Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1981 of 7 October 2025 imposing a definitive anti-dumping duty on imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware originating in the People’s Republic of China following an expiry review pursuant to Article 11(2) of Regulation (EU) 2016/1036 of the European Parliament and of the Council
Preamble 1
THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,
Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,
Having regard to Regulation (EU) 2016/1036 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2016 on protection against dumped imports from countries not members of the European Union ( 1 ) (‘the basic Regulation’), and in particular Article 11(2) thereof,
Whereas:
1.PROCEDURE
1.1. Previous investigations and measures in force
HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:
recital 1recital 1
(1) By Regulation (EU) No 1072/2012 ( 2 ) , the Eurpean Commission (‘the Commission’) imposed a provisional anti-dumping duty on imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware, originating in the People’s Republic of China (‘China’ or ‘the PRC’).
recital 2recital 2
(2) By Implementing Regulation (EU) No 412/2013 ( 3 ) , the Council imposed anti-dumping duties on imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware, originating in the PRC (‘the original measures’). The investigation that led to the imposition of the original measures will hereinafter be referred to as ‘the original investigation’.
recital 3recital 3
(3) By Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/1932 ( 4 ) , the Commission amended the product scope as defined in the original measures, leading to the exclusion of imports of ceramic condiment or spice mills and their ceramic grinding parts, ceramic coffee mills, ceramic knife sharpeners, ceramic sharpeners, ceramic kitchen tools to be used for cutting, grinding, grating, slicing, scraping and peeling, and cordierite ceramic pizza-stones of a kind used for baking pizza or bread following a partial interim review of the product scope.
recital 4recital 4
(4) By Implementing Regulation (EU) 2019/1198 ( 5 ) , the Commission re-imposed the definitive anti-dumping measures on imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware originating in the People’s Republic of China following an expiry review (the ‘previous expiry review’).
recital 5recital 5
(5) By Implementing Regulation (EU) 2019/2131 ( 6 ) , the Commission amended the existing measures pursuant to an anti-circumvention investigation, extending the residual duty rate of 36,1 % to imports declared by 33 companies previously benefiting from reduced duty rates, and repealing their TARIC additional codes.
recital 6recital 6
(6) The individual anti-dumping duty rates currently in force range from 13,1 % to 18,3 %. All non-sampled cooperating exporting producers in the investigation leading to the original measures (‘the original investigation’) received a duty rate of 17,9 % and all other companies are subject to the residual duty rate of 36,1 % (‘the original measures’).
recital 7recital 7
1.2. Request for an expiry review
(7) Following the publication of a notice of impending expiry ( 7 ) , the Commission received a request for a review pursuant to Article 11(2) of the basic Regulation.
recital 8recital 8
(8) The request for review was submitted on 14 April 2024 by Cerame Unie / The European Federation of Ceramic Table and Ornamentalware (‘FEPF’) and an individual Czech company (‘the applicants’) on behalf of the Union industry of ceramic tableware and kitchenware in the sense of Article 5(4) of the basic Regulation. The request for review was based on the grounds that the expiry of the measures would be likely to result in continuation of dumping and recurrence of injury to the Union industry.
recital 9recital 9
1.3. Initiation of an expiry review
(9) Having determined, after consulting the Committee established by Article 15(1) of the basic Regulation, that sufficient evidence existed for the initiation of an expiry review, on 12 July 2024 the Commission initiated an expiry review with regard to imports into the Union of ceramic tableware and kitchenware originating in the People’s Republic of China (‘the country concerned’) on the basis of Article 11(2) of the basic Regulation. It published a Notice of Initiation in the Official Journal of the European Union ( 8 ) (‘the Notice of Initiation’).
recital 10recital 10
(10) On 19 December 2024, the Commission initiated a partial interim review concerning imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware, originating in the People’s Republic of China, pursuant to Article 11(3) of the basic Regulation. That partial interim review was requested by Cerame-Unie/The European Federation of Ceramic Table and Ornamentalware (‘FEPF’) and it is limited in scope to the examination of dumping.
recital 11recital 11
(11) The China Chamber of Commerce for Exports and Imports of Light Industrial Products and Art Crafts (‘CCCLA’) submitted comments upon initiation of the expiry review investigation. CCCLA drew attention to the length of time that the initial measures had been in place, since they were first imposed back in 2012. Consequently, in CCCLA’s view, the Union industry had already been benefiting from market protection for almost 12 years, and, should the present expiry review lead to an extension of the measures for another 5-five year period, it would result in nearly 18 years of continuous protection of the Union market from imports of Chinese ceramic tableware and kitchenware. CCCLA made reference to Article 11.3 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement (‘ADA’), which states that anti-dumping measures should be terminated after five years unless there is evidence to suggest that they should be continued. CCCLA claimed that an extension of the measures against imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from China would serve merely a protectionist purpose and would be unwarranted, unlawful and harmful to Union market as a whole.
recital 12recital 12
(12) CCCLA further argued that the Union industry is in a sound state, as confirmed by the Regulation imposing provisional measures, the Regulation extending the measures and the present request for an expiry review investigation, demonstrating that the Union industry has, except for 2010 followed by full-scale economic crisis in the EU, been profitable at a rate of between 2 % and 5 % since 2008. Therefore, there is no injury that needs to be counteracted.
recital 13recital 13
(13) This claim had to be dismissed. The Commission recalls that Article 11.3 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement (‘ADA’) and Article 11(2) of the basic Regulation allow for an exception of the five-year expiry rule if it is determined in a review that the expiry would be likely to lead to a continuation or recurrence of dumping and injury.
recital 14recital 14
(14) As regards the situation of the Union industry, the Commission noted that the purpose of anti-dumping measures is to eliminate the trade distorting effects of injurious dumping and to restore effective competition by having a positive effect on the state of the Union industry. Even if the Union industry had not suffered material injury in the period considered by the request, one would need to assess whether resulting from the Chinese imports injury may recur if measures would be allowed to lapse. In addition, the Notice of Initiation stated in point 4.2 that the applicants alleged the likelihood of continuation or recurrence of injury from the PRC. In this respect, the applicants have provided sufficient evidence that, should measures be allowed to lapse, the current import level of the product under review from the country concerned to the Union would likely increase significantly and cause further injury to the Union industry. Therefore, this claim was dismissed.
recital 15recital 15
(15) At initiation, CCCLA requested the Commission to reject the applicants’ claim on the alleged significant distortions and accept the domestic prices and costs reported by the cooperating Chinese exporters. To support this claim, CCCLA further argued that: (a) The applicants relied heavily on the ‘Commission Staff Working Document on Significant Distortions in the Economy of the People’s Republic of China for the Purposes of Trade Defence Investigations’ ( 9 ) . As the report was prepared by the Commission with the specific purpose of facilitating the lodging of trade defence complaints by Union industries, it cannot be considered impartial nor objective. (b) The claim by the applicants according to which the mentions of the Chinese light industry contained in the 14th Five-Year Plan are enough to evidence of significant distortions is misguided, as all Five-Year Plans are merely guiding documents, and do not have binding force. Moreover, the Commission has published similar plans, such as the ‘New Industrial Strategy’ ( 10 ) , which aims to steer the future development of the EU industries. (c) Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation, to which the applicants referred, appears to be incompatible with Article 2.2 of the WTO ADA. On this specific point, CCCLA provided three arguments: (i) Article 2.2 of the WTO ADA does not mention the concept of ‘significant distortions’ but rather provides an alternative calculation method for normal values. This alternative calculation method is reserved for event that there are ‘no sales in the ordinary course of trade in the domestic market of the exporting country’, or ‘because of the particular market situation or the low volume of the sales in the domestic market of the exporting country’, neither of which fits the concept of ‘significant distortions’. (ii) Article 2.2 of the WTO ADA only permits using ‘the cost of production in the country of origin plus a reasonable amount for administrative, selling, and general costs and profits’ when constructing normal value, and does not consider the possibility of using data from an appropriate representative country or international prices. (iii) Article 2.2.1.1 of the WTO ADA provides that costs shall be calculated on the basis of records kept by the exporting producers, provided that they are reasonable and follow international accounting standards. Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation contradicts this stance by allowing the Commission to disregard the cost of production and sales in the exporting country and then use such data from a third country.
recital 16recital 16
(16) Finally, the CCCLA pointed to WTO jurisprudence ( 11 ) ( 12 ) stablishing that investigating authorities must use the product costs actually incurred by producers or exporters for the calculation of constructed normal values. It also argued that WTO jurisprudence supports its claim that Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation appears to be inconsistent with Article 2.2 and 2.2.1.1 of the WTO ADA.
recital 17recital 17
(17) The Commission recalled that its Report constitutes a body of evidence placed on the file of the investigation that the Commission can rely upon to find existence of significant distortions, as provided by Article 2(6a)(c) of the basic Regulation. The Report has been published on 21 December 2017 and updated on 10 April 2024, after providing the opportunity for everybody (that is, not only the parties to a particular anti-dumping investigation) to submit comments, rebut, and supplement the evidence contained in the Report. To date, the Commission has received no contribution on the Report questioning the objectivity thereof. Moreover, the CCCLA itself did not provide any specific elements rebutting the evidence or the legal conclusions contained in the Report. Accordingly, it has not been shown why the Report would lack objectivity and the claim that the Report could not be relied on in this investigation was rejected.
recital 18recital 18
(18) The claim that Five-Year Plans are merely guiding documents is already demerited in the ‘Commission Staff Working Document on Significant Distortions in the Economy of the People’s Republic of China for the Purposes of Trade Defence Investigations’, mentioned above.
recital 19recital 19
(19) The report foresees this argument and considers that ‘However, the fact that the FYPs (or the overarching strategies) do not have a precisely defined status within the Chinese legal order does not […] put in question their binding nature which transpires from other pieces of legislation, such as the Organic Law of the Local People’s Congresses and Local People’s Governments of the PRC. This law unequivocally obliges said authorities to implement the FYPs […].In view of the above, it is apparent that the implementation and reference to higher level plans is resolutely addressed across plans at every level, often in the introductory part or the final chapters of the respective FYPs and other planning documents. This cannot be dismissed as simply aspirational language since the implementation of plans is mandated by law, including by the Constitution. In addition, the implementation and fulfilment of targets set by various plans are regularly monitored and evaluated […]’ ( 13 ) .
recital 20recital 20
(20) With regard to point (c) and to the further claims related to the compliance of the normal value construction with WTO jurisprudence, the Commission noted that, in the case at hand, the Commission had applied the relevant rules contained in Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation. The Commission considered that the provision of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation is fully consistent with the European Union’s WTO obligations and the jurisprudence. Indeed, the existence of significant distortions renders costs and prices in the exporting country inappropriate for the construction of normal value. In these circumstances, Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation envisages the construction of costs of production and sale on the basis of undistorted prices or benchmarks, including those in an appropriate representative country with a similar level of development as the exporting country. As explicitly clarified by the Appellate Body in DS473 ( 14 ) , WTO law permits the use of data from a third country, duly adjusted when such adjustment is necessary and substantiated. The Commission recalled in this connection that once it is determined that due to the existence of significant distortions in the exporting country in accordance with Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation it is not appropriate to use domestic prices and costs in the exporting country, the normal value is constructed by reference to undistorted prices or benchmarks in an appropriate representative country for each exporting producer according to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation. The same provision of the basic Regulation also allows the use of domestic costs if they are positively established not to be distorted. In that context, the exporting producers had the possibility to provide evidence that their individual costs were undistorted. However, no positive evidence as to the factors of production of individual exporting producers being undistorted was submitted.
recital 21recital 21
(21) On the construction of the Normal Value proposed in the expiry review request, CCCLA argued that by disclosing cost structure and prices in ranges, the applicants were infringing CCCLA’s right of defence and not complying with WTO practice. Additionally, the CCCLA claimed that the level of SG & A costs and profit found by the applicants proved that the constructed normal value (‘CNV’) established in the expiry review request cannot be compared to the price of sales by Chinese producers/exporters.
recital 22recital 22
(22) Moreover, CCCLA noted that while in previous investigations the applicants split up the product concerned into different product types for its calculation of the CNV, in the present proceeding they used a simplified approach and aggregated values, leading to an unrepresentative CNV. To support this claim, CCCLA further argued that: (a) The complexity of the Commission’s product control number (‘PCN’) used in the initial and first review investigations highlights the fact that a comparison based on the aggregated single product mix was meaningless from an economic perspective. (b) The website of the producer identified in the representative country by the applicants for the calculation of SG & A costs and profit margins showed a wide range of products that cannot be objectively put together for establishing a single CNV.
recital 23recital 23
(23) Therefore, the CCCLA qualified the applicants’ approach as unacceptable, and argues that the data used in the dumping margin assessment section of the review request should not have been accepted by the Commission.
recital 24recital 24
(24) Regarding the CCCLA’s right to defence, the Commission considered that the version open for inspection by interested parties of the complaint contained all the essential evidence and non-confidential summaries of data provided under confidential cover to let the interested parties exercise their right of defence throughout the proceeding. These summaries were therefore sufficiently detailed to permit a reasonable understanding of the substance of the information submitted in confidence pursuant to Article 19(2) of the basic Regulation.
recital 25recital 25
(25) It is further recalled that Article 19(2) of the basic Regulation and Article 6(5) of the WTO ADA allow for the safeguarding of confidential information in circumstances where disclosure would be of significant competitive advantage to a competitor or would have a significantly adverse effect upon a person supplying the information or upon a person from whom that person has acquired the information. The information provided under confidential cover falls under these categories. Therefore, the bracketing of relevant numerical data was considered appropriate and sufficient to ensure the right to defence of interested parties. Consequently, this claim was rejected.
recital 26recital 26
(26) As regards the level of SG & A costs and profit employed in the construction of the Normal value in the expiry review request, the CCCLA provided no explanation as to why this would render the comparison of the CNV and the export price of the product concerned from China unrepresentative. Therefore, the claim was rejected.
recital 27recital 27
(27) Finally, concerning the claims that the use of a single product type for the construction of the normal value of the product concerned in the complaint was intolerable and should have not been accepted by the Commission, it is recalled that, according to Article 5(3) of the basic Regulation, the Commission shall, as far as possible, examine the accuracy and adequacy of the evidence provided in the complaint, to determine whether there is sufficient evidence to justify the initiation of an investigation. In this context, the Commission reminded the CCCLA that complainants are not subject to the same standard of proof as the Commission is during an investigation. Moreover, the applicants cannot be required to use information that is not available to them. In this case, the Commission analysed the expiry review request thoroughly and confirmed that sufficient evidence of a likelihood of dumping and injury existed to justify the initiation of an expiry review. Therefore, this claim was rejected.
recital 28recital 28
1.4. Review investigation period and period considered
(28) The investigation of a continuation of dumping covered the period from 1 January 2023 to 31 December 2023 (‘the review investigation period’ or ‘RIP’). The examination of the trends relevant for the assessment of the likelihood of continuation of recurrence of injury covered the period from 1 January 2020 to the end of the review investigation period (‘the period considered’).
recital 29recital 29
(29) CCCLA criticised the selection of both the period considered and the RIP as it would not meet the legal standard prescribed by Article 6(1) of the basic Regulation and strongly distorts potential findings by pushing them towards positive determinations on dumping and injury recurrence due to two main factors.
recital 30recital 30
(30) Firstly, setting the RIP from the first to the fourth quarter of 2023 would be unacceptably distant, given that the request for a review investigation was lodged on 27 May 2024, and proceedings were initiated on 12 July. Furthermore, using 2020 as a benchmark for analysing import trends and the current state of the Union industry would produce a distorted picture due to the heavy impact of the administrative measures adopted in response to the pandemic in 2020, and would impede an objective examination of this case based on positive evidence. The CCCLA concluded that the applicants should have been invited to resubmit the request based on a non-distorted period considered, i.e. as of 1 January 2019, excluding the year 2020, with the end date as close as possible to the initiation date.
recital 31recital 31
(31) In determining the investigation period, the Commission’s general approach aligns with Article 6(1), second subparagraph of the basic Regulation (applicable to reviews pursuant to Article 11(5), first subparagraph of the basic Regulation), which states that the ‘investigation period shall be selected which in the case of dumping shall, normally, cover a period of no less than six months immediately prior to the initiation of proceedings’. In the present review, by contrast to a normal case, exceptional circumstances had to be taken into account in view of the Union industry’s composition, which is high fragmented, with a very high proportion of SMEs. In order to ensure access to this trade defence instrument for such a diverse and fragmented industry, the Commission used the last full calendar year preceding the year in which the investigation was initiated. It is common practice for small and medium-sized enterprises to have a financial year that corresponds to the calendar year. By letting the review investigation period coincide with the calendar year, and consequently with the financial year, as set out in Article 6(9), last sentence of the basic Regulation, the Commission sought to reduce the burden on SMEs in providing information in the investigation. CCCLA’s claim was therefore rejected.
