair trade restoration and the need to prevent further deterioration of the Union industry for numerous reasons. First, Organik already applies diversified sourcing strategy, sourcing the material from combination of suppliers and notably 50-70 % from the Union producers. As outlined by Organik in their own submission, where downstream users source inputs from a mix of domestic and imported supplies and are not highly dependent on the imports from countries concerned (which is the case here), the cost impact of duties may be mitigated. Second, contrary to Organik’s claim, as set out in recital (407), the sales price in the Union was consistently decreasing during the period considered and the users (including Organik) actually benefitted for an extended period from artificially low prices. Hence, any price correction would merely be a manifestation of the fair-trade restoration in a situation where Union industry prices were depressed by a downward pressure coming from the dumped imports. In any event, imposition of duties and any resulting price increase for AE should not prevent downstream users from increasing prices to pass on any such cost increase. Organik did not provide any evidence to the contrary.
recital 513recital 513
(513) Furthermore, Organik raised a concern that existing structural asymmetries between vertically integrated Union producers and their downstream operations on one hand and non-integrated downstream operators (without captive access to AE) on the other hand would be further exacerbated if duties are imposed. Gantrade also submitted that several Union producers are vertically integrated, operating their own downstream activities and are able to source key raw materials internally. According to Gantrade, they would effectively shield their downstream operations from the full impact of price increases caused by the proposed duties. The exporting producer Sasol, and the other users Bear, Alberdingk and Follmann made a similar claim, submitting that raw material costs would increase for non-integrated downstream users relative to vertically integrated acrylic-monomer producers.
recital 514recital 514
(514) It was not disputed that there is an asymmetry between the vertically integrated and non-integrated operators. However, anti-dumping duties serve a clear regulatory purpose of restoring fair trade, should legitimate interest on the part of the Union industry be established and conditions for imposition of measures be met (which is the case here). Trade defence measures operate independently and irrespective of any market structures in place and do not have the objective of curing any existing or potential market imperfections. Moreover, the parties seem to ignore in their arguments the fact that unlike independent downstream users, the vertically integrated Union producers face considerable capital expenditures and carry significant business risks associated with the production of the upstream material (in this case AE) used then in their downstream operations, including fluctuations in costs of raw material and energy, irrespective of any impact that the duties may have. The claims of the parties were therefore dismissed.
recital 515recital 515
(515) The exporting producer – Dow – stated that unfairly traded imports of AE from China already adversely affect Dow’s downstream businesses in the Union and that imposing duties on imports from the US would further undermine Dow’s ability to compete in downstream markets in the Union and in export markets.
recital 516recital 516
(516) First, measures introduced on the Chinese imports of AE with a view to restore fair trade in the Union are addressing Dow’s concerns on imports originating from China. Second, regarding the duties imposed on the US imports, Dow can source (at least BA) internally also from Dow Union operations independently of the Dow US imports. Moreover, Dow will still be able to source AE from the US, at reasonable and non-injurious prices.
recital 517recital 517
(517) In Pinghu Petro’s view, imposition of anti-dumping duties would not be in the Union interest, as the wider Union industry faces an energy shock caused by the Middle East crisis, which should be addressed by a Union-wide industrial policy measure, rather than by anti-dumping measures. Pinghu Petro failed to substantiate the link between the factor alleged and the Union interest analysis in this case and its claim was therefore rejected.
recital 518recital 518
(518) Finally, the Hellenic Association of Chemical Industries (Hellenic association’) acting on behalf of Greek downstream users, expressed an opposition against measures in this case. It was noted that the Hellenic association came forward with their submission late in the procedure, almost six months into the investigation. For the sake of completeness, the association raised arguments made also by other interested parties, such as cost pressure on downstream industries and on final consumers as a result of the measures, security of supply concern, possible arbitrage on the imported downstream goods incorporating AE unencumbered by the duties on AE, loss of (export) competitiveness of the downstream users, structural asymmetry between the independent, non-integrated downstream users and vertically integrated producers. Conclusions set out in recitals (504)-(514) apply accordingly to address these arguments raised by the Hellenic association.
recital 519recital 519
(519) In addition, the Hellenic association submitted that part of the downstream industry (waterborne resins) will be subject to cumulative burden of AE duties, together with duties imposed on imports of Chinese titanium dioxide (also used by the producers of resins) in January 2025 ( 164 ) . Contrary to what the association claimed and as it follows from the user submissions and their profitability record in 2025, their economic performance does not seem to have been adversely impacted by the titanium dioxide measures. The same preliminary conclusion can also be drawn with respect to the AE measures introduced, for the reasons set out in recital (500) .