recital 32recital 32
1.4.1. Interested parties
(32) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission invited all interested parties to participate in the investigation. In particular, it advised the following parties of the initiation of the expiry review: the applicants, the known producers in the Union and their relevant associations, the known exporting producers in the PRC, the known unrelated importers in the Union and the authorities of the PRC.
recital 33recital 33
(33) Interested parties had an opportunity to comment on the initiation of the expiry review and to request a hearing with the Commission and/or the Hearing Officer in trade proceedings.
recital 34recital 34
(34) The Commission received, together with the request for review dated 14 April 2024, a request for anonymity from six Union producers supporting the expiry review request. All those who requested anonymity brought forward their reasoning for not revealing their identity. The companies claimed concerns of retaliation from their customers in China, as well as indirectly from Chinese competitors through the customers and distributors they have in common in the European Union and in other parts of the world. To avoid risk of retaliation from private Chinese actors, which could potentially have a severe negative impact on their business activities, the companies requested the Commission to keep their identity confidential.
recital 35recital 35
(35) The Commission assessed these requests, and the supporting evidence provided. The Commission concluded that indeed the alleged risk of retaliation exists and, on this basis, granted confidential treatment to the identity of the companies in question ( 15 ) .
recital 36recital 36
1.4.2. Sampling
(36) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission stated that it might sample the interested parties in accordance with Article 17 of the basic Regulation.
recital 37recital 37
1.4.2.1. Sampling of Union producers
(37) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission stated that it had provisionally selected a sample of Union producers. The Commission selected the sample on the basis of the producers’ production volumes of the like product, size, geographic location in the Union and product segment. The sample consisted of three Union producers located in three Member States, including Portugal and Romania ( 16 ) , and covered all major product types. Out of these three producers, one was a small and medium-sized enterprise (SME ( 17 ) ). The provisional sample accounted for [19 to 24] % of the estimated total volume of production and for [41 to 52] % of the estimated total sales of the like product in the Union in 2023.
recital 38recital 38
(38) Following the establishment of the provisional sample, the selected SME informed the Commission that organisational and financial circumstances made it objectively unfeasible for this company to participate in the investigation as a sampled Union producer. Having reviewed the arguments raised in the comments received by Cerame-Unie/FEPF, the Commission amended its provisional sample to include another SME in order to maintain a representative sample ( 18 ) . Consequently, the resulting final sample included three Union producers located in three Member States, including Portugal and Romania, out of which one was an SME, and covering all major product types ( 19 ) . That sample represented [16–21] % of estimated total EU production and [35–46] % of estimated total EU sales volume of the like product on the Union market in 2023.
recital 39recital 39
(39) CCCLA provided comments on the sample of the Union industry and raised concerns about potential self-selection strategies within the Union industry, as demonstrated by the abovementioned SME’s refusal to cooperate under the pretext of organisational and financial circumstances rather than the substance of the sample (i.e. production volumes, product mix, scale of company, geographical scope). This exercise could be repeated with an aim that companies performing below the average for the entire industry in the Union be included in the sample by the Commission, which would distort the injury determination. In this context, CCCLA referred to the Appellate Body Report in European Communities – Definitive Anti-Dumping Measures on Certain Iron or Steel Fasteners from China (Article 21.5) which would state that investigating authority shall not define the domestic industry in a way that it would include, exclusively or predominantly, producers considering themselves injured by allegedly dumped imports ( 20 ) .
recital 40recital 40
(40) According to Article 17(1) of the basic Regulation the Commission has to select a sample that is statistically valid according to the information available at the time of the selection and, in case of non-cooperation of one of the sampled entities that is likely to materially affect the outcome of the investigation, in accordance with Article 17(4) of the basic Regulation, a new sample may be selected. The revised sample was very similar to the original sample in terms of coverage of production and sales. Furthermore, according to the provision of Article 17(2) of the basic Regulation the final selection of parties made under the sampling provisions rest with the Commission and not with the parties involved. The claim was therefore dismissed.
recital 41recital 41
1.4.2.2. Sampling of importers
(41) To decide whether sampling was necessary and, if so, to select a sample, the Commission asked unrelated importers to provide the information specified in the Notice of Initiation.
recital 42recital 42
(42) The European Commission did not receive a reply containing the information requested in the Annex to the Notice of Initiation from any unrelated importer within the deadline set in the Notice of Initiation. Therefore, no sample of unrelated importers was selected.
recital 43recital 43
1.4.2.3. Sampling of exporting producers in the PRC
(43) To decide whether sampling is necessary and, if so, to select a sample, the Commission asked all known exporting producers in the PRC to provide the information specified in the Notice of Initiation. In addition, it asked the Mission of the People’s Republic of China to the European Union to identify and/or contact other exporting producers, if any, that could be interested in participating in the investigation.
recital 44recital 44
(44) One hundred and one (101) Chinese exporting producers / groups of exporting producers provided the requested information and agreed to be included in the sample. These cooperating Chinese exporting producers together represented around 21 % of the total imports from China during the RIP and around 8 % of the total production and production capacity in China. After analysing the information supplied by the Chinese exporting producers, the Commission decided to limit its investigation to a reasonable number of exporting producers by using a sample in accordance with Article 17(1) of the basic Regulation. On 8 August 2024 the Commission selected a sample of three groups of exporting producers based on the largest sales volume to the Union during the review investigation period. The three sampled groups covered around 21 % of the total import volumes from China and around 8 % of the total production in China during the RIP ( 21 ) .
recital 45recital 45
1.5. Replies to the questionnaire
(45) The Commission sent a questionnaire concerning the existence of significant distortions in the PRC within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation to the Government of the People’s Republic of China (‘GOC’). The GOC did not submit any responses to the questionnaire.
recital 46recital 46
(46) The Commission sent questionnaires to the three sampled groups of Chinese exporting producers and to the GOC and to the three sampled Union producers, as well as to Cerame-Unie/FEPF.
recital 47recital 47
(47) Only one of the Chinese exporting producers provided a complete questionnaire reply. The three sampled Union producers and Cerame-Unie/FEPF also provided complete questionnaire replies.
recital 48recital 48
(48) The only exporting producer that provided a complete questionnaire reply accounted for around [1–2] % of the total volume of imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from the PRC into the European Union during the RIP. The Commission services considered that such a low level of imports would have not provided sufficient information to assess the export price and the existence of dumping during the review investigation period and could not be considered as representative of the total imports from the People’s Republic of China. In view of the insufficient level of cooperation, the Commission informed the interested parties that it may base its findings on facts available as provided for in Article 18 of the basic Regulation ( 22 ) .
recital 49recital 49
(49) The Commission sought and verified all the information it deemed necessary for a determination of the likelihood of a continuation or recurrence of dumping and injury and of the Union interest. Verification visits pursuant to Article 16 were carried out at the premises of the following Union producers/associations. — SC Apulum SA, Romania, — Ria Stone – Fábrica de Louça de Mesa em Grés, S.A., Portugal, — Anonymous Company 7 (SME, see recital (50) below), — Cerame-Unie/FEPF.
recital 50recital 50
1.5.1. Confidentiality requests
(50) Similar to the requests made by the supporting Union producers at initiation as outlined in recital (35), above, both SMEs, one of which was selected for the preliminary sample and the other which was selection for the final sample, respectively, requested that their identities be kept confidential for fear that they could face retaliation by customers or competitors concerned by this investigation, in accordance with Article 19(1) of the basic Regulation. Following an individual examination of their merits, the Commission found all confidentiality requests to be justified and accepted that the identities of those companies should not be disclosed ( 23 ) . Moreover, the Commission considered that it was not appropriate to disclose the Member State(s) where these SMEs are located since this could also disclose the identity of the companies concerned.
recital 51recital 51
(51) The CCCLA claimed that the non-disclosure of the identities of Union producers who either supported the request for the investigation or cooperated by agreeing to be included in the sample constituted a severe breach of the rights of defence of other interested parties. Firstly, CCCLA argued that, if the identity of certain sampled/preliminary sampled Union producers are not disclosed, interested parties are prevented from providing meaningful comments on the representativeness of this sample. Secondly, the Commission’s injury findings always include an analysis of certain ‘microeconomic indicators’, which are solely related to the sampled EU producers. If any of these producers remain anonymous throughout the proceedings, interested parties would not be able to verify or comment on the validity of the Commission’s injury findings. Thirdly, in view of a correct determination of the margin of injury, if the Commission withholds the identity of the Union producer included in the sample, interested parties would also be prevented from verifying whether that producer produces branded or generic products.
recital 52recital 52
(52) According to the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice the protection of rights of defence must be, where necessary, reconciled with the duty to respect confidential information, which is specifically laid down in Article 19 of the basic Regulation, even though that duty cannot deprive the rights of the defence of their essential content ( 24 ) . This reconciliation permits the receipt of non-confidential summaries of such information (carried out, for instance, in the form of ranges and/or indexed elements of information). However, it must always be ensured that, even in summarised form, the information would not result in the disclosure of business secrets.
recital 53recital 53
(53) Following the reconciliation indicated in the case law recalled above, the Commission has ensured throughout the current investigation that all relevant issues could be verified and dealt with in the files available for inspection by interested parties. These files included notes on the sample selection and its representativeness, open submissions of the sampled Union producers including ranges and/or indexed information and other relevant communication with those companies and their representatives, such as on the percentage of branded products produced by the different sampled companies. No information, other than that of which an open version was disclosed to the interested parties, was used in the choice of sampled companies or the determination of the Commission’s injury findings. The disclosure of the identity of these companies would therefore not have provided the interested parties with any additional information that would have been relevant to verifying the correctness of the Commission’s findings. Hence, the Commission deemed the information provided in the documents disclosed to the interested parties sufficient to satisfy the rights of defence of interested parties, while disclosing the identities of the Union producers would have likely caused irreparable and disproportionate economic harm to them. The claim was therefore rejected.
recital 54recital 54
2.PRODUCT CONCERNED AND LIKE PRODUCT
2.1. Product under review
(54) The product under review is the same as defined in Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/1932 following a product scope review initiated on 12 April 2017 ( 25 ) , that is ceramic tableware and kitchenware, excluding ceramic condiment or spice mills and their ceramic grinding parts, ceramic coffee mills, ceramic knife sharpeners, ceramic sharpeners, ceramic kitchen tools to be used for cutting, grinding, grating, slicing, scraping and peeling, and cordierite ceramic pizza-stones of a kind used for baking pizza or bread (‘the product under review’), currently falling under CN codes ex 6911 10 00 , ex 6912 00 21 , ex 6912 00 23 , ex 6912 00 25 and ex 6912 00 29 (TARIC codes 6911 10 00 90, 6912 00 21 11, 6912 00 21 91, 6912 00 23 10, 6912 00 25 10 and 6912 00 29 10) and originating in the People’s Republic of China (‘the product concerned’ or ‘ceramic tableware and kitchenware’).
recital 55recital 55
(55) Ceramic tableware and kitchenware can be made of porcelain (including China/bone China), of common pottery, stoneware, earthenware or fine pottery or other materials. The final ceramic product depends on the type and composition of the main raw materials such as clay, kaolin, feldspar and quartz.
recital 56recital 56
(56) Ceramic tableware and kitchenware products are commercialised in a large variety of forms that have been evolving over time. They are used in a wide range of places, e.g. households, hotels, restaurants or care establishments and are principally intended to come into contact with food.
recital 57recital 57
2.2. Product concerned
(57) The product concerned by this investigation is the product under review originating in the People’s Republic of China currently falling under CN codes 6911 10 00 , ex 6912 00 21 , ex 6912 00 23 , ex 6912 00 25 and ex 6912 00 29 (TARIC codes 6911 10 00 90, 6912 00 21 11, 6912 00 21 91, 6912 00 23 10, 6912 00 25 10 and 6912 00 29 10).
recital 58recital 58
2.3. Like product
(58) As established in the original investigation, as well as in the previous expiry review investigation, this expiry review investigation confirmed that the following products have the same basic physical and chemical characteristics, and the same basic uses. — the product concerned when exported to the Union, — the product under review produced and sold on the domestic market of the PRC, — the product under review produced and sold by the exporting producers to the rest of the world;, and — the product under review produced and sold in the Union by the Union industry.
recital 59recital 59
(59) They are therefore considered to be like products within the meaning of Article 1(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 60recital 60
3.DUMPING
3.1. Procedure for the determination of the normal value under Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation for the imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware) originating in the PRC
(60) In view of the sufficient evidence available at the initiation of the investigation tending to show the existence in the PRC of significant distortions within the meaning of point (b) of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation, the Commission considered it appropriate to initiate the investigation on the basis of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 61recital 61
(61) Consequently, in order to collect the necessary data for the eventual application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation, in the Notice of Initiation the Commission invited all known producers in the PRC to provide the information requested in Annex III to the Notice of the Initiation regarding the inputs used for producing the product under review.
recital 62recital 62
(62) In order to obtain the information that it deemed necessary for its investigation with regard to the alleged significant distortions within the meaning of point (b) of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation, the Commission also sent a questionnaire to the GOC. No reply was received from the GOC.
recital 63recital 63
(63) In the Notice of Initiation, the Commission also invited all interested parties to make their views known, submit information and provide supporting evidence regarding the appropriateness of the application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation within 37 days of the date of publication of this Notice in the Official Journal of the European Union .
recital 64recital 64
(64) In the Notice of Initiation the Commission also specified that, in view of the evidence available, it might need to select an appropriate representative country pursuant to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation for the purpose of determining the normal value based on undistorted prices or benchmarks.
recital 65recital 65
(65) On 6 June 2025, the Commission published a note to the file ( 26 ) (‘the Note of 6 June’) seeking the views of the interested parties on the relevant sources that the Commission might use for the determination of the normal value, in accordance with Article 2(6a)(e) second indent of the basic Regulation. Based on the information contained in the expiry review request updated where available, combined with other sources of available information deemed appropriate according to the relevant criteria laid down in Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation in accordance with Article 18(5) of the basic Regulation the Commission provided a list of all factors of production such as materials, energy and labour used in the production of ceramic tableware and kitchenware by the exporting producers. In addition, based on the criteria guiding the choice of undistorted prices or benchmarks, the Commission identified three potential representative countries: Brazil, Thailand and Türkiye and concluded that, at that stage, Türkiye was the most appropriate representative country under Article 2(6a)(a), first indent of the basic Regulation.
recital 66recital 66
(66) The Commission gave the opportunity to all interested parties to comment. The Commission received comments from the applicants.
recital 67recital 67
(67) The present Regulation has addressed these comments in Section 5.1.2 below.
recital 68recital 68
3.2. Subsequent procedure
(68) On 1 August 2025, the Commission disclosed the essential facts and considerations on the basis of which it intended to maintain the anti-dumping duties (‘final disclosure’). All parties were granted a period within which they could make comments on the disclosure.
recital 69recital 69
(69) The comments made by interested parties were considered by the Commission and taken into account, where appropriate. The parties who so requested were granted an opportunity to be heard.
recital 70recital 70
3.3. Normal value
(70) According to Article 2(1) of the basic Regulation, ‘the normal value shall normally be based on the prices paid or payable, in the ordinary course of trade, by independent customers in the exporting country’.
recital 71recital 71
(71) However, according to Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation, ‘in case it is determined […] that it is not appropriate to use domestic prices and costs in the exporting country due to the existence in that country of significant distortions within the meaning of point (b), the normal value shall be constructed exclusively on the basis of costs of production and sale reflecting undistorted prices or benchmarks’, and ‘shall include an undistorted and reasonable amount of administrative, selling and general costs and for profits’ (‘administrative, selling and general costs’ is referred to hereinafter as ‘SG & A costs’).
recital 72recital 72
(72) As further explained below, the Commission concluded in the present investigation that, based on the evidence available, the application of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation was appropriate.
recital 73recital 73
3.4. Existence of significant distortions
(73) The Commission examined the evidence on the file to decide whether significant distortions within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation exist in the People’s Republic of China (‘PRC’), rendering the use of domestic prices and costs in that country inappropriate. That analysis covered the following evidentiary elements on the various criteria relevant to establish the existence of significant distortions.
recital 74recital 74
(74) First, the evidence contained in the request included the following elements pointing to the existence of significant distortions.
recital 75recital 75
(75) In the request, the applicants highlighted – as an important feature of the ‘socialist market economy’ – the active guidance of the Chinese Communist Party (‘CCP’) in both the public and private sector of the economy. In addition, the applicants underlined the existence of cross-cutting systemic distortions in China and analysed government interventions at various levels of the economy, in particular in the ceramic sector and the market of ceramic tableware and kitchenware.
recital 76recital 76
(76) The request further noted that the Chinese ceramic sector, including the market of the product under review are served by enterprises that operate under the ownership, control or policy supervision or guidance of Chinese authorities. In this regard, the applicants pointed out the interference of the Government of China (‘GOC’) in the economy through tight links with both public and private entities and stated that the GOC’s policy goals are achieved through several measures, among which the national economic plans.
recital 77recital 77
(77) The request in particular mentioned the 13th Five-Year Development Plan for 2016-2020 – the Light Industry Development Plan – and the related Guiding Opinions, which aim at strengthening and improving fiscal and financial support policies for the sector and encouraging local governments to pursue the goals set for the sector also at provincial and municipal level ( 27 ) . The applicants noted that given its importance within the Chinese light industries, the ceramic industry is under ongoing policy oversight and guidance from the GOC to ensure adherence to these plans. The Work Plan for Steady Growth of Light Industry (2023-2024), which includes also the ceramic sector, represents another policy document put in place by the GOC to guide the functioning of the sector, through the adoption of ‘more powerful measures […] to enhance development momentum, optimize the economics structure, and promote the continued recovery of the economy’ ( 28 ) .
recital 78recital 78
(78) The request also noted that the presence of the state in firms allows it to interfere with respect to prices and costs of the product under review. The applicants reiterated the Commission’s conclusions in the first expiry review, in particular with regard to the continuous Chinese interference through the establishment CCP cells in both State-owned and private enterprises. The applicants referred to the CCP presence in companies such as Great Wall Group and Guandong Sitong, with CCP members in managerial positions. Moreover, the request highlighted the inclusion of ceramic raw materials in provincial plans such as in the Jiangxi Comprehensive Plan for Mineral Resources (2016-2020) and the Guangdong Provincial Mineral Resources Master Plan (2021-2025).
recital 79recital 79
(79) Moreover, the applicants underlined the existence of public policies or measures discriminating in favour of domestic suppliers or otherwise influencing free market forces. It highlighted findings of previous antidumping investigations, in which the Commission established that resources are allocated to sectors designated as strategic, or otherwise economically important, including the ceramic sector, and recalled that the GOC has been implementing an ‘industrial cluster developing strategy’ to provide strategic infrastructure and specialised facilities. Therefore, the applicants concluded that the Chinese state allocates resources to the Chinese ceramic sector while requiring companies to adhere to State policies, influencing free market forces in such sector.
recital 80recital 80
(80) The request also examined the lack, discriminatory application, or inadequate enforcement of bankruptcy, corporate or property laws within the ceramic sector and in the market of the product under review. The applicants noted the important role of the GOC in insolvency proceedings, including the fact the Chinese People’s Court is subordinated to the Chinese government. The court later has to give prior approval to decide whether to accept or reject the applications of listed companies in. With regards to property laws in China, the applicants indicated that all land is owned by the state, therefore its allocation is solely dependent on the GOC. It also reiterated the findings of the first expiry review, in which the Commission established that despite the existence of legal provisions for the allocation of land use in a transparent manner, these are regularly not respected.
recital 81recital 81
(81) Lastly, the request underlined that the wage costs are distorted in China and specifically in the ceramic sector and in the market of the product under review. Such distortions were already established in the first expiry review and the applicants found no evidence that the ceramic tableware and kitchenware sector is shielded from the wage costs’ distortions.
recital 82recital 82
(82) Second, in a recent investigation concerning the ceramic sector in the PRC ( 29 ) , the Commission found that significant distortions in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation were present. In this investigation, the Commission found that there is substantial government intervention in the PRC resulting in a distortion of the effective allocation of resources in line with market principles ( 30 ) . In particular, the Commission concluded that in the ceramic sector, not only does a substantial degree of ownership by the GOC persists in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b), first indent of the basic Regulation ( 31 ) but the GOC is also in a position to interfere with prices and costs through State presence in firms in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b), second indent of the basic Regulation ( 32 ) . The Commission found further that the State’s presence and intervention in the financial markets, as well as in the provision of raw materials and inputs further have an additional distorting effect on the market. Indeed, overall, the system of planning in the PRC results in resources being driven to sectors designated as strategic or otherwise politically important by the GOC, rather than being allocated in line with market forces ( 33 ) . Moreover, the Commission concluded that the Chinese bankruptcy and property laws do not work properly in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b), fourth indent of the basic Regulation, thus generating distortions in particular when maintaining insolvent firms afloat and when allocating land use rights in the PRC ( 34 ) . In the same vein, the Commission found distortions of wage costs in the ceramic sector in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b), fifth indent of the basic Regulation ( 35 ) , as well as distortions in the financial markets in the sense of Article 2(6a)(b), sixth indent of the basic Regulation, in particular concerning access to capital for corporate actors in the PRC ( 36 ) .
recital 83recital 83
(83) Third, in the first expiry review concerning the product under review ( 37 ) the Commission concluded that significant distortions within the meaning of point (b) of Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation were present. No major structural changes in the PRC in general and/or in the relevant sector in particular, capable of affecting that conclusion, are known to the Commission.
recital 84recital 84
(84) Fourth, additional evidence available in the Report on Significant Distortions in the Economy of China (‘Report’) ( 38 ) , prepared by the Commission pursuant to Article 2(6a)(c) of the basic Regulation and recalled above, pointed to the existence of significant distortions also during the review investigation period.
recital 85recital 85
(85) Fifth, no evidence or arguments to the contrary have been adduced by the GOC or the exporting producers in the present investigation.
recital 86recital 86
(86) In view of the above, the evidence available showed that prices or costs of the product under review, including the costs of raw materials, energy and labour, are not the result of free market forces because they are affected by substantial government intervention within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation as shown by the actual or potential impact of one or more of the relevant elements listed therein. On that basis, the Commission concluded that it is not appropriate to use domestic prices and costs to establish normal value in this case. Consequently, the Commission proceeded to construct the normal value exclusively on the basis of costs of production and sale reflecting undistorted prices or benchmarks, that is, in this case, on the basis of corresponding costs of production and sale in an appropriate representative country, in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 87recital 87
(87) Upon disclosure, CCCLA urged the Commission to accept the domestic prices and costs reported by the cooperating Chinese exporters and reverse its decision on significant distortions. To support this claim, CCCLA further argued that: (a) The Commission relied heavily on the ‘Commission Staff Working Document on Significant Distortions in the Economy of the People’s Republic of China for the Purposes of Trade Defence Investigations’ ( 39 ) . As the report was prepared by the Commission with the specific purpose of facilitating the lodging of trade defence complaints by Union industries, it cannot be considered impartial nor objective. (b) The consideration according to which the mentions of the Chinese light industry contained in the 14th Five-Year Plan are enough to evidence of significant distortions is misguided, as all Five-Year Plans are merely guiding documents, and do not have binding force. Moreover, the Commission has published similar plans, such as the ‘New Industrial Strategy’ ( 40 ) , which aims to steer the future development of the EU industries.
recital 88recital 88
(88) The Commission remits interested parties to the assessment made in recitals (17) to (19). Based on this, and as CCCLA did not provide any new evidence, the claim was dismissed.
recital 89recital 89
3.5. Representative country
3.5.1. General remarks
(89) Having determined that significant distortions affect prices and/or costs in the Chinese ceramic tableware and kitchenware sector, pursuant to Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation, the Commission constructed the normal value on the basis of costs of production and sale in an appropriate representative country, in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 90recital 90
(90) The choice of the representative country was based on the following criteria pursuant to Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation: — A level of economic development similar to the PRC. For this purpose, the Commission used countries with a gross national income per capita similar to the PRC on the basis of the database of the World Bank ( 41 ) , — Production of the product concerned in that country, — Availability of relevant public data in that country, — Where there is more than one possible representative country, preference shall be given, where appropriate, to the country with an adequate level of social and environmental protection.
recital 91recital 91
(91) As explained in recital (65), the Commission issued one note for the file on the sources for the determination of the normal value, i.e. the Note of 6 June. This Note described the facts and evidence underlying the relevant criteria. In this Note, the Commission informed interested parties of its intention to consider Türkiye as an appropriate representative country in the present case if the existence of significant distortions pursuant to Article 2(6a) of the basic Regulation would be confirmed.
recital 92recital 92
(92) Both the CCCLA and the applicants submitted comments.
recital 93recital 93
3.5.2. A level of economic development similar to the PRC
(93) Brazil, Thailand and Türkiye are all classified as countries with a similar level of economic development as the PRC, that is they are all classified as ‘upper-middle income’ countries by the World Bank.
recital 94recital 94
(94) No comments were received concerning the selection of countries identified in the note.
recital 95recital 95
3.5.3. Production of the product under review in the representative country and availability of relevant public data in the representative country
(95) Practically all countries of the world produce some quantities of the product under review. Following the analysis of the available data and in particular data from the Global Trade Atlas ( 42 ) (‘GTA’) and Orbis Bureau van Dijk ( 43 ) (‘Orbis’), the Commission identified Brazil, Thailand and Türkiye as possible representative countries for this investigation.
recital 96recital 96
(96) The Commission carefully analysed all relevant data available on the file on all factors of productions in all three potential representative countries and noted the following: (a) In the GTA database, all three countries have imports for most of the raw materials in representative quantities. However, for a number of items (such as silica sand and quartz, pigments, and clay) together representing roughly 20 % of cost of production of an integrated producer, Türkiye has significantly higher import quantities than Brazil and Thailand. (b) Additionally, imports from China represented a significant proportion of the imports of Thailand, around 37 % of the overall quantity imported while Chinese imports in Brazil and in Türkiye were negligible (Please refer to Table 1 below). No difference was found in terms of proportion of imports from China compared with the rest of the world when comparing Brazil and Türkiye. At HS codes level, the Commission noted that Brazil had a higher proportion of Chinese imports for 4 HS codes compared with Türkiye (Please refer to Table 1 below). (c) When analysing imports from the rest of the world, in terms of actual imported quantity, Türkiye imported over 10 times more of kaolin (the main raw material in terms of quantity) and 4 times more of pigments from the rest of the world compared with Brazil. For zinc oxide, Brazil imported 5 times more compared with Türkiye. Table 1 FOP imported quantities at HS6 level BR Brazil TH Thailand TR Türkiye Chinese exports/ROW ROW China ROW China ROW China BR TR HS6 250510 2 601 958 401 951 72 265 007 59 221 466 858 671 767 144 634 15,4 % 0,0 % HS6 2507 32 746 822 703 040 56 878 756 26 337 539 347 859 951 7 528 703 2,1 % 2,2 % HS6 250810 80 378 719 1 466 098 111 787 710 35 005 923 7 955 919 681 033 1,8 % 8,6 % HS6 250840 2 874 548 16 020 6 661 046 8 773 721 37 745 100 12 245 0,6 % 0,0 % HS6 251010 1 310 945 933 0 6 304 578 086 691 1 0,0 % 0,0 % HS6 252020 115 687 408 262 590 2 467 564 269 126 6 009 528 279 780 0,2 % 4,7 % HS6 252910 1 685 879 0 38 178 349 633 002 42 969 410 606 0,0 % 0,0 % HS6 253090 10 073 661 1 113 725 6 953 917 51 919 252 39 815 431 5 204 569 11,1 % 13,1 % HS6 2817 12 978 710 21 349 7 107 747 1 854 908 2 171 753 40 501 0,2 % 1,9 % HS6 283990 792 579 1 202 836 2 226 616 1 690 047 2 035 626 249 824 151,8 % 12,3 % HS6 320710 1 866 880 2 991 261 5 937 003 1 939 579 20 878 965 1 670 139 160,2 % 8,0 % HS6 320720 3 806 035 186 814 1 157 317 1 207 973 6 987 437 505 222 4,9 % 7,2 % HS6 320740 14 727 116 91 346 8 220 802 809 321 17 036 899 41 459 0,6 % 0,2 % HS6 490810 7 618 063 24 376 8 785 294 3 764 630 34 399 981 343 159 0,3 % 1,0 % HS6 691110 6 329 43 714 10 657 302 096 923 82 690,7 % 8,9 % HS6 320619 4 274 417 259 859 419 855 2 323 835 3 606 543 29 615 341 6,1 % 821,2 % HS6 760310 471 296 105 000 195 286 33 202 1 362 822 18 519 22,3 % 1,4 % Overall share of imports from China 0,55 % 37,33 % 2,26 %
recital 97recital 97
(97) The producer identified in Türkiye has its recent audited financial reports publicly available, while this is not the case of the companies identified in Brazil and in Thailand. The financial reports, though not a pre-requisite for this type of analysis, still constitute an advantage, as they enable the Commission to ascertain that the most appropriate figures are used and that the effects of eventual extraordinary events are excluded.
recital 98recital 98
(98) Türkiye has detailed, publicly available information on labour costs in the country as well as details on hours worked in the relevant sector (non-metallic mineral sector including ceramic, glass, cement, and lime production). The data in Türkiye includes social security payments and other labour cost expenses payable by companies. Labour costs are an important factor in the case at hand as they represent on average 45 %–55 % of the total cost of production.
recital 99recital 99
(99) On initiation, the CCCLA argued that the selection of Türkiye as an appropriate representative country in the present case would lead to artificially inflated dumping margins. The CCCLA notes that energy prices increased significantly in Türkiye during 2023, to an extent that they did not in China, which would prove that energy costs, being among the main cost drivers, were subject to major economic shocks. This claim was reiterated during a hearing at a later stage.
recital 100recital 100
(100) The Commission would like to point out that while energy is indeed an important input in the manufacture of ceramic tableware, it is by far, not the main cost driver, that being labour. Additionally, the CCCLA provided supporting data on electricity prices to sustain its claim, however, electricity makes up a minor part of the energy mix employed in the manufacture of the product under investigation which, due to the insufficient cooperation by exporting producers from the PRC, had to be based on facts available. In fact, energy costs are driven by natural gas prices, which increased significantly in 2022, but were already decreasing at the start of the RIP ( 44 ) .
recital 101recital 101
(101) Regarding the argument that energy prices should be considered as distorted because China did not suffer similar increases, and that for that reason, Türkiye does not fulfil the condition of appropriateness to be selected as the representative country, the Commission notes that in view of the established existence of significant distortions in China within the meaning of Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation, the evolution of prices in China is not relevant for the assessment of distortions in potential representative countries. Therefore, the comment was rejected.
recital 102recital 102
(102) Based on the combined effect of all these factors the Commission considered Türkiye to be the most appropriate representative country for this investigation. In the Note of 6 June, the Commission informed the interested parties of its intention to use Türkiye as representative country and invited them to comment thereon.
recital 103recital 103
(103) The applicants welcomed the choice of representative country, noting that out of the three possible representative countries, Türkiye imported the largest quantities of the main raw materials needed to manufacture the product concerned, while having a minimal share of imports from China. The applicants added that, of all three possible representative countries, Türkiye had the most complete set of information concerning labour, as well as readily available audited financial statements.
recital 104recital 104
3.5.4. Level of social and environmental protection
(104) Having established that Türkiye was the only available appropriate representative country, based on all of the above elements, there was no need to carry out an assessment of the level of social and environmental protection in accordance with the last sentence of Article 2(6a)(a) first indent of the basic Regulation.
recital 105recital 105
3.5.5. Conclusion on representative country
(105) In view of the above analysis, and the data available on the file, the Commission used the data of and the Turkish company Kutahya Porselen Sanayii A.S. for establishing corresponding costs of production and sale in an appropriate representative country in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 106recital 106
3.6. Sources used to establish undistorted costs
(106) In the First Note, the Commission listed the factors of production such as materials, energy and labour used in the production of the product under review by the exporting producers and invited the interested parties to comment and propose publicly available information on undistorted values for each of the factors of production mentioned in that note.
recital 107recital 107
(107) Subsequently, in the Second Note, the Commission stated that, in order to construct the normal value in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation, it would use GTA to establish the undistorted cost of most of the factors of production, notably the raw materials. In addition, the Commission stated that it would use the information provided by the Turkish Statistical Institute (‘Turkstat’) ( 45 ) on labour and the information published by the Energy Market Regulatory Authority of Türkiye ( 46 ) for establishing undistorted costs of labour and energy. The Commission also informed interested parties that it would use the financial data of the Turkish company Kutahya Porselen Sanayii A.S for SG & A costs and profit as available in its audited accounts made public in their own website.