recital 520recital 520
(520) The Hellenic association equally requested (i) an end-use relief in a form of end-use exemption, duty free tariff rate quota or a suspension of duties, while referring to the previous Commission practice or (ii) an inward processing relief. First, the reference to the precedents in the Commission’s practice is ineffective, since. the lawfulness of anti-dumping regulations must be assessed in the light of the basic Regulation and not based on the Commission’s previous decisions. Second, in the current case, the investigation concerns highly commoditized products (BA and 2EHA) rather than any specialty products to even consider an end-use exemption. Furthermore, no exceptional circumstances or supply constraints have been identified to warrant any duty-free tariff-rate quota or duty suspension. Regarding the inward processing, anti-dumping duties are only imposed on dumped products that are released for free circulation within the Union. Thus, anti-dumping duties do not apply to products brought into the customs territory of the Union under special customs procedures that does not involve entry for free circulation, such as inward processing,
recital 521recital 521
7.5. Conclusion on Union interest
(521) When weighing the effects, the positive consequences of imposing measures for the Union industry—namely restoring fair competition, preserving production and employment, and strengthening supply security—outweigh the limited negative consequences for users and importers. Given the largely commoditised nature of the product and the wide range of alternative sources of supply as well as overall positive economic performance of users, measures are not expected to lead to disproportionate cost increases or shortages. Moreover, the impact on users will likely be short-term as opposed to possibly irreversible and long-term effect that absence of measures would have on the operations of the Union producers.
recital 522recital 522
(522) On the basis of the above, the Commission concluded that there were no compelling reasons that it was not in the Union interest to impose measures on imports of AE originating in countries concerned at this stage of the investigation.
recital 523recital 523
8. PROVISIONAL ANTI-DUMPING MEASURES
(523) On the basis of the conclusions reached by the Commission on dumping, injury, causation, level of measures and Union interest, provisional measures should be imposed to prevent further injury being caused to the Union industry by the dumped imports.
recital 524recital 524
(524) Provisional anti-dumping measures should be imposed on imports of certain acrylic esters originating in the countries concerned, in accordance with the lesser duty rule in Article 7(2) of the basic Regulation. The Commission compared the injury margins and the dumping margins in recital (489) above. The amount of the duties was set at the level of the lower of the dumping and the injury margins.
recital 525recital 525
(525) On the basis of the above, the provisional anti-dumping duty rates, expressed on the CIF Union border price, customs duty unpaid, should be as follows: Country Company Provisional anti-dumping duty (%) China Shanghai Huayi New Material Co., Ltd. 29,0 Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd. 22,3 Other Chinese cooperating companies 23,9 All other imports originating in China 29,0 Saudi Arabia All imports originating in Saudi Arabia 40,3 South Africa Sasol South Africa Ltd 32,4 All other imports originating in South Africa 32,4 USA Dow Chemical Company 39,0 All other imports originating in the USA 39,0
recital 526recital 526
(526) The individual company anti-dumping duty rates specified in this Regulation were established on the basis of the findings of this investigation. Therefore, they reflect the situation found during this investigation with respect to these companies. These duty rates are exclusively applicable to imports of the product concerned originating in the countries concerned and produced by the named legal entities.
recital 527recital 527
(527) Imports of the product concerned produced by any other company not specifically mentioned in the operative part of this Regulation, including entities related to those specifically mentioned, should be subject to the duty rate applicable to ‘all other imports originating in country concerned’. They should not be subject to any of the individual anti-dumping duty rates.
recital 528recital 528
(528) To minimise the risks of circumvention due to the difference in duty rates concerning exporting producers in China, special measures are needed to ensure the application of the individual anti-dumping duties. The application of individual anti-dumping duties is only applicable upon presentation of a valid commercial invoice to the customs authorities of the Member States. The invoice must conform to the requirements set out in Article 1(3) of this regulation. Until such invoice is presented, imports should be subject to the anti-dumping duty applicable to ‘all other imports originating in the People’s Republic of China’.
recital 529recital 529
(529) While presentation of this invoice is necessary for the customs authorities of the Member States to apply the individual rates of anti-dumping duty to imports originating in China, it is not the only element to be taken into account by the customs authorities.
recital 530recital 530
(530) Indeed, even if presented with an invoice meeting all the requirements set out in Article 1(3) of this regulation, the customs authorities of Member States must carry out their usual checks and may, like in all other cases, require additional documents (shipping documents, etc.) for the purpose of verifying the accuracy of the particulars contained in the declaration and ensure that the subsequent application of the lower rate of duty is justified, in compliance with customs law.
recital 531recital 531
(531) Should the exports by one of the companies benefiting from lower individual duty rates increase significantly in quantity after the imposition of the measures concerned, such an increase in quantity could be considered as constituting in itself a change in the pattern of trade due to the imposition of measures within the meaning of Article 13(1) of the basic Regulation.
recital 532recital 532
(532) In such circumstances and provided the conditions are met an anti-circumvention investigation may be initiated. This investigation may, amongst other things, examine the need for the removal of individual duty rate(s) and the consequent imposition of a countrywide duty.