recital 108recital 108
(108) Considering all the information based on the previous expiry review investigation, the following factors of production and their sources have been identified in order to determine the normal value in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation: Table 2 Factors of production for ceramic tableware and kitchenware Factor of production Turkish Classification Code Source of data Unit of measurement Unit cost Raw materials Silica sands and quartz sands, natural 2505 10 Global Trade Atlas ( 47 ) (‘GTA’) KG 0,40 CNY/KG Kaolin (and other kaolinic clays) 250700200011, 250700200018, 250700800011, 250700800012 GTA KG 1,74 CNY/KG Bentonite, whether or not calcined 250810000011, 250810000012 GTA KG 2,35 CNY/KG Ball Clay (clay) 2508 40 GTA KG 1,33 CNY/KG Natural calcium phosphates, natural aluminium calcium phosphates and phosphatic chalk: Unground 251010009011, 251010009012 GTA KG 0,99 CNY/KG Gypsum Materials for Molds 2520 20 00 10, 252020009019 GTA KG 4,66 CNY/KG Feldspar 252910000011, 252910000012, 252910000019 GTA KG 1,05 CNY/KG Mineral substances, not elsewhere specified or included 2530 90 30 , 2530 90 40 , 2530 90 50 , 2530 90 70 GTA KG 14,37 CNY/KG Zinc oxide; zinc peroxide 2817 00 00 10, 2817 00 00 90 GTA KG 22,01 CNY/KG Silicates; commercial alkali metal silicates, Not of Sodium 2839 90 00 10, 2839 90 00 20, 283990009012, 283990009013, 283990009015 GTA KG 9,12 CNY/KG Pigments and preparations based on titanium dioxide 3206 19 GTA KG 23,51 CNY/KG Prepared pigments, prepared opacifiers, prepared colours and similar preparations 3207 10 GTA KG 49,83 CNY/KG Glaze Materials 3207 20 10 , 320720900011, 320720900019 GTA KG 12,18 CNY/KG Glass frit and other glass, in the form of powder, granules or flakes 3207 40 40 , 3207 40 85 GTA KG 9,54 CNY/KG Flower paper 4908 10 GTA KG 505,88 CNY/KG Ceramic Tableware and Kitchenware, Of Porcelain or China 691110000011, 691110000012, 691110000019 GTA KG 38,30 CNY/KG Aluminium powders of non-lamellar structure 7603 10 GTA KG 28,9 CNY/KG Energy Electricity N/A Energy Market Regulatory Authority of Türkiye ( 48 ) KwH 0,93 CNY/KwH Natural Gas N/A Energy Market Regulatory Authority of Türkiye ( 49 ) m 3 3,40 CNY/m 3 Labour Labour costs in manufacturing sector N/A Turkish Statistical Institute ( 50 ) hour 59,96 CNY/hour Other Water N/A Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye Investment Office ( 51 ) m 3 1,63 CNY/m 3
recital 109recital 109
3.6.1. Raw materials
(109) In order to establish the undistorted price of raw materials as delivered at the gate of a representative country producer, the Commission used as a basis the weighted average import price to the representative country as reported in the GTA. To establish the undistorted price of raw materials as delivered at the gate of a representative country producer, the Commission would have normally added the import duty of the representative country to the import price and an estimation of transport costs. In this case, however, given that the dumping margins, as explained in recital (145) below were already so high as to confirm the existence of dumping during the review investigation period, an increase of the dumping margin as a result of this adjustment is therefore not relevant for the outcome of this review
recital 110recital 110
(110) The import price in the representative country was determined as a weighted average of unit prices of imports from all third countries excluding the PRC and countries which are not members of the WTO, listed in Annex 1 of Regulation (EU) 2015/755 of the European Parliament and the Council ( 52 ) . The Commission decided to exclude imports from the PRC into the representative country as it concluded in Section 3.4 above that it is not appropriate to use domestic prices and costs in the PRC due to the existence of significant distortions in accordance with Article 2(6a)(b) of the basic Regulation. Given that there is no evidence showing that the same distortions do not equally affect products intended for export, the Commission considered that the same distortions affected export prices. After excluding imports from the PRC into the representative country, the volume of imports from other third countries remained representative.
recital 111recital 111
3.6.2. Labour
(111) The Turkish Statistical Institute publishes detailed information on wages in different economic sectors in Türkiye. The Commission used the wages reported in the manufacturing sector for 2022, for the economic activity C.23 (Manufacture of other non-metallic mineral products) ( 53 ) according to NACE Rev.2 classification ( 54 ) which are the most recent statistics available. The values have been properly adjusted for inflation using the producer price index published by the Turkish statistical institute ( 55 ) . The average hourly labour cost per FTE ( 56 ) amounted to 59,96 CNY per hour ( 57 ) .
recital 112recital 112
3.6.3. Electricity
(112) The Commission intends used the electricity price statistics published by the Turkish Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA) ( 58 ) in its regular press releases covering tariff tables based on electricity bills, which are published quarterly or bi-annually ( 59 ) . The Commission used the data of the industrial electricity prices in Kuruş/kWh for the industrial sector for 2023 covering the review investigation period, i.e. 0,93 CNY/KWh.
recital 113recital 113
3.6.4. Natural gas
(113) The Commission used the price of gas for industrial users in Türkiye as published by the Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA) ( 60 ) in its 2023 Natural Gas Market Sector Report ( 61 ) . The Commission intends to use the data of the industrial gas prices in the corresponding consumption band in TRY/Sm 3 covering the review investigation period. The applicable unit cost is estimated to amount to 3,40 CNY per sm 3 ( 62 ) .
recital 114recital 114
(114) In the comments to the note of 6 June, the applicants noted that the link to the source provided for gas prices wasn’t functional. The Commission has updated the link, which can now be accessed.
recital 115recital 115
3.6.5. Water
(115) The Commission intends to use applicable prices for water for industrial use published by the Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye Investment Office based on sources from the Istanbul water and Sewerage administration, the Eskișehir Water and Sewerage Administration and the Antalya Water and Sewerage Administration ( 63 ) . The Commission intends to use the data of Eskisehir region since the Turkish company used for SG & A costs and profit is located in this region. The applicable unit cost is estimated to amount to 1,63 CNY/m 3 ( 64 ) .
recital 116recital 116
3.7. Manufacturing overhead costs, SG & A costs and profits
(116) According to Article 2(6a)(a), second paragraph of the basic Regulation, ‘the constructed normal value shall include an undistorted and reasonable amount for administrative, selling and general costs and for profits’. In addition, a value for manufacturing overhead costs needs to be established to cover costs not included in the factors of production referred to above..
recital 117recital 117
(117) The level of manufacturing overheads was adjusted to the benchmarks calculated above from the information used in the previous expiry review investigation.
recital 118recital 118
(118) In order to establish an undistorted value, for SG & A costs and profit, the Commission used the financial data from the Turkish company Kutahya Porselen Sanayi A.S. More precisely, the Commission used the SG & A costs and profit figures as reported in the company’s audited accounts for the year 2023. Based on available company information the majority of the business activity concerned the product concerned. Financial statements were adjusted by the company according to the standards set by the International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) requiring Turkish companies to apply inflation adjustments to their financial statements. The percentage of SG & A costs and profits was corrected to an ex-works level by deducting the packaging costs and transportation cost from the total SG & A costs and from the turnover.
recital 119recital 119
3.8. Calculation of the normal value
(119) On the basis of the above the Commission constructed the normal value on an ex-works basis in accordance with Article 2(6a)(a) of the basic Regulation.
recital 120recital 120
(120) In order to establish the constructed normal value, the Commission followed the following two steps. First, the Commission established the undistorted manufacturing costs. To this end, and due to the insufficient level of cooperation, the Commission multiplied the usage factors as observed in the previous expiry review for materials, labour, electricity and water by the undistorted costs per unit observed in the representative country Türkiye.
recital 121recital 121
(121) Second, to the manufacturing costs identified above the Commission applied, the aforementioned overheads margin, and Kutahya Porselen Sanayi A.S.’s SG & A costs and profit.
recital 122recital 122
(122) As a result, the following items were added to the undistorted cost of manufacturing: (a) Overheard consumption level of 15,65 % expressed on the cost of manufacturing and added to the sum of the costs of manufacturing; (b) SG & A costs of 35,97 % expressed on the cost of goods sold applied to the sum of costs of manufacturing; (c) A profit of 17,74 % expressed on the cost of goods sold applied to the costs of manufacturing.
recital 123recital 123
3.9. Export price
(123) In the absence of sufficient cooperation, the Commission calculated the export price on the basis of import statistics available in Eurostat adjusted to ex-works level so as to represent the price actually paid or payable for the product concerned when sold for export to the Union, in accordance with Article 2(8) of the basic Regulation. Thus, the CIF price was reduced by the (sea) freight and insurance cost and domestic transport cost as estimated in the expiry review request.
recital 124recital 124
(124) At initiation, CCCLA argued that, due to the complexity and wide variety of product types included under the definition of the product concerned, and that are blended in official trade statistics, the prices reported in the official trade statistics does not constitute an adequate assumption of what the dumping margin might be.
recital 125recital 125
(125) The Commission reminded CCCLA that the insufficient cooperation received from exporting producers of the product under investigation in the PRC didn’t allow for any differentiation by PCN on the construction of the Normal Value. Accordingly, the Commission had no alternative than to calculate the dumping margin as a comparison of averages, for which the level of specification of the official trade statistics employed was perfectly reasonable. Therefore, this claim was rejected.
recital 126recital 126
(126) After disclosure, CCCLA argued that prices reported in trade statistics tools (e.g., Eurostat) do not differentiate by PCN and, therefore, prices reported do ‘not constitute an adequate assumption of what the dumping margin might be’.
recital 127recital 127
(127) Ceramie-Unie pointed out that the Commission relied on this method only due to the insufficient cooperation from Chinese exporting producers. The Commission contacted one hundred and one (101) Chinese exporting producers/groups of exporting producers of which only one provided a complete questionnaire reply.
recital 128recital 128
(128) This single exporting producer amounted to approximately [1-2 %] of the total volume of imports of the product concerned into the Union during the RIP.
recital 129recital 129
(129) As rightly determined by the Commission, such a low level of imports could not be considered representative of the total imports from China.
recital 130recital 130
(130) Ceramie-Unie pointed out that Article 18(6) of the basic Regulation is unambiguous: in cases of non-cooperation ‘the result of the investigation may be less favourable to the party’. Therefore, the Commission’s calculation of the dumping margin as a comparison of averages is perfectly reasonable and within the boundaries of the Union law, given the circumstances of the case.
recital 131recital 131
(131) In conducting this analysis, Ceramie-Unie highlights the Commission’s findings that the dumping margin during the RIP was found to be ‘more than 100 %’. The Commission further noted that such dumping margin was ‘significantly undervalued, as the normal value was not adjusted for transportation and custom duties on the import price of raw materials (see recital (106)) and the export price was not adjusted for VAT refunds (see recital (125))’.
recital 132recital 132
(132) In light of the above, Ceramie-Unie stressed that the data demonstrating the continuation of dumping during the RIP is supporting the need to extend the continuation of the anti-dumping measures.
recital 133recital 133
(133) Upon disclosure, CCCLA insisted on its claim that prices reported in trade statistics tools (e.g. Eurostat) do not differentiate by PCN and, therefore, prices reported do ‘not constitute an adequate assumption of what the dumping margin might be’. Because no new information or evidence was brought forward to support the claim, the Commission refers all parties to its previous assessment of the issue stated also in recital (125).
recital 134recital 134
3.10. Comparison
(134) Article 2(10) of the basic Regulation requires the Commission to make a fair comparison between the normal value and the export price at the same level of trade and to make allowances for differences in factors which affect prices and price comparability. In the case at hand the Commission chose to compare the normal value and the export price of the sampled exporting producers at the ex-works level of trade. As further explained below, where appropriate, the normal value and the export price were adjusted in order to: (i) net them back to the ex-works level; and (ii) make allowances for differences in factors which were claimed, and demonstrated, to affect prices and price comparability.
recital 135recital 135
3.11. Adjustments made to the normal value
(135) As explained in recitals (119) to (122), the normal value was established at the ex-works level of trade by using costs of production together with amounts for SG & A costs and profit, which were considered to be reasonable for that level of trade.
recital 136recital 136
(136) The question whether to adjust the normal value for VAT refunds on exports was not assessed, since, as it will be demonstrated in the following section, the dumping margins already established during the review investigation period are high enough (more than 100 %) to confirm the likely continuation of dumping. An increase of the dumping margin as a result of the VAT adjustment is therefore not relevant for the outcome of this review, as it would not contradict that conclusion.
recital 137recital 137
3.12. Adjustments made to the export price
(137) As explained in recital (123), in order to net the export price back to the ex-works level of trade, adjustments were made on the account of: the (sea) freight and insurance cost and domestic transport cost as estimated in the expiry review request.
recital 138recital 138
3.13. Dumping margin
(138) On this basis, the weighted average dumping margins expressed as a percentage of the CIF Union frontier price, duty unpaid, was above 100 %. It must be noted that the dumping margin obtained was significantly undervalued, as the normal value was not adjusted for transportation and custom duties on the import price of raw materials (see recital (109)) and the export price was not adjusted for VAT refunds (see recital (136)).
recital 139recital 139
(139) It was therefore concluded that dumping continued during the review investigation period.
recital 140recital 140
(140) Upon disclosure, CCCLA manifested surprise at the level of dumping found, and claimed that it was the result of inflated benchmark prices, and exaggerated SG & A cost and profit ratios, deeming the choice of Kütahya Porselen inappropriate. To this effect, CCCLA compared the prices of raw materials in the previous expiry review and in the current investigation, noting a generalized increase. CCCLA alluded to the cost of labour being one of the principal cost drivers of the production of ceramic tableware and kitchenware and suggested that the increase of labour costs between the previous expiry review and the current investigation does not reflect the actual labour cost increase in China.
recital 141recital 141
(141) The Commission noted that, as presented in Annex II to the FOP Note of 6 June, import prices into Türkiye were in line with the prices of imports into Brazil and Thailand. Additionally, the Commission pointed out that not all factors of production have the same weight in the cost structure of the PUI. In this regard, the use of Gypsum Materials for moulds, mentioned by CCCLA for having increased its price by 37 times, is minimal and had virtually no impact on the calculation. Moreover, the main raw material used in the production of the PUI is kaolin, for which, again, the benchmark price used is consistent to that of Brazil and Thailand.
recital 142recital 142
(142) Regarding the level of SG & A costs and profit used in the construction of the normal value, the Commission noted that the SG & A costs and profit reported in Kütahya Porselen’s audited reports are in line with the levels of the wider sector (NACE C-234) reported by the Turkish government.
recital 143recital 143
(143) Finally, regarding the claim that labour cost increases are not representative of the situation in China, the Commission noted that according to the available sources, labour costs in Turkey went up as a result of recent increases of the minimal wage by the Turkish government, which aimed to restore Turkish citizens’ purchasing power. This means that the Turkish government aimed to restore labour costs to the level that would be commensurate with the level of the overall economic development in the country, a level similar to the one of China. In view of this, there is no reason to consider that the increase in labour costs was exaggerated. Moreover, the development of labour costs in China, which were found to be affected by significant distortions found in this investigation is irrelevant.
recital 144recital 144
(144) Furthermore, in the first note on Factors of production, the Commission invited all parties to suggest other appropriate representative countries, but no suggestions were brought forward by CCCLA. Based on the above, the Commission dismissed CCCLA’s claims.
recital 145recital 145
3.14. Likelihood of continuation or recurrence of dumping from the PRC
(145) Further to the finding of the existence of dumping during the review investigation period, the Commission investigated the likelihood of continuation of dumping, should the measures be repealed. Accordingly, the Commission analysed the following additional elements: the production capacity and spare capacity in the PRC, pricing behaviour of Chinese exporting producers in other markets, and the attractiveness of the Union market.
recital 146recital 146
3.14.1. Production capacity and spare capacity in the PRC
(146) China is the world’s largest exporter of ceramic tableware and kitchenware and has thousands of active producers ( 65 ) . In the annexes of the expiry review request, the applicants brought forward sources indicating that China had a daily production capacity of 87,03 billion pieces of daily ceramics during the RIP, with a spare capacity of 18,7 % ( 66 ) . Production capacity of daily ceramics has increased steadily since the last review, while maintaining a stable capacity utilization level of around 81 %. This has allowed spare capacity to increase from 12,9 billion pieces in 2019 to over 16 billion pieces during the RIP. Spare production capacity of such magnitude means that China alone could cover multiple times the total Union consumption, that was estimated at roughly 491 264 tonnes during the review investigation period (see recital (161) below). The problem of overcapacity was acknowledged in the financial reports of some of the big Chinese producers ( 67 ) , as well as in several pieces of market intelligence ( 68 ) ( 69 ) .
recital 147recital 147
(147) Since the imposition of the measures, exports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from China have entered the Union in big quantities and were still representing almost 60 % of the Union consumption in the RIP as it is explained more in detail in Section 4.3.1 below. This also indicates that Chinese exporting producers of ceramic tableware and kitchenware have strong business relations with their clients in the Union.
recital 148recital 148
(148) Based on the above, the Commission concluded that China was among the biggest producers of ceramic tableware and kitchenware in the world and had significant spare capacity which, facilitated by the strong business relationships, could be easily exported at even higher volumes to the Union should measures be repealed.
recital 149recital 149
3.14.2. Exports to third countries
(149) According to GTA, China ( 70 ) exported 2 094 958 tonnes amounting to 53 393 909 510 RMB or an average CIF value of 25,48 RMB/kg.
recital 150recital 150
(150) The Commission compared the average export prices at CIF level of the main export markets of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from China, as reported in the GTA database with the export price to the Union at the same level of trade. It found that, Chinese export prices to their main export markets (US, Russia) are similar or lower than those to the EU, reinforcing the attractiveness of the Union market for Chinese exporters of the product concerned.
recital 151recital 151
3.14.3. Attractiveness of the Union market
(151) The Union is one of the biggest markets of ceramic tableware and kitchenware in the world. As already mentioned in recital (147) above, following the imposition of the anti-dumping measures in 2012, Chinese exports of the product concerned continued to enter the Union in significant quantities. During the review investigation period, Chinese exports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware to the Union represented almost 60 % of the Union consumption (see recital (181)). This clearly demonstrates that the Union remained an attractive and important market destination for Chinese ceramic tableware and kitchenware.
recital 152recital 152
(152) Additionally, the market intelligence brought up by the applicants, as well as company reports, claim that the growth domestic market of daily use ceramics is slowing down. As production capacity and daily output continue to grow, companies will face higher pressure to increase their export volumes, and the Union’s market attractiveness will increase.
recital 153recital 153
(153) Finally, trade defence measures concerning Chinese ceramic tableware and kitchenware imports are in place in other third countries, illustrating the same type of pricing behaviour as observed in the Union ( 71 ) . These trade defence measures will make it more difficult for Chinese exporting producers to export to these markets and further increase the attractiveness of the Union market where these exports may be redirected.
recital 154recital 154
3.14.4. Price behaviour of Chinese exporting producers
(154) Another element demonstrating the attractiveness of the Union market is the pricing strategy of Chinese exporting producers. Export prices of Chinese exporting producers of the product concerned are significantly below the prices of the Union industry on the Union market. In fact, Chinese imports have the lowest prices on the Union market. The few third countries which export at lower prices account for only a fraction of the total imports into the Union, with a growth potential which is not comparable with the size of the production facilities in the PRC. Therefore, it can be reasonably expected that the Chinese imports will enter the Union market at lower prices should the measures be allowed to lapse, even taking into account the amount of current anti-dumping duties.
recital 155recital 155
(155) Indeed, during the period considered, the average import price from China increased by 17 %. Despite this increase, it still remains below Union industry average sales price by 18 %. Without the anti-dumping duties, the difference would amount to 38 % (see recital (169)).
recital 156recital 156
3.15. Conclusion on the likelihood of continuation or recurrence of dumping
(156) Chinese imports of the product concerned continued to enter the Union market at dumped prices during the review investigation period. The Commission also found that the PRC was the biggest producer and exporter of ceramic tableware and kitchenware in the world and had significant spare capacities.
recital 157recital 157
(157) In addition, the Commission found that the pricing behaviour of the Chinese exporting producers in third markets supports the finding of a likelihood of continuation or recurrence of dumping to the Union, should the measures be allowed to lapse.
recital 158recital 158
(158) Finally, the Commission established that the Union market remained an attractive market for Chinese exporting producers of ceramic tableware and kitchenware even after the impositions of measures.
recital 159recital 159
(159) Given the above, the Commission concluded that there was a strong likelihood that the repeal of the anti-dumping measures would result in increased imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from the PRC into the Union at dumped prices.
recital 160recital 160
4.INJURY
4.1. Union production and Union industry
(160) During the review investigation period, the like product was manufactured in the Union by more than 140 known producers. Production is concentrated in the Czech Republic, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Portugal and Romania. The total Union production was established at 226 147 tonnes during the RIP on the basis of verified questionnaire responses submitted by the sampled Union producers and Cerame-Unie/FEPF. The Union producers accounting for the total Union production constitute the Union industry within the meaning of Articles 4(1) and 5(4) of the basic Regulation.
recital 161recital 161
4.2. Union consumption
(161) The Union consumption was established on the basis of Eurostat import statistics and sales volumes of the Union industry in the Union, as submitted by Cerame-Unie/FEPF and information from sampled Union producers, which was duly verified.
recital 162recital 162
(162) During the period considered the Union consumption developed as follows: Table 3 2020 2021 2022 RIP Union consumption (tonnes) 399 085 459 741 555 832 491 264 Index (2020 = 100) 100 115 139 123 Source: Eurostat, Cerame-Unie/FEPF verified questionnaire reply.
recital 163recital 163
(163) During the period considered, Union consumption increased by 23 %, due to the ongoing post-COVID effect of renewed interest among European consumers in ceramic tableware and kitchenware. It increased steadily from 2020 to 2022, where it reached a peak of 555 832 tonnes, but dropping to 491 264 tonnes in the RIP.
recital 164recital 164
4.3. Imports into the Union from the PRC
4.3.1. Volume and market share
(164) Based on Eurostat data and macro data provided by Cerame-Unie/FEPF, the volume of imports, market share and average prices of imports of the product concerned developed as set out below: Table 4 Imports from the PRC 2020 2021 2022 RIP Volume of imports (tonnes) 226 033 270 662 318 598 285 513 Index (2020 = 100) 100 120 141 126 Market share (%) 56,6 58,9 57,3 58,1 Source: Eurostat, Cerame-Unie/FEPF verified questionnaire reply.
recital 165recital 165
(165) While the anti-dumping measures were in place, the total volume of imports from the PRC rose by 26 % during the period considered. It followed the increasing Union consumption steadily up to 2022, decreasing to 285 513 tonnes during the RIP. In the context of a growing market, the share of Chinese imports in total Union consumption (see Table 3) increased at the expense of the Union industry, reaching 58,1 % during the RIP.
recital 166recital 166
4.3.2. Price of the imports from the country concerned and price undercutting
(166) Over the period considered the price of imports from the PRC into the Union developed as follows: Table 5 Imports from the PRC 2020 2021 2022 RIP Average import price (EUR/tonne) 1 871 2 155 2 668 2 188 Index (2020 = 100) 100 115 143 117 Source: Eurostat.
recital 167recital 167
(167) Over the period considered the prices of Chinese imports increased by 17 %, from 1 871/tonne to 2 188 EUR/tonne. This is the average import price per tonne of all imports of the product concerned and therefore, the trend could be affected by further imports.
recital 168recital 168
(168) The Commission determined the price undercutting during the review investigation period by comparing: (i) the weighted average sales prices of the sampled Union producers charged to unrelated customers on the Union market, adjusted to an ex-works level. These prices were weighted in accordance with the share of the relevant segment they related to (i.e. large companies and SMEs, see recital (178)); and (ii) the import price (CIF Union frontier) from Eurostat data. The CIF prices were then adjusted upwards for the post-importation costs, i.e. customs clearance, handling and loading costs, based on the information of the previous expiry review investigation, conventional customs duties and anti-dumping duties.
recital 169recital 169
(169) The result of the comparison was expressed as a percentage of the sampled Union producers’ turnover during the review investigation period. On the basis of the above methodology, the comparison showed that during the review investigation period the imports of the product concerned undercut the Union industry’s prices by 18 %. Without the anti-dumping duties, the undercutting would have amounted to 38 %.
recital 170recital 170
(170) In its comments on anonymous treatment of certain sampled and non-sampled Union producers by the Commission (see recital (51)), CCCLA also claimed that Chinese producers sell only generic products while Union producers sell high end and branded products. Therefore, comparing potentially branded products produced in the EU with generic products produced in China would inevitably lead to an inflated undercutting calculation.
recital 171recital 171
(171) However, the investigation showed that virtually no branded products were sold by the sampled Union producers, representing a significant proportion of the Union sales volume in the period considered. If there was any impact on the undercutting calculation, it would be very limited. Consequently, this claim was rejected.
recital 172recital 172
4.4. Imports from third countries other than the PRC
(172) The aggregated volume of imports into the Union, as well as the market share and price trends for imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from other third countries other than the PRC developed as follows: Table 6 Country 2020 2021 2022 RIP Türkiye Volume (tonnes) 17 177 22 139 33 228 21 546 Index (2020 = 100) 100 129 193 125 Market share (%) 4,3 4,8 6,0 4,4 Index (2020 = 100) 100 112 139 102 Average price (EUR/tonne) 2 095 2 250 2 798 3 465 Index (2020 = 100) 100 107 134 165 Thailand Volume (tonnes) 10 500 11 184 15 190 12 626 Index (2020 = 100) 100 107 145 120 Market share (%) 2,6 2,4 2,7 2,6 Index (2020 = 100) 100 92 104 98 Average price (EUR/tonne) 5 152 5 209 5 986 5 639 Index (2020 = 100) 100 101 116 109 United Kingdom Volume (tonnes) 9 705 4 082 6 695 7 074 Index (2020 = 100) 100 42 69 73 Market share (%) 2,4 0,9 1,2 1,4 Index (2020 = 100) 100 37 50 59 Average price (EUR/tonne) 5 823 8 263 8 225 8 499 Index (2020 = 100) 100 142 141 146 Bangladesh Volume (tonnes) 3 776 4 931 5 875 6 433 Index (2020 = 100) 100 131 156 170 Market share (%) 0,9 1,1 1,1 1,3 Index (2020 = 100) 100 113 112 138 Average price (EUR/tonne) 3 384 3 999 4 444 3 751 Index (2020 = 100) 100 118 131 111 United Arab Emirates Volume (tonnes) 471 652 5 286 6 532 Index (2020 = 100) 100 138 1 122 1 387 Market share (%) 0,1 0,1 1,0 1,3 Index (2020 = 100) 100 120 806 1 126 Average price (EUR/tonne) 2 687 2 996 3 375 3 606 Index (2020 = 100) 100 111 126 134 Others Volume (tonnes) 12 824 15 969 20 085 15 590 Index (2020 = 100) 100 125 157 122 Market share (%) 3,2 3,5 3,6 3,2 Index (2020 = 100) 100 108 112 99 Average price (EUR/tonne) 3 874 4 168 4 640 4 675 Index (2020 = 100) 100 108 120 121 Totals Volume (tonnes) 54 454 58 958 86 359 69 802 Index (2020 = 100) 100 108 159 128 Market share (%) 13,6 12,8 15,5 14,2 Index (2020 = 100) 100 94 114 104 Average price (EUR/tonne) 3 733 4 094 4 389 4 223 Index (2020 = 100) 100 110 118 113 Source: Eurostat.
recital 173recital 173
(173) In the RIP, 69 802 tonnes of ceramic tableware and kitchenware were imported from third countries excluding China. The main exporters of the product concerned into the Union were Türkiye and Thailand, representing 4,4 % and 2,6 % in the RIP, respectively. The total import volume from third countries represented however only 14,2 % of the Union market, which was a slight increase from 13,6 % at the beginning of the considered period. Consequently, it can be concluded that China was by far the largest exporter of the product under review to the EU during the period considered, representing more than four times the total import volume of all other third countries taken together in the RIP.
recital 174recital 174
(174) The average import prices of other third countries were consistently and significantly above the Chinese average import price during the period considered.
recital 175recital 175
4.5. Economic situation of the Union industry
(175) Pursuant to Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation, the examination of the impact of the dumped imports on the Union industry included an evaluation of all economic factors and indices having a bearing on the state of the Union industry during the period considered.
recital 176recital 176
(176) The macroeconomic indicators (production, production capacity, capacity utilisation, sales volume, market share, employment, productivity, magnitude of dumping margins and recovery from the effects of past dumping) were assessed at the level of the whole Union industry. The assessment was based on the verified information provided by Cerame-Unie/FEPF, the verified questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers and import statistics.
recital 177recital 177
(177) The analysis of microeconomic indicators (stocks, sale prices, profitability, cash flow, investments, return on investments, ability to raise capital, wages and cost of production) was carried out at the level of the sampled Union producers. The assessment was based on their information which was duly verified during on-spot verification visits.
recital 178recital 178
(178) The Union industry is highly fragmented and can largely be divided into two segments: SMEs and larger companies. For some microeconomic indicators (sales price, cash flow, investments, average wage per employee, stocks, profitability and cost of production) the results of the sampled companies have been weighted in accordance with the share of the segment to which that specific company belonged. As in the original investigation and the last expiry review investigation, for this purpose the specific weight in terms of production volumes of each segment in the total ceramic tableware and kitchenware sector were used (42 % SMEs, 58 % large companies). This ensured that the situation of the smaller companies was properly reflected to prevent an imbalance in the overall injury analysis due to the results of large companies.
recital 179recital 179
4.5.1. Macroeconomic indicators
4.5.1.1. Production, production capacity and capacity utilisation
(179) Over the period considered, the production, the production capacity and the capacity utilisation of the Union industry developed as follows: Table 7 2020 2021 2022 RIP Production volume (tonnes) 199 487 228 747 245 278 226 147 Index (2020 = 100) 100 115 123 113 Production capacity (tonnes) 307 470 320 896 327 575 330 260 Index (2020 = 100) 100 104 107 107 Capacity utilisation (%) 73 82 76 68 Index (2020 = 100) 100 112 104 93 Source: Cerame-Unie/FEPF verified questionnaire reply.
recital 180recital 180
(180) It follows that, in line with the growing Union consumption during the period considered, there was an increase in production volume (by 13 %). As for consumption, it peaked in 2022 and decreased in the RIP. As a result from efficiency gains due to investments in production equipment (see recital (193)), production capacity rose by 7 %. However, despite a growing market, due to the high volumes of Chinese imports, capacity utilisation decreased over the period considered, from 73 % to 68 %.
recital 181recital 181
4.5.1.2. Sales volume and market share in the Union
(181) Over the period considered sales in the Union by the Union industry developed as follows: Table 8 2020 2021 2022 RIP Sales volume (tonnes) 118 599 130 121 150 875 135 950 Index (2020 = 100) 100 110 127 115 Market share (of Union consumption) (%) 29,7 28,3 27,1 27,7 Source: Cerame-Unie/FEPF verified questionnaire reply.
recital 182recital 182
(182) The sales by the Union industry on the Union market followed the development in consumption and increased in 2021 and 2022, when they reached a peak of 150 875 tonnes. As for consumption, sales volumes decreased again during the RIP. Overall, they increased by only 15 % during the period considered. However, at the same time, the market share of the Union industry decreased from 29,7 % to 27,7 %, as the Union industry could not benefit from the growing Union market and lost sales to the advantage of Chinese dumped imports.
recital 183recital 183
4.5.1.3. Employment and productivity
(183) Over the period considered the employment level and productivity within the Union industry developed as follows: Table 9 2020 2021 2022 RIP Number of employees (full-time equivalent) 19 496 19 907 21 685 22 007 Index (2020 = 100) 100 102 111 113 Productivity (tonnes per employee) 102 11,5 11,3 10,3 Index (2020 = 100) 100 112 111 100 Source: Cerame-Unie/FEPF verified questionnaire reply.
recital 184recital 184
(184) In line with the increasing Union industry production, the employment rose throughout the period considered by 13 %. Productivity of the Union producers’ workforce, measured as output (tonnes) per person employed per year, remained stable during the period considered.
recital 185recital 185
4.5.1.4. Growth
(185) During the period considered, the production of the Union industry increased by 13 % while the volume of sales in the Union increased by 15 % in response to the growing Union consumption. With a Union consumption growing by 23 %, the Union industry was not able to benefit from it due to the dumped Chinese imports, and hence unable to fully utilise the increases in production capacity of its production facilities achieved through efficiency gains resulting from investments.
recital 186recital 186
4.5.1.5. Magnitude of dumping
(186) Dumping continued during the review investigation period at a significant level, as explained under Section 3 above. It is noted that Chinese producers undercut Union industry’s sales prices to a significant extent.