recital 533recital 533
9. REGISTRATION
(533) As mentioned in recital (4) above, the Commission made imports of the product concerned subject to registration. Registration took place with a view to possibly collecting duties retroactively under Article 10(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 534recital 534
(534) In view of the findings at provisional stage, the registration of imports should cease.
recital 535recital 535
(535) No decision on a possible retroactive application of anti-dumping measures has been taken at this stage of the proceeding.
recital 536recital 536
10. INFORMATION AT PROVISIONAL STAGE
(536) In accordance with Article 19a of the basic Regulation, the Commission informed interested parties about the planned imposition of provisional duties. This information was also made available to the general public via DG TRADE's website. Interested parties were given three working days to provide comments on the accuracy of the calculations specifically disclosed to them.
recital 537recital 537
(537) The complainant provided comments on the benchmarks for constructing the normal value in China, in particular on the methodology for the calculation of the profit margin used for the construction of the normal value. Since the comments did not concern the accuracy of the calculations, they will be addressed at the definitive stage of the investigation.
recital 538recital 538
11. FINAL PROVISIONS
(538) In the interests of sound administration, the Commission will invite the interested parties to submit written comments and/or to request a hearing with the Commission and/or the Hearing Officer in trade proceedings within a fixed deadline.
recital 539recital 539
(539) The findings concerning the imposition of provisional duties are provisional and may be amended at the definitive stage of the investigation,
Article 1
1. A provisional anti-dumping duty is imposed on imports of certain acrylic esters which are butyl acrylate, currently falling under CAS RN 141-32-2 and CUS 0012413-0, and 2-ethylhexyl acrylate, currently falling under CAS RN 103-11-7 and CUS 0017228-1, currently classified under CN code ex 2916 12 00 (TARIC code 2916 12 00 15) and originating in the People’s Republic of China, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Republic of South Africa, and the United States of America.
2. The product scope excludes other essential acrylates like Ethyl Acrylate or Methyl Acrylate and specialty acrylates like Alkyl acrylates, Hydroxy-alkyl acrylates or Dialkylaminoethylacrylates.
3. The rates of the provisional anti-dumping duty applicable to the net, free-at-Union-frontier price, before duty, of the product described in paragraph 1 and produced by the companies listed below shall be as follows: Country Company Provisional anti-dumping duty (%) TARIC additional code The People’s Republic of China Shanghai Huayi New Material Co., Ltd. 29,0 88GR Pinghu Petro Chemical Co., Ltd. 22,3 88GS Other Chinese cooperating companies in Annex 23,9 See Annex All other imports originating in China 29,0 8999 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia All imports originating in Saudi Arabia 40,3 8999 The Republic of South Africa Sasol South Africa Ltd 32,4 88GV All other imports originating in South Africa 32,4 8999 The United States of America Dow Chemical Company 39,0 88GW All other imports originating in the USA 39,0 8999
4. The application of the individual duty rates specified for the companies mentioned in paragraph 3 shall be conditional upon presentation to the Member States’ customs authorities of a valid commercial invoice, on which shall appear a declaration dated and signed by an official of the entity issuing such invoice, identified by their name and function, drafted as follows: ‘I, the undersigned, certify that the tonnes of acrylic esters sold for export to the European Union covered by this invoice was manufactured by (company name and address) (TARIC additional code) in (name of country concerned). I declare that the information provided in this invoice is complete and correct.’ Until such an invoice with this declaration is presented, the duty applicable to all other imports originating in the country concerned shall apply.
5. The release for free circulation in the Union of the product referred to in paragraph 1 shall be subject to the provision of a security deposit equivalent to the amount of the provisional duty.
6. Unless otherwise specified, the provisions in force concerning customs duties shall apply.
Article 2
1. Interested parties shall submit their written comments on this regulation to the Commission within 15 calendar days of the date of entry into force of this Regulation.
2. Interested parties wishing to request a hearing with the Commission shall do so within 5 calendar days of the date of entry into force of this Regulation.
3. Interested parties wishing to request a hearing with the Hearing Officer in trade proceedings are invited to do so within 5 calendar days of the date of entry into force of this Regulation. The Hearing Officer may examine requests submitted outside this time limit and may decide whether to accept to such requests if appropriate.
Article 3
1. Customs authorities are hereby directed to discontinue the registration of imports established in accordance with Article 1(1) of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1085.
2. Data collected regarding products which entered the EU for consumption not more than 90 days prior to the date of the entry into force of this Regulation shall be kept until the entry into force of possible definitive measures, or the termination of this proceeding.
Article 4
This Regulation shall enter into force on the day following that of its publication in the Official Journal of the European Union .
Annex 1ANNEX
Chinese cooperating exporting producers not sampled
Company Name TARIC additional code Wanhua-PIC Petrochemicals Co., Ltd. 88GT Jiangsu Sandie Chemical CO., Ltd. 88GU