recital 187recital 187
(187) During the period considered, the Union industry could not take full advantage of increase in Union consumption, which was not followed by the same extent by production and sales of the Union industry. Moreover, despite rising production and sales, Union producers’ market shares even decreased in the period considered. By contrast, the volume of imports from the PRC grew at a stronger rate than Union consumption, allowing for increasing market shares in the same period. The Commission, therefore, concluded that the Union industry has in fact been unable to gain, in the presence of Chinese imports, more economic space in a growing Union market.
recital 188recital 188
4.5.2. Microeconomic indicators
4.5.2.1. Average unit sales prices in the Union and cost of production
(188) Over the period considered, average unit sales prices to unrelated customers in the Union and average unit cost of production of the sampled Union producers developed as follows: Table 10 2020 2021 2022 RIP Average unit sales price to unrelated parties (EUR/tonne) 3 154 3 257 3 812 3 925 Index (2020 = 100) 100 103 121 124 Unit cost of production (EUR/tonne) 3 587 3 514 4 482 4 149 Index (2020 = 100) 100 98 125 116 Source: Verified questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers.
recital 189recital 189
(189) Over the period considered, Union industry prices were overall constant in 2020 and 2021. They increased as of 2022, following the increasing cost of production, explained by higher energy costs and inflation. Yet, the Union industry prices were overall below the cost of production during the entire period considered due to the constant price pressure imposed by Chinese imports.
recital 190recital 190
4.5.2.2. Stocks
(190) Over the period considered stocks levels of the sampled Union producers developed as follows: Table 11 2020 2021 2022 RIP Stocks (tonnes) 1 409 1 342 1 732 2 610 Index (2020 = 100) 100 95 123 185 Source: Verified questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers.
recital 191recital 191
(191) The level of closing stocks of the Union industry increased in absolute terms by 85 % over the period considered. The steep upward trend, particularly between 2022 and the RIP, is a cause for concern given that the industry normally operates on an order basis, as was found in the original investigation and confirmed for the sampled Union producers in the current review investigation.
recital 192recital 192
4.5.2.3. Profitability, cash flow, investments, return on investment, ability to raise capital and wages
Table 12
2020 2021 2022 RIP Profitability (%) –7,9 –1,9 –8,6 –6,2 Cash flow (EUR) 4 454 901 4 836 800 538 686 163 925 Index (2020 = 100) 100 109 12 4 Investments (EUR) 550 853 1 248 391 1 263 537 3 242 161 Index (2020 = 100) 100 227 229 589 Return on investments (net assets) (%) –25,1 –15,0 –27,4 –14,3 Index (2020= – 100) – 100 – 60 – 109 – 57 Annual labour costs per employee (EUR) 19 638 22 459 23 765 24 516 Index (2020 = 100) 100 114 121 125 Source: Verified questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers.
(192) The Commission established the profitability of the sampled Union producers by expressing the pre-tax net profit of the sales of the like product to unrelated customers in the Union as a percentage of the turnover of those sales. During the period considered, the Union industry was constantly loss-making, progressively declining from –7,9 % to –6,2 %. This was still below the small level of profitability achieved during the original investigation (3,5 %), and thus well below the target profit considered acceptable in the original investigation (i.e. 6,0 %).
recital 193recital 193
(193) During the period considered the cash flow of the Union industry went down to almost zero. By contrast, at the same time the level of investments increased by 489 %. However, it should be noted that this investment was mainly financed by public support funds granted to mitigate the impact of the COVID crisis in 2020 and 2021 and the sharp rise in energy costs in 2022. These one-off state subsidies, tied to the modernisation of production equipment, enabled the companies to upgrade their production equipment significantly, as demonstrated by the increase in production.
recital 194recital 194
(194) During the period considered, return on investment, defined as the profit in percentage of the net book value of investments, was consistently negative.
recital 195recital 195
4.5.2.4. Labour cost
Table 13
2020 2021 2022 RIP Annual labour costs per employee (EUR) 19 638 22 459 23 765 24 516 Index (2020 = 100) 100 114 121 125 Source: Verified questionnaire replies of the sampled Union producers.
(195) During the same period, the average wage levels increased by 25 %, i.e. at a higher rate than the overall increase in unit cost of production.
recital 196recital 196
4.6. Conclusion on injury
(196) The injury analysis shows that the situation of the Union industry deteriorated during the period considered, despite efforts to keep pace with rising consumption. Although production capacity and production volumes increased in line with sales volumes, market shares could not be maintained. In the face of mounting production costs, most notably the energy, the Union industry found itself unable to adequately raise its sales prices. This was largely due to the low prices of Chinese imports, which, in spite of the measures in place, significantly undercut the prices of the Union industry. On the basis of the above, the Commission therefore concluded that the Union industry did suffer material injury within the meaning of Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation during the review investigation period.
recital 197recital 197
(197) Therefore, it is evident that the Union industry was unable to recover from past injury during the period considered. The continued significant import volumes from the PRC at prices undercutting those of the Union industry, which were already below cost of production, have put the Union industry again in an injurious situation.
recital 198recital 198
(198) After disclosure, Ceramie-Unie pointed out that on 2 April 2025 the US Administration announced a general tariff increase on most trading partners. For the case of Chinese goods, US duties initially amounted to 67 %. Although this percentage value has been reduced through negotiations, China is currently subject to a total 55 % tariff rate (not yet in force). Since the Commission found that the US is one of China’s main export markets of the product concerned, should the US tariff rate be effectively implemented, even more massive exportations from China to the Union would follow, resulting in further injury to Union ceramic tableware producers. Ceramie-Unie therefore argued that the US’s so-called reciprocal tariffs could have the effect of further reinforcing the attractiveness of the Union market for Chinese exporters of ceramic tableware and kitchenware, notably in view of the significant spare capacities of the Chinese tableware industry.
recital 199recital 199
(199) The Commission examined this claim and agreed that, indeed, the imposition of such tariffs could increase the attractiveness of the Union market.
recital 200recital 200
(200) After disclosure, CCCLA contested the Commission’s conclusions on injury claiming that causal link between Chinese imports and the injury observed during the review investigation period is not supported by positive evidence.
recital 201recital 201
(201) In CCCLA’s view the Commission’s injury findings lean almost entirely on the indicator of profitability, while several key macroeconomic indicators – including Union consumption, production, sales volume, employment and investments – showed an improvement over the period considered.
recital 202recital 202
(202) Furthermore, the CCCLA claimed that also some microeconomic indicators such as unit cost of production, investments and labour cost are the main causes that depressed the profitability, and not the Chinese imports.
recital 203recital 203
(203) This claim had to be dismissed. It is true that following the increase in Union consumption, production and sales volume of the Union industry increased due to the ongoing post-Covid effect and, in order to benefit from the renewed interest among European consumers, the Union industry invested in increased capacity. However, as explained in recital (182), despite these efforts, the Union industry could not benefit from the growing Union market and lost market share to the advantage of Chinese imports, as demonstrated by the increase in stocks and the decrease in capacity utilisation.
recital 204recital 204
(204) As regards the microeconomic indicators, the Commission agrees that the increase in unit cost of production of the Union industry cannot be attributed to the effects of imports from China. However, as acknowledged by the CCCLA itself in its submission, the average price of the Union industry remained below its costs throughout the whole period considered. As explained in recital (189) the constant price pressure of the Chinese dumped imports did not allow the Union industry to raise its prices to a sustainable level to cover for the increase in costs, such as labour and energy, and for the recovery of the investments made. Therefore, this claim has been rejected.
recital 205recital 205
5.CAUSATION
(205) In accordance with Article 3(6) of the basic Regulation, the Commission examined whether the dumped imports from the country concerned caused material injury to the Union industry. In accordance with Article 3(7) of the basic Regulation, the Commission also examined whether other known factors could at the same time have injured the Union industry. The Commission ensured that any possible injury caused by factors other than the dumped imports from the country concerned was not attributed to the impact of the dumped imports. These factors are imports from other third countries and export performance of the Union industry.
recital 206recital 206
5.1. Effects of the dumped imports
(206) The volume of imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from the PRC increased by 26 % over the period considered, reaching a 58,1 % market share in the Union in the RIP. At the same time, sales of the Union industry, albeit increasing, lost market share to Chinese imports. The average import price from China remained constant, and significantly, below prices and costs of the Union industry throughout the period considered. Average import prices undercut Union industry average sales price by 18 %. Without the anti-dumping duties, the difference would amount to 38 % (see recital (169)).
recital 207recital 207
(207) On the basis of the above, the Commission concluded that the imports from China were significant and were exerting a downward pressure on the Union industry prices and sales volumes, thus determining the injury suffered by the Union industry.
recital 208recital 208
(208) Moreover, the Commission considered that there was a clear coincidence in time between the upward movement in Chinese imports and the injurious situation of the Union industry.
recital 209recital 209
5.2. Effects of other factors
5.2.1. Imports from third countries
(209) The volume of imports from other third countries increased only marginally over the period considered, as shown in recital (173) above. These imports came mainly from Türkiye (4,4 % market share in the RIP), Thailand (2,6 %), United Kingdom (1,4 %), Bangladesh (1,3 %), and United Arab Emirates (1,3 %).
recital 210recital 210
(210) In the case of Türkiye and the United Arab Emirates, these imports were made at prices significantly lower than those of Union producers throughout the period considered, albeit, well above Chinese prices. Only in the RIP, import prices of Bangladesh were lower than Union producers’ sales prices, but always higher than prices of Chinese imports during the period considered. Imports from other countries, on the contrary, were at much higher prices compared to Union producers’ prices.
recital 211recital 211
(211) On the basis of the above, the Commission concluded that the prices observed for Türkiye, the United Arab Emirates and Bangladesh, which were below the average prices of the Union industry, could have contributed to the injury. However, given the low volumes of these imports, such effects would have been limited.
recital 212recital 212
(212) After disclosure the CCCLA argued that the Commission failed to properly analyse the effect of the imports from other third countries as, in its view, even small-volume suppliers can influence market prices, especially in niche segments or geographic sub-markets. However, the CCCLA did not provide any evidence to substantiate its claim that was, therefore, dismissed.
recital 213recital 213
5.2.2. Export performance of the Union industry
(213) The exports of the Union producers developed over the period considered as follows: Table 14 2020 2021 2022 RIP Export volume (tonnes) 74 978 96 920 87 517 81 059 Index (2020 = 100) 100 129 117 108 Source: Verified questionnaire replies from Cerame-Unie/FEPF.
recital 214recital 214
(214) Export sales accounted for around 40 % of the total sales of the Union producers. While there was a significant rise in export sales by Union producers of 29 % in 2021, the growth figures were smaller compared to those in the Union market in 2022 and the RIP (see Table 8, 2022: 27 %, RIP: 15 %, respectively). Overall, during the period considered, export sales increased by 8 % compared to 15 % in the Union market. Furthermore, insufficient capacity utilisation (see Table 7) and mounting stock levels (see Table 10) point to no redirection towards export sales during this period. Therefore, it was concluded that the export performance did not contribute to the injury suffered.
recital 215recital 215
(215) After disclosure the CCCLA claimed that the increased export performance of the Union industry contradicts the Commission’s conclusion of a weakened industry whose difficulties are primarily driven by import competition from China. The Commission disagrees with this assessment. As explained in the previous recital above during the period considered, export sales increased by a far lesser extent than sales in the Union market, i.e. by 8 % compared to 15 %. Therefore, the export performance of the Union industry did not break the causal link.
recital 216recital 216
5.2.3. Increase in energy costs
(216) An increase in the costs of energy due to the war in Ukraine had an impact on production costs. However, during the RIP, this trend reversed. Despite this, the Union industry was still unable to even maintain its market share nor increase sales prices above production costs, due the pricing and volume pressure of Chinese dumped imports in the RIP.
recital 217recital 217
5.3. Conclusion on causation
(217) On the basis of the above, the Commission concluded that the dumped imports originating in the PRC materially injured the Union industry.
recital 218recital 218
(218) The other identified factors such as the imports from other third countries, the export sales performance of the Union producers and the increase in the costs of energy, whether considered individually or collectively, did not attenuate the causal link between the dumped imports and the injury.
recital 219recital 219
6.LIKELIHOOD OF CONTINUATION OF INJURY
(219) As determined in Section 3 above, Chinese imports were made at dumped price levels during the review investigation period and a likelihood of continuation of dumping was found should the measures be allowed to lapse. In accordance with Article 11(2) of the basic Regulation, the Commission therefore examined the likelihood of continuation or recurrence of injury should measures be allowed to lapse.
recital 220recital 220
(220) To establish the likelihood of continuation of injury, the following elements were analysed: the production capacity and spare capacities in the PRC, the attractiveness of the Union market, including the existence of anti-dumping or countervailing measures on ceramic tableware and kitchenware in other third countries, the price behaviour of Chinese exporting producers in other third-country markets, and the effects on the Union industry’s situation.
recital 221recital 221
6.1. Production capacity and spare capacities in the PRC
(221) The PRC is by far the largest global exporter of ceramic table- and kitchenware in the world. It accounts for around 65 % of the world’s overall exports ( 72 ) . The EU is the PRC’s second most important export market, based on total value exported during the RIP ( 73 ) .
recital 222recital 222
(222) As explained in recitals (146) to (148) above, producers in the PRC have significant production capacities which largely exceed the total Union consumption during the review investigation period.
recital 223recital 223
6.2. The attractiveness of the Union market
(223) As stated in recitals (151) to (153) above, increasing consumption levels in the Union market, as well as the imposition of measures on ceramic tableware and kitchenware from China in third markets, have contributed to the attractiveness of the Union market.
recital 224recital 224
(224) The fact that market share of Chinese imports increased during the period considered, and that there are significant imports, even with the existing measures, confirms that Chinese exporting producers find the Union market attractive and will continue selling on the Union market.
recital 225recital 225
6.3. Price behaviour of Chinese exporting producers
(225) The pricing strategy of Chinese producers, as summarised in recital (154), showing lower prices on the main markets of Chinese imports, makes it so that it can be reasonably expected that Chinese imports will enter the Union market at lower prices should the measures be allowed to lapse.
recital 226recital 226
(226) Given the high spare capacities in the PRC, the slowdown of the Chinese internal market, the attractiveness of the Union market and the pricing behaviour of Chinese exporting producers as summarised above in recitals (154) to (155), it is likely that significant volumes of low-priced ceramic tableware and kitchenware would be available for sale/redirection to the Union already in the short term should the measures be allowed to lapse, as demonstrated by the level of undercutting found without taking into account the anti-dumping duties, i.e. 38 % (see recital (169)) which is the most likely indication of the price behaviour of Chines exporters in the absence of the measures.
recital 227recital 227
6.4. Conclusion
(227) In view of the above findings, namely the massive spare capacity in the PRC, the attractiveness of the Union market, the price levels of imports from the PRC in the absence of anti-dumping measures and their likely impact on the Union industry, the Commission concluded that the absence of measures would in all likelihood result in a significant increase of dumped imports from the PRC at injurious prices and injury would be likely to continue.
recital 228recital 228
7.UNION INTEREST
7.1. Introduction
(228) In accordance with Article 21 of the basic Regulation, the Commission examined whether the maintenance of the measures would not be against the interest of the Union as a whole. The determination of the Union interest was based on an appreciation of the various interests involved, that is those of the Union industry on the one hand, and those of importers and other parties on the other hand.
recital 229recital 229
(229) The Commission recalled that, in the original investigation, the adoption of measures was considered not to be against the interest of the Union. Furthermore, the fact that the present investigation is a review, thus analysing a situation in which anti-dumping measures have already been in place, allows for the assessment of any undue negative impact on the parties concerned by the current anti-dumping measures.
recital 230recital 230
(230) On that basis, it was examined whether, despite the conclusions on the likelihood of a continuation of dumping and injury, compelling reasons existed which would lead to the conclusion that it is not in the Union interest to maintain measures in this particular case.
recital 231recital 231
7.2. Interest of the Union industry
(231) The investigation showed that should the measures expire, this would likely have a significant negative effect on the Union industry. The Union industry’s situation would further deteriorate in terms of volumes and prices resulting in a strong decrease in profitability. On the other hand, the continuation of measures would allow the Union industry to recover from past injury caused by dumped imports, and to exploit its potential on a Union market that is not affected by unfair trading practices.
recital 232recital 232
(232) CCCLA stated, and reiterated after disclosure, that imports from China do have certain complementary effects on Union production, resulting in a mixture of interest within the Union industry. Therefore, prolonging the measures would not appear to be in the interest of EU producers, given that their economic indicators (imports, production, domestic and export sales) show a sound state. Moreover, according to CCCLA, certain EU producers do not manufacture all types of ceramic tableware and kitchenware, meaning that these items need to be imported from third countries, including China. The anti-dumping duties have increased the price of products sourced from producers in China, which has had a continuous negative effect on these EU producers.
recital 233recital 233
(233) However, the injury analysis in Section 4 above (recitals (160) to (197)) has shown that in fact, the Union industry continued to suffer, despite the measures, from the injurious effects of the dumped imports from the PRC. Indeed, Union industry had experienced a decrease in market share during the period considered, while not able to increase their sales prices to profitable levels. Furthermore, CCCLA’s above assertion to the contrary lacked substantiating evidence that could be further analysed, leading the Commission to reject this claim.
recital 234recital 234
(234) Based on the above it was concluded that maintaining the anti-dumping measures in force is in the interest of the Union industry.
recital 235recital 235
7.3. Interest of unrelated importers
(235) At the initiation stage of this investigation, 51 known unrelated importers were contacted and invited to cooperate. No one came forward at the sampling stage. Only one importer at a later stage spontaneously submitted some limited information on imports, not raising any objections to the possible extension of the current measures.
recital 236recital 236
(236) Based on this, and in line with the findings of the previous expiry review that revealed healthy profit margins of importers of the product concerned ( 74 ) , it was concluded that maintaining the existing measures would not have a significant adverse effect on the activity of unrelated importers of the product concerned.
recital 237recital 237
7.4. Interest of consumers (households)
(237) Like in the previous expiry review investigation, no parties representing the interests of end-users, such as associations of consumers, came forward or cooperated in any way in the investigation. In the continued absence of cooperation from users in the present expiry review investigation, the Commission considered that its findings in the original investigation are still valid, and that the continuation of measures would not negatively affect consumers such as households, or at least not to any significant extent.
recital 238recital 238
(238) The CCCLA brought forward and reiterated after definitive disclosure, that as ceramic tableware and kitchenware is a final product, the anti-dumping duties would hit Union consumers directly as there is no intermediate industry to absorb the costs.
recital 239recital 239
(239) Cerame-Unie/FEPF responded to above claim that despite the anti-dumping measures currently in force, imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware from China have continued entering the Union in large quantities and at very low prices.
recital 240recital 240
(240) The Commission considered it very unlikely that the repeal of the measures would result in the lowering of prices with the full amount of the duties. Even in the unlikely scenario where consumer prices would be lowered with the full amount of the current anti-dumping duties, the yearly cost of consumers would be reduced by less than EUR 1 ( 75 ) . As the measures cannot be deemed to have had a significant impact on consumers, the Commission rejected these claims.
recital 241recital 241
7.5. Balancing of interests
(241) In balancing the different competing interests in the Union, the Commission gave special consideration to the need to eliminate the trade distorting effects of injurious dumping and to ensure effective fair competition. On the one hand the continuation of measures would protect an important Union industry, including many small and medium enterprises, against a likely continuation of injury. On the other hand, the assessment of the situation of importers and users based on the information available due to the lack of cooperation shows that the continuation of measures would clearly not have a disproportionate negative impact on them.
recital 242recital 242
7.6. Conclusion
(242) Therefore, the Commission concluded that there are no compelling reasons of Union interest against the maintenance of the definitive anti-dumping measures on imports of tableware and kitchenware originating in the PRC.
recital 243recital 243
8.ANTI-DUMPING MEASURES
(243) It follows from the above that the anti-dumping measures applicable to imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware originating in China should be maintained.
recital 244recital 244
(244) To minimise the risks of circumvention due to the difference in duty rates, special measures are needed to ensure the application of the individual anti-dumping duties. The application of individual anti-dumping duties is only applicable upon presentation of a valid commercial invoice to the customs authorities of the Member States. The invoice must conform to the requirements set out in Article 1(4) of this regulation. Until such invoice is presented, imports should be subject to the anti-dumping duty applicable to ‘all other imports originating in China’.
recital 245recital 245
(245) While presentation of this invoice is necessary for the customs authorities of the Member States to apply the individual rates of anti-dumping duty to imports, it is not the only element to be taken into account by the customs authorities. Indeed, even if presented with an invoice meeting all the requirements set out in Article 1(4) of this regulation, the customs authorities of Member States must carry out their usual checks and may, like in all other cases, require additional documents (shipping documents etc.) for the purpose of verifying the accuracy of the particulars contained in the declaration and ensure that the subsequent application of the lower rate of duty is justified, in compliance with customs law.
recital 246recital 246
(246) Should the exports by one of the companies benefiting from lower individual duty rates increase significantly in volume after the imposition of the measures concerned, such an increase in volume could be considered as constituting in itself a change in the pattern of trade due to the imposition of measures within the meaning of Article 13(1) of the basic Regulation. In such circumstances and provided the conditions are met an anti-circumvention investigation may be initiated. This investigation may, inter alia, examine the need for the removal of individual duty rate(s) and the consequent imposition of a country-wide duty.
recital 247recital 247
(247) The individual company anti-dumping duty rates specified in this Regulation are exclusively applicable to imports of the product under review originating in China and produced by the named legal entities. Imports of the product under review produced by any other company not specifically mentioned in the operative part of this Regulation, including entities related to those specifically mentioned, should be subject to the duty rate applicable to ‘all other imports originating in China’. They should not be subject to any of the individual anti-dumping duty rates.
recital 248recital 248
(248) A company may request the application of individual anti-dumping duty rates if it changes subsequently the name of its entity. The request must be addressed to the Commission ( 76 ) . The request must contain all the relevant information enabling to demonstrate that the change does not affect the right of the company to benefit from the duty rate which applies to it. If the change of name of the company does not affect its right to benefit from the duty rate which applies to it, a notice informing about the change of name will be published in the Official Journal of the European Union .
recital 249recital 249
(249) All interested parties were informed of the essential facts and considerations on the basis of which it was intended to recommend that the existing measures be maintained. They were also granted a period to make representations subsequent to this disclosure.
recital 250recital 250
(250) An exporter or producer that did not export the product concerned to the Union during the period that was used to set the level of the duty currently applicable to its exports may request the Commission to be made subject to the anti-dumping duty rate for cooperating companies not included in the sample. The Commission should grant such request, provided that three conditions are met. The new exporting producer would have to demonstrate that: (i) it did not export the product concerned to the Union during the period that was used to set the level of the duty applicable to its exports; (ii) it is not related to a company that did so and thus is subject to the anti-dumping duties; and (iii) has exported the product concerned thereafter or has entered into an irrevocable contractual obligation to do so in substantial quantities.
recital 251recital 251
(251) In view of Article 109 of Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2024/2509 of the European Parliament and of the Council ( 77 ) , when an amount is to be reimbursed following a judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union, the interest to be paid should be the rate applied by the European Central Bank to its principal refinancing operations, as published in the C series of the Official Journal of the European Union on the first calendar day of each month.
recital 252recital 252
(252) The measures provided for in this Regulation are in accordance with the opinion of the Committee established by Article 15(1) of Regulation (EU) 2016/1036,
Article 1
1.A definitive anti-dumping duty is imposed on imports of ceramic tableware and kitchenware, excluding ceramic condiment or spice mills and their ceramic grinding parts, ceramic coffee mills, ceramic knife sharpeners, ceramic sharpeners, ceramic kitchen tools to be used for cutting, grinding, grating, slicing, scraping and peeling, and cordierite ceramic pizza-stones of a kind used for baking pizza or bread, currently falling under CN codes ex 6911 10 00 , ex 6912 00 21 , ex 6912 00 23 , ex 6912 00 25 and ex 6912 00 29 (TARIC codes 6911 10 00 90 , 6912 00 21 11 , 6912 00 21 91 , 6912 00 23 10 , 6912 00 25 10 and 6912 00 29 10 ) and originating in the People’s Republic of China.
2.The rate of the definitive anti-dumping duty applicable to the net, free-at-Union-frontier price, before duty, of the products described in paragraph 1 shall be as follows: Country of origin Definitive anti-dumping duty (%) People’s Republic of China 79,0
3.Unless otherwise specified, the provisions in force concerning customs duties shall apply.
Article 2
This Regulation shall enter into force on the day following that of its publication in the Official Journal of the European Union .
Annex 1ANNEX
Cooperating Chinese exporting producers not sampled
Company TARIC Additional Code Amaida Ceramic Product Co., Ltd. B357 Asianera Porcelain (Tangshan) Ltd. B358 Beiliu Changlong Ceramics Co., Ltd. B359 Beiliu City Heyun Building Materials Co., Ltd. B361 Beiliu Quanli Ceramic Co., Ltd. B363 Beiliu Shimin Porcelain Co., Ltd. B364 Beiliu Windview Industries Ltd. B365 Cameo China (Fengfeng) Co., Ltd. B366 Changsha Happy Go Products Developing Co., Ltd. B367 Chao An Huadayu Craftwork Factory B368 Chaoan County Fengtang Town HaoYe Ceramic Fty B369 Chao’an Lian Xing Yuan Ceramics Co., Ltd. B370 Chaoan Oh Yeah Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B371 Chaoan Shengyang Crafts Industrial Co., Ltd B372 Chaoan Xin Yuan Ceramics Factory B373 Chao’an Yongsheng Ceramic Industry Co., Ltd. B374 Guangdong Baodayi Porcelain Co., Ltd. B375 Chaozhou Baode Ceramics Co., Ltd, B376 Chaozhou Baolian Ceramics Co., Ltd. B377 Chaozhou Big Arrow Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B378 Chaozhou Boshifa Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B379 Chaozhou Cantake Craft Co., Ltd. B380 Chaozhou Ceramics Industry and Trade General Corp. B381 Chaozhou Chaofeng Ceramic Making Co., Ltd. B382 Chaozhou Chengxi Jijie Art & Craft Painted Porcelain Fty. B383 Chaozhou Chengxinda Ceramics Industry Co., Ltd. B384 Chaozhou Chenhui Ceramics Co., Ltd. B385 Chaozhou Chonvson Ceramics Industry Co., Ltd. B386 Chaozhou Daxin Arts & Crafts Co., Ltd. B387 Chaozhou DaXing Ceramics Manufactory Co., Ltd B388 Chaozhou Dayi Ceramics Industries Co., Ltd. B389 Chaozhou Dehong Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B390 Chaozhou Deko Ceramic Co., Ltd. B391 Chaozhou Diamond Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B392 Chaozhou Dongyi Ceramics Co., Ltd. B393 Chaozhou Dragon Porcelain Industrial Co., Ltd. B394 Chaozhou Fairway Ceramics Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B395 Chaozhou Feida Ceramics Industries Co., Ltd. B396 Chaozhou Fengxi Baita Ceramics Fty. B397 Chaozhou Fengxi Dongtian Porcelain Fty. No 2 B398 Chaozhou Fengxi Fenger Ceramics Craft Fty. B399 Chaozhou Fengxi Hongrong Color Porcelain Fty. B400 Chaozhou Fengxi Jiaxiang Ceramic Manufactory B401 Guangdong GMT Foreign Trade Service Corp. B402 Chaozhou Fengxi Shengshui Porcelain Art Factory B403 Chaozhou Fengxi Zone Jinbaichuan Porcelain Crafts Factory B404 Chaozhou Fromone Ceramic Co., Ltd. B405 Chaozhou Genol Ceramics Manufacture Co., Ltd. B406 Chaozhou Good Concept Ceramics Co., Ltd. B407 Chaozhou Grand Collection Ceramics Manufacturing Co. Ltd. B408 Chaozhou Guangjia Ceramics Manufacture Co., Ltd. B409 Chaozhou Guidu Ceramics Co., Ltd. B410 Chaozhou Haihong Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B411 Chaozhou Hengchuang Porcelain Co., Ltd. B412 Chaozhou Henglibao Porcelain Industrial Co., Ltd. B413 Chaozhou Hongbo Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B414 Chaozhou Hongjia Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B415 Chaozhou Hongye Ceramics Manufactory Co., Ltd. B416 Chaozhou Hongye Porcelain Development Co., Ltd. B417 Chaozhou Hongyue Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B418 Chaozhou Hongzhan Ceramic Manufacture Co., Ltd. B419 Chaozhou Hua Da Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B420 Chaozhou Huabo Ceramic Co., Ltd. B421 Chaozhou Huade Ceramics Manufacture Co., Ltd. B422 Chaozhou Huashan Industrial Co., Ltd. B423 Chaozhou Huayu Ceramics Co., Ltd. B424 Chaozhou Huazhong Ceramics Industries Co., Ltd. B425 Chaozhou Huifeng Ceramics Craft Making Co., Ltd. B426 Chaozhou J&M Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B427 Chaozhou Jencymic Co., Ltd. B428 Chaozhou Jiahua Ceramics Co., Ltd. B429 Chaozhou Jiahuabao Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B430 Chaozhou JiaHui Ceramic Factory B431 Chaozhou Jiaye Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B432 Chaozhou Jiayi Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B433 Chaozhou Jiayu Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B434 Chaozhou Jin Jia Da Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B435 Chaozhou Jingfeng Ceramics Craft Co., Ltd. B436 Guangdong Jinqiangyi Ceramics Co., Ltd. B437 Chaozhou Jinxin Ceramics Making Co., Ltd B438 Chaozhou Jinyuanli Ceramics Manufacture Co., Ltd. B439 Chaozhou Kaibo Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B440 Chaozhou Kedali Porcelain Industrial Co., Ltd. B441 Chaozhou King’s Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B442 Chaozhou Kingwave Porcelain & Pigment Co., Ltd. B443 Chaozhou Lemontree Tableware Co., Ltd. B444 Chaozhou Lianfeng Porcelain Co., Ltd. B445 Chaozhou Lianyu Ceramics Co., Ltd. B447 ChaoZhou Lianyuan Ceramic Making Co., Ltd. B448 Chaozhou Lisheng Ceramics Co., Ltd. B449 Chaozhou Loving Home Porcelain Co., Ltd. B450 Chaozhou Maocheng Industry Dve. Co., Ltd. B451 Chaozhou MBB Porcelain Factory B452 Guangdong Mingyu Technology Joint Stock Limited Company B453 Chaozhou New Power Co., Ltd. B454 Chaozhou Ohga Porcelain Co.,Ltd. B455 Chaozhou Oubo Ceramics Co., Ltd. B456 Chaozhou Pengfa Ceramics Manufactory Co., Ltd. B457 Chaozhou Pengxing Ceramics Co., Ltd. B458 Chaozhou Qingfa Ceramics Co., Ltd. B459 Chaozhou Ronghua Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B460 Guangdong Ronglibao Homeware Co., Ltd. B461 Chaozhou Rui Cheng Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B462 Chaozhou Rui Xiang Porcelain Industrial Co., Ltd. B463 Chaozhou Ruilong Ceramics Co., Ltd. B464 Chaozhou Sanhua Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B465 Chaozhou Sanming Industrial Co., Ltd. B466 Chaozhou Santai Porcelain Co., Ltd. B467 Chaozhou Shuntai Ceramic Manufactory Co., Ltd. B468 Chaozhou Songfa Ceramics Co.,Ltd. B469 Chaozhou Sundisk Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B470 Chaozhou Teemjade Ceramics Co., Ltd. B471 Chaozhou Thyme Ceramics Co., Ltd. B472 Chaozhou Tongxing Huajiang Ceramics Making Co., Ltd B473 Guangdong Totye Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B474 Chaozhou Trend Arts & Crafts Co., Ltd. B475 Chaozhou Uncommon Craft Industrial Co., Ltd. B476 Chaozhou Weida Ceramic Making Co., Ltd. B477 Chaozhou Weigao Ceramic Craft Co., Ltd. B478 Chaozhou Wingoal Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B479 Chaozhou Wood House Porcelain Co., Ltd. B480 Chaozhou Xiangye Ceramics Craft Making Co., Ltd. B481 Chaozhou Xin Weicheng Co., Ltd. B482 Chaozhou Xincheng Ceramics Co., Ltd. B483 Chaozhou Xingguang Ceramics Co., Ltd. B485 Chaozhou Wenhui Porcelain Co., Ltd. B486 Chaozhou Xinkai Porcelain Co., Ltd. B487 Chaozhou Xinlong Porcelain Industrial Co., Ltd. B488 Chaozhou Xinyu Porcelain Industrial Co., Ltd. B489 Chaozhou Xinyue Ceramics Manufacture Co., Ltd. B490 Chaozhou Yangguang Ceramics Co., Ltd. B491 Chaozhou Yinhe Ceramics Co., Ltd. B493 Chaozhou Yongsheng Ceramics Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B494 Chaozhou Yongxuan Domestic Ceramics Manufactory Co., Ltd. B495 Chaozhou Yu Ri Ceramics Making Co., Ltd. B496 Chaozhou Yuefeng Ceramics Ind. Co., Ltd. B497 Chaozhou Yufeng Ceramics Making Factory B498 Chaozhou Zhongxia Porcelain Factory Co., Ltd. B499 Chaozhou Zhongye Ceramics Co., Ltd. B500 Dabu Yongxingxiang Ceramics Co., Ltd. B501 Dapu Fuda Ceramics Co., Ltd. B502 Dapu Taoyuan Porcelain Factory B503 Dasheng Ceramics Co., Ltd. Dehua B504 De Hua Hongshun Ceramic Co., Ltd. B505 Dehua Hongsheng Ceramic Co., Ltd. B506 Dehua Jianyi Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B507 Dehua Kaiyuan Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B508 Dehua Ruyuan Gifts Co., Ltd. B509 Dehua Xinmei Ceramics Co., Ltd. B510 Dongguan Kennex Ceramic Ltd. B511 Dongguan Shilong Kyocera Co., Ltd. B512 Dongguan Yongfuda Ceramics Co., Ltd. B513 Excellent Porcelain Co., Ltd. B515 Fair-Link Limited (Xiamen) B516 Far East (chaozhou) Ceramics Factory Co., Ltd. B518 Fengfeng Mining District Yuhang Ceramic Co. Ltd. (‘Yuhang’) B519 Foshan Metart Company Limited B520 Fujian Jiashun Art&Crafts Co., Ltd. B521 Fujian Dehua Chengyi Ceramics Co., Ltd. B522 Fujian Dehua Five Continents Ceramic Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B523 Fujian Dehua Fujue Ceramics Co., Ltd. B524 Fujian Dehua Full Win Crafts Co., Ltd. B525 Fujian Dehua Fusheng Ceramics Co., Ltd. B526 Fujian Dehua Gentle Porcelain Co., Ltd. B527 Fujian Dehua Guanhong Ceramic Co., Ltd. B528 Fujian Dehua Guanjie Ceramics Co., Ltd. B529 Luzerne (Fujian) Group Co., Ltd. B530 Fujian Dehua Hongda Ceramics Co., Ltd. B531 Fujian Dehua Hongsheng Arts & Crafts Co., Ltd. B532 Fujian Dehua Hongyu Ceramic Co., Ltd. B533 Fujian Dehua Huachen Ceramics Co., Ltd. B534 Fujian Dehua Huaxia Ceramics Co., Ltd. B535 Fujian Dehua Huilong Ceramic Co., Ltd. B536 Fujian Dehua Jingyi Ceramics Co., Ltd. B537 Fujian Dehua Jinhua Porcelain Co., Ltd. B538 Fujian Dehua Jinzhu Ceramics Co., Ltd. B539 Fujian Dehua Lianda Ceramic Co., Ltd. B540 Fujian Dehua Myinghua Ceramics Co., Ltd. B541 Fujian Dehua Pengxin Ceramics Co., Ltd. B542 Fujian Dehua Shisheng Ceramics Co., Ltd. B544 Fujian Dehua Will Ceramic Co., Ltd. B545 Fujian Dehua Xianda Ceramic Factory B546 Fujian Dehua Xianghui Ceramic Co., Ltd. B547 Fujian Dehua Yonghuang Ceramic Co., Ltd. B549 Fujian Dehua Yousheng Ceramics Co., Ltd. B550 Fujian Dehua You-Young Crafts Co., Ltd. B551 Fujian Dehua Zhenfeng Ceramics Co., Ltd. B552 Fujian Dehua Zhennan Ceramics Co., Ltd. B553 Fujian Jackson Arts and Crafts Co., Ltd. B554 Fujian Jiamei Group Corporation B555 Fujian Province Dehua County Beatrot Ceramic Co., Ltd. B557 Fujian Province Yongchun County Foreign Processing and Assembling Corporation B558 Fujian Quanzhou Longpeng Group Co., Ltd. B559 Fujian Dehua S&M Arts Co., Ltd., and Fujian Taigu Ceramics Co., Ltd. B560 Fung Lin Wah Group B561 Ganzhou Koin Structure Ceramics Co., Ltd. B562 Global Housewares Factory B563 Guangdong Baofeng Ceramic Technology Development Co., Ltd. B564 Guangdong Bening Ceramics Industries Co., Ltd. B565 Guangdong Daye Porcelain Co., Ltd. B566 Guangdong Dongbao Group Co., Ltd. B567 Guangdong Huaxing Ceramics Co., Ltd. B568 Guangdong Quanfu Ceramics Ind. Co., Ltd. B569 Guangdong Shunqiang Ceramics Co., Ltd B570 Guangdong Shunxiang Porcelain Co., Ltd. B571 Guangdong Sitong Group Co., Ltd. B572 GuangDong XingTaiYi Porcelain Co., Ltd B574 Guangdong Yutai Porcelain Co., Ltd. B575 Guangdong Zhentong Ceramics Co., Ltd B576 Guangxi Baian Ceramic Co. Ltd B577 Guangxi Beiliu City Ming Chao Porcelain Co., Ltd. B578 Guangxi Beiliu Huasheng Porcelain Ltd. B580 Guangxi Beiliu Newcentury Ceramic Llc. B581 Guangxi Beiliu Qinglang Porcelain Trade Co., Ltd. B582 Guangxi Beiliu Xiongfa Ceramics Co., Ltd. B584 Guangxi Beiliu Yujie Porcelain Co., Ltd. B585 Guangxi Beiliu Zhongli Ceramics Co., Ltd B586 Guangxi Nanshan Porcelain Co., Ltd. B587 Guangxi Yulin Rongxing Ceramics Co., Ltd. B589 Guangzhou Chaintime Porcelain Co., Ltd. B590 Haofa Ceramics Co., Ltd., Dehua Fujian B591 Hebei Dersun Ceramic Co., Ltd. B592 Hebei Great Wall Ceramic Co., Ltd. B593 Henan Ruilong Ceramics Co., Ltd B594 Henghui Porcelain Plant Liling Hunan China B595 Huanyu Ceramic Industrial Co., Ltd. Liling Hunan China B596 Hunan Baihua Ceramics Co., Ltd. B597 Hunan Eka Ceramics Co., Ltd. B598 Hunan Fungdeli Ceramics Co., Ltd. B599 Hunan Gaofeng Ceramic Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B600 Hunan Huari Ceramic Industry Co., Ltd B601 Hunan Huayun Ceramics Factory Co., Ltd B603 Hunan Liling Tianxin China Industry Ltd. B604 Hunan Provincial Liling Chuhua Ceramic Industrial Co., Ltd. B605 Hunan Quanxiang Ceramics Corp. Ltd. B606 Hunan Rslee Ceramics Co., Ltd B607 Hunan Taisun Ceramics Co., Ltd. B608 Hunan Victor Imp. & Exp. Co., Ltd B609 Hunan Xianfeng Ceramic Industry Co.,Ltd B611 Jiangsu Gaochun Ceramics Co., Ltd. B612 Jiangsu Yixing Fine Pottery Corp., Ltd. B613 Jiangxi Global Ceramic Co., Ltd. B614 Jiangxi Kangshu Porcelain Co.,Ltd. B615 Jingdezhen F&B Porcelain Co., Ltd. B616 Jingdezhen Yuanjing Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B617 Jiyuan Jukang Xinxing Ceramics Co., Ltd. B618 Junior Star Ent’s Co., Ltd. B620 K&T Ceramics International Co., Ltd. B621 Kam Lee (Xing Guo) Metal and Plastic Fty. Co., Ltd. B622 Karpery Industrial Co., Ltd. Hunan China B623 Kilncraft Ceramics Ltd. B624 Lian Jiang Golden Faith Porcelain Co., Ltd. B625 Liling Gaojia Ceramic Industry Co., Ltd B626 Liling GuanQian Ceramic Manufacture Co., Ltd. B627 Liling Huahui Ceramic Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B628 Liling Huawang Ceramics Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B629 Liling Jiahua Porcelain Manufacturing Co., Ltd B630 Liling Jialong Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd B631 Liling Jiaxing Ceramic Industrial Co., Ltd B632 Liling Kaiwei Ceramic Co., Ltd. B633 Liling Liangsheng Ceramic Manufacture Co., Ltd. B634 Liling Liuxingtan Ceramics Co., Ltd B635 Liling Minghui Ceramics Factory B636 Liling Pengxing Ceramic Factory B637 Liling Quanhu Industries General Company B638 Liling Ruixiang Ceramics Industrial Co., Ltd. B640 Liling Santang Ceramics Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B641 Liling Shenghua Industrial Co., Ltd. B642 Liling Spring Ceramic Industry Co., Ltd B643 Liling Tengrui Industrial and Trading Co.,Ltd. B644 Liling Top Collection Industrial Co., Ltd B645 Liling United Ceramic-Ware Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B646 Liling Yonghe Porcelain Factory B647 Liling Yucha Ceramics Co., Ltd. B648 Liling Zhengcai Ceramic Manufacturing Co., Ltd B649 Linyi Jinli Ceramics Co., Ltd. B650 Linyi Pengcheng Industry Co., Ltd. B651 Linyi Wanqiang Ceramics Co., Ltd. B652 Linyi Zhaogang Ceramics Co., Ltd. B653 Liveon Industrial Co., Ltd. B654 Long Da Bone China Co., Ltd. B655 Meizhou Lianshunchang Trading Co., Ltd. B657 Meizhou Xinma Ceramics Co., Ltd. B658 Meizhou Yuanfeng Ceramic Industry Co., Ltd. B659 Meizhou Zhong Guang Industrial Co., Ltd. B660 Miracle Dynasty Fine Bone China (Shanghai) Co., Ltd. B661 Photo USA Electronic Graphic Inc. B662 Quanzhou Allen Light Industry Co., Ltd. B663 Quanzhou Chuangli Craft Co., Ltd. B664 Quanzhou Dehua Fangsheng Arts Co., Ltd. B665 Quanzhou Haofu Gifts Co., Ltd. B666 Quanzhou Hongsheng Group Corporation B667 Quanzhou Jianwen Craft Co., Ltd. B668 Quanzhou Kunda Gifts Co., Ltd. B669 Quanzhou Yongchun Shengyi Ceramics Co., Ltd. B670 Raoping Bright Future Porcelain Factory (‘RBF’) B671 Raoping Sanrao Yicheng Porcelain Factory B672 Raoping Sanyi Industrial Co., Ltd. B673 Raoping Suifeng Ceramics and Glass Factory B674 Raoping Xinfeng Yangda Colour Porcelain FTY B675 Red Star Ceramics Limited B676 Rong Lin Wah Industrial (Shenzhen) Co., Ltd. B677 Shandong Futai Ceramics Co., Ltd. B679 Shandong Gaode Hongye Ceramics Co., Ltd. B680 Shandong Kunlun Ceramic Co., Ltd. B681 Shandong Zhaoding Porcelain Co., Ltd. B682 Shantou Ceramics Industry Supply & Marketing Corp. B683 Sheng Hua Ceramics Co., Ltd. B684 Shenzhen Baoshengfeng Imp. & Exp. Co., Ltd. B685 Shenzhen Bright Future Industry Co., Ltd. (‘SBF’) B686 Shenzhen Ehome Enterprise Ltd B688 Shenzhen Ever Nice Industry Co., Ltd. B689 Shenzhen Fuliyuan Porcelain Co., Ltd. B690 Shenzhen Full Amass Ind. Dev. Co. Ltd B691 Shenzhen Gottawa Industrial Ltd. B694 Shenzhen Hiker Housewares Ltd. B695 Shenzhen Hua Mei Industry Development Ltd B696 Shenzhen Mingsheng Ceramic Ltd. B697 Shenzhen Senyi Porcelain Industry Co. Ltd. B698 Shenzhen SMF Investment Co., Ltd B699 Shenzhen Tao Hui Industrial Co., Ltd. B700 Shenzhen Topchoice Industries Limited B701 Shenzhen Trueland Industrial Co., Ltd. B702 Shenzhen Universal Industrial Co., Ltd. B703 Shenzhen Zhan Peng Xiang Industrial Co., Ltd. B704 Shijiazhuang Kuangqu Huakang Porcelain Co., Ltd. B705 Shun Sheng Da Group Co., Ltd. Quanzhou Fujian B706 Stechcol Ceramic Crafts Development (Shenzhen) Co., Ltd. B707 Taiyu Ceramic Co., Ltd. Liling Hunan China B708 Tangshan Beifangcidu Ceramic Group Co., Ltd. B709 Tangshan Boyu Osseous Ceramic Co., Ltd. B710 Tangshan Chinawares Trading Co., Ltd B711 Tangshan Golden Ceramic Co., Ltd. B713 Tangshan Haigelei Fine Bone Porcelain Co., Ltd. B714 Tangshan Hengrui Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. B715 Tangshan Huamei Porcelain Co., Ltd. B716 Tangshan Huaxincheng Ceramic Products Co., Ltd. B717 Tangshan Huyuan Bone China Co., Ltd. B718 Tangshan Imperial-Hero Ceramics Co., Ltd. B719 Tangshan Jinfangyuan Bone China Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B720 Tangshan Keyhandle Ceramic Co., Ltd. B721 Tangshan Longchang Ceramics Co., Ltd. B722 Tangshan Masterwell Ceramic Co., Ltd. B723 Tangshan Shiyu Commerce Co., Ltd. B725 Tangshan Xueyan Industrial Co., Ltd. B726 Tangshan Yida Industrial Corp. B727 Tao Yuan Porcelain Factory B728 Teammann Co., Ltd. B729 The China & Hong Kong Resources Co., Ltd. B730 The Great Wall of Culture Group Holding Co., Ltd Guangdong B731 Tienshan (Handan) Tableware Co., Ltd. (‘Tienshan’) B732 Topking Industry (China) Ltd. B733 Weijian Ceramic Industrial Co., Ltd. B734 Weiye Ceramics Co., Ltd. B735 Winpat Industrial Co., Ltd. B736 Xiamen Acrobat Splendor Ceramics Co., Ltd. B737 Xiamen Johnchina Fine Polishing Tech Co., Ltd. B738 Xiangqiang Ceramic Manufacturing Co., Ltd. Liling City Hunan B739 Xin Xing Xian XinJiang Pottery Co., Ltd. B740 Xinhua County Huayang Porcelain Co., Ltd. B741 Yangjiang Shi Ba Zi Kitchen Ware Manufacturing Co., Ltd. B743 Yanling Hongyi Import N Export Trade Co., Ltd. B744 Ying-Hai (Shenzhen) Industry Dev. Co., Ltd. B745 Yiyang Red Star Ceramics Ltd. B746 China Yong Feng Yuan Co., Ltd. B747 Yongchun Dahui Crafts Co., Ltd. B748 Yu Yuan Ceramics Co., Ltd. B749 Yuzhou City Kongjia Porcelain Co., Ltd. B750 Zeal Ceramics Development Co., Ltd, Shenzhen, China B753 Zhangjiakou Xuanhua Yici Ceramics Co., Ltd. (‘Xuanhua Yici’) B754 Zhejiang Nansong Ceramics Co., Ltd. B755 Zibo Boshan Shantou Ceramic Factory B756 Zibo CAC Chinaware Co., Ltd. B757 Zibo Fortune Light Industrial Products Co., Ltd. B758 Zibo GaoDe Ceramic Technology & Development Co., Ltd. B760 Zibo Hongda Ceramics Co., Ltd. B761 Zibo Jinxin Light Industrial Products Co., Ltd. B762 Zibo Kunyang Ceramic Corporation Limited B763 Liling Xinyi Ceramics Industry Ltd. B957 Gemmi (Shantou) Industrial Co., Ltd. B958 Jing He Ceramics Co., Ltd B959 Fujian Dehua Huamao Ceramics Co., Ltd C303 Fujian Dehua Jiawei Ceramics Co., Ltd C304 Fujian Dehua New Qili Arts Co., Ltd C305 Quanzhou Dehua Hengfeng Ceramics Co., Ltd C306 Fujian Dehua Sanfeng Ceramics Co. Ltd C485 Huatai Ceramics Industry Limited, Hunan, China and Kerun Ceramics Manufactory Ltd. C551 Hunan Huazhi Ceramic Co., Ltd. C550 Liling Yuanmei Ceramic Co., Ltd. C556 Hunan Legend Porcelain Industry Co., Ltd. C608 Liling Taichang Ceramics Co., Ltd C685 Hunan Jewelmoon Ceramics Co., Ltd C764 Raoping Jinde Ceramics Co. Ltd C879 Linyi Hongshun Porcelain Co., Ltd 899C Fujian Dehua Longnan Ceramics Co., Ltd 899D Shenzhen M&G Ceramics Co., Ltd. C932 Chaozhou Jingmei Craft Products Co., Ltd. C